I'm a sucker for period pieces, so the entire Julia Child side of the movie and the fact that it takes place in Europe is the selling feature for me. I have been watching Julia Child cook on TV for as long as I can remember. Her bio is intriguing and, while watching the movie, you tend to forget that it is actually Meryl Streep acting and not the real thing! Ms. Streep carries this movie -- there is no doubt about it! She has the accent and mannerisms of Ms. Child down pat! :D Stanley Tucci is fabulous as Paul Child also! :D
On the opposite end, the Julie Powell side of the movie touches my heart from the 9-11 point of view, as I was working in Manhattan at that time and I am well aware of the thought processes of most of the citizens during that time. Finding themselves, searching for meaning -- re-births galore! Her blog/challenge is totally understandable as it was also the height of the internet and the DOT com companies.
I have watched this movie at least 20 times and the one major thing that I cannot stand is the character of Eric Powell -- not to be confused with the wonderful actor, Chris Messina, who portrayed him. The director/writers are to blame for his over-the-top character flaws, which Chris portrayed brilliantly! Almost too much so. What were they thinking? Why didn't the director pull him back? Being a female, she must have a dozen ankle biters, Hell's Angels biker gang, pygmies, cannibals, acid metal rock groups, hyenas and toothless hillbillies in her home at any given time because she is obviously not offended by an adult male inhaling food like a caveman and talking with his mouth full! I find this extremely disgusting, probably because Chris acts the part over the top with his gulping, yumming, groaning and mumbling with every mouthfull. He actually has the perfect lips/mouth to do it -- perfect vaccuum shaped! He could sweep a pie-eating contest hands down! LOL
Also, they cruelly made this guy out to be extremely insensitive and self-centered -- I certainly hope the real-life Eric is not that way! The scene when they just moved into their apt and Julie is unpacking the kitchen and he is batting socks with a tennis racket -- was this for real? He immediately joined the ranks of useless men worldwide.
One of the most important scenes -- when Julie's distinguished dinner guest cancelled -- Eric was heartless -- right after they discussed the possibility of a $100,000 advance for a possible publishing! That is some serious bucks and all he cared about was 'more stew for us' while he continued to stuff his pie hole before leaving her! Not to mention the guest alone was a huge honor for this epic task and long-distance time-travelling relationship that Julie took on with Julia! This extremely important dinner plan falling apart -- especially after burning the dinner the night before and Julie having to call in sick to try to make it work a second time was a HUGE setback! If Eric was a supportive husband there should have been an immediate Plan B to pack up the meal, hail a cab, and take everything to Judith Jones for the interview! Even if it wasn't true, they could have made Eric out to be a better man than that! If it was true -- I would have divorced his sorry ass! LOL
They did give Eric some credit at the end when he was consoling Julie after she heard from an interviewer of Julia Child on her birthday that she was not too impressed with Julie's blog. I have to give them kudos on that scene! He was written very sweet at that point -- no food in his mouth either! LOL
Finally, a year of hard work, sacrifice and revelation ends with a pilgrimage to the Smithsonian Museum in DC to see the Julia Child kitchen. But the characters only breezed through the exhibit in less than 2 minutes and, although Julie presented a pound of butter, she didn't even sign the Guest Book!
This would have been a great time to go over some interesting details of Julia Child's life rather than just a single sentence at the end of the movie. The fact that they dared to end the movie with the line "her's was made into a movie" -- making it seem like Julie Powell's life/book was more significant than Julia Child's, is just plain annoying! Talk about disrespectful! Get over yourself, Julie!
I enjoy this movie for the bio of Julia Child, the romance of Europe, the joy of cooking (no pun intended), the remembrance of 9-11, and the love and respect of great acting by Meryl Streep!
Without criticizing the actors, Amy Adams and Chris Messina, I'm not too impressed with the Powells, whether the details of their stroy is true or not!
1 out of 2 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends