This movie has its merits. It's good campy fun, and director Ronny Yu gives us some visuals that are extremely cool to watch at. Any flick that features Jason going up in flames, walking through a corn field, slashing ravers with his machete is fine with me.
But seriously, at times Yu manages to make this camp fest look awesome. There's a fight scene close to the end where Jason and Freddy beat the crap out of each other at a construction side by night which is hilarious and almost iconic.
The movie knows what it is, never takes itself too seriously, gives fans of the genre a better time than most of the predecessors of both franchises.
The plot (Freddy is almost forgotten by people so he sends Jason to Elm Street hoping that people will think that Jason's rampage is Freddy's work so he can nourish on their fear) is ludicrous but as good as the set up allows it to be.
Nevertheless, even from a movie like this it's not too much to ask for some coherence within itself and within the franchises. From that point of you, much can be held against it.
First of all, Freddy slays teenagers, he doesn't kill adults. (He does so in Part 7: Freddy's New Nightmare, but that movie was meant rather as a satire than a legit part of the mythology). But there's a crucial back story in FvJ that sees Freddy kill the mother of one protagonist – clearly a violation of the Nightmare-myth.
When Freddy enters the teenager's dreams, they are asleep. They don't actually walk around doing stuff, they are lying somewhere, sleeping. Funnily enough, at the convenience of the plot, sometimes they're actually doing what they're doing in their dreams, and sometimes – if it's not convenient for the plot - they don't. (Consider the scene where Freeburg is spilling the hypnocil, clearly a dream sequence, but he's actually doing it).
So two teenagers had dreams of a man in a hat. Another man with a hockey mask and a machete just went berserk at a rave party. Based on that information, would you be able to conclude that one undead serial killer magically resurrected another undead serial killer in order for the second one to pave the first one's way into the teenager's dreams where he's powerful enough to kill them (which of course is exactly what has happened)? No? Well, the dumbest kids on earth draw that conclusion within minutes.
They are also able to act upon facts they can't possibly know. Consider the scene where Lori and Will hurry to Mark's house. How do they know he's having a nightmare in that very moment? By the way, I can only imagine but if Freddy murdered my family, I was committed to a psychiatric institution and broke out one day, I guess I wouldn't have the keys to my family's house which is still there with all the old furniture even though no one has been living there for at least four years.
Some fight scenes, as hilarious as they are, don't make sense in a physical way. Sometimes they couldn't decide whether one person was standing up or lying down. The distance between two spots can obviously vary. It takes them a minute to go from A to B, but only seconds to be back. Of course you can blame it all on bad editing, but somehow I don't think that it's that.
However, in spite of all these flaws, I've watched the film 20 times and it still entertains. I would love a sequel, but I don't think it's going to happen.
1 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends