With how strong the vitriol for this film is, I am going to come across as an apologist for it. I did not like this movie. Giving it 5/10 does not mean I liked it, it means the good and the bad canceled each other out.
There are many reasons to like this movie. There is some witty dialog, despite what the overwhelming majority say, and Ben Affleck minus some of his horrid flirting scenes is completely serviceable in this film. I think it was lost on some people that this is a comedy, and much of the comedy in this movie is derived from watching Ben Affleck's character be put in awkward and strange situations. The most obvious example of this is the morgue scene where he needs to get a finger, and only has a cheap plastic knife at his disposal, while also having to babysit a mentally ill hostage. Christopher Walken has a great wacky Walken scene in this movie that if you took in any way other than comedy, you did it wrong. I almost recommend the movie for the scene with Al Pacino alone. He may be playing a caricature of previous roles he has done, but he does it oh so well.
Now, the bad. Yes, quite a bit of the dialog is drawn out and sub par, especially between Affleck and Lopez. There are several lines in the movie that I would say are worthy of being enshrined in the terrible dialog hall of shame. I would say that the mental illness humor probably wasn't as big of a hit as the script hopes for, because there is a lot of it. I would say that if the viewer cannot stand Ben Affleck, or does not like situational humor that Gigli finds himself in, this movie can turn into an unfunny comedy. And trust me, I understand that not much is worse than an unfunny comedy.
Thankfully the humor in this movie worked enough for me that I got through the movie without hating it, and if it was 10 or 15 minutes shorter, I probably would have given it a 6. I wouldn't recommend the movie as a whole, but I would definitely recommend the Al Pacino scene by itself. If this is the worst movie you have ever seen, you haven't seen enough movies.
There are many reasons to like this movie. There is some witty dialog, despite what the overwhelming majority say, and Ben Affleck minus some of his horrid flirting scenes is completely serviceable in this film. I think it was lost on some people that this is a comedy, and much of the comedy in this movie is derived from watching Ben Affleck's character be put in awkward and strange situations. The most obvious example of this is the morgue scene where he needs to get a finger, and only has a cheap plastic knife at his disposal, while also having to babysit a mentally ill hostage. Christopher Walken has a great wacky Walken scene in this movie that if you took in any way other than comedy, you did it wrong. I almost recommend the movie for the scene with Al Pacino alone. He may be playing a caricature of previous roles he has done, but he does it oh so well.
Now, the bad. Yes, quite a bit of the dialog is drawn out and sub par, especially between Affleck and Lopez. There are several lines in the movie that I would say are worthy of being enshrined in the terrible dialog hall of shame. I would say that the mental illness humor probably wasn't as big of a hit as the script hopes for, because there is a lot of it. I would say that if the viewer cannot stand Ben Affleck, or does not like situational humor that Gigli finds himself in, this movie can turn into an unfunny comedy. And trust me, I understand that not much is worse than an unfunny comedy.
Thankfully the humor in this movie worked enough for me that I got through the movie without hating it, and if it was 10 or 15 minutes shorter, I probably would have given it a 6. I wouldn't recommend the movie as a whole, but I would definitely recommend the Al Pacino scene by itself. If this is the worst movie you have ever seen, you haven't seen enough movies.
Tell Your Friends