Top-ratedS5.E1 ∙ The Eerie Case Of The WatcherFri, Mar 22, 2019Who was the Broaddus family's mysterious stalker at 657 Boulevard? Ryan and Shane investigate.8.7/10 (74)Rate
S5.E2 ∙ The Unusual Australian Shark Arm MurdersFri, Mar 29, 2019Ryan and Shane dive deep into a wacky case involving a shark, a speedboat, and a mysterious severed arm.7.6/10 (55)Rate
S5.E3 ∙ The Suspicious Case of the Reykjavik ConfessionsFri, Apr 5, 2019Ryan and Shane discuss the baffling Reykjavik Confessions. The details are simply suspicious.7.8/10 (55)Rate
S5.E4 ∙ The Unexplained Murder of Mobster Bugsy SiegelFri, Apr 12, 2019Ryan and Shane talk Mobsters. Mainly Bugsy Siegal and his death and who killed him.7.6/10 (57)Rate
S5.E5 ∙ The Horrifying Texarkana Phantom KillerFri, Apr 19, 2019Ryan and Shane look over the details of the Texarkana Phantom Killings. And who the killer might or might not be.8.1/10 (56)Rate
S5.E6 ∙ The Shocking Florida Machete MurderFri, Apr 26, 2019Ryan and Shane discuss the Florida Machete Murders with all the shocking details intact.7.9/10 (56)Rate
S5.E7 ∙ The Puzzling Disappearance of Walter CollinsFri, May 3, 2019Ryan and Shane talk about the disappearance of Walter Collins. A 90+ year old case about a 9-year old boy who disappeared on his way to the movies.8.1/10 (54)Rate
S5.E8 ∙ The Curious Death of Vincent Van GoghFri, May 10, 2019Ryan and Shane revisit the death of famed artist Vincent Van Gogh. Long accepted as a suicide - but was it? Were his words covering up a grievous mistake by another party?8.1/10 (59)Rate
S5.E9 ∙ The Impossible Disappearance of Dorothy ArnoldThu, Sep 26, 2019Ryan and Shane examine the 100-year-old case of a missing socialite.8.1/10 (39)Rate