Penguins (2012) User Reviews

Great Penguins - Poor Production

[brenttraft · 7/10 · 10 March 2014]

The Blu-ray for "Adventures of the Penguin King (2012)" has 3 discs: Standard DVD, 2D Blu-ray, and 3D Blu-ray. This is a review of the 2D Blu-ray. I do not have a 3D TV and have not seen the 3D version of the film.

First of all, this has the worst narration of any nature video I have ever seen. Tim Allen narrates from the first person from the point of view of the penguin. He tries to be comical but instead comes off as juvenile and condescending. Apparently there is a European version that has David Attenborough but that version is not included on the Blu-ray released in the U.S.

Also, the video quality is not up to the normal BBC Nature quality. The contrast is way too high and the colors don't look natural. I was able to correct it to a point by adjusting my television but I could never get it to look as good as my other BBC Nature videos.

Despite those flaws, I still am giving this a 7 rating because it does have some very good footage of King Penguins in high definition. Anyone who loves King Penguins will want to add this to their collection.

In Penguin City

[TheLittleSongbird · 6/10 · 4 November 2017]

As a fan of penguins, ever since watching the likes of 'Pingu' as a child, and documentaries (especially those from David Attenborough), missing 'Adventures of the Penguin King' was not an option.

Essentially, 'Adventures of the Penguin King' is the US version of David Attenborough's 'The Penguin King' from 2012, another reason for seeing it. While that is one of the weaker Attenborough 3D endeavours and a lesser project from him, 'The Penguin King' was still decent and is superior to 'Adventures of the Penguin King'. The main thing that makes 'Adventures of the Penguin King' inferior is the narration. The script itself is repetitive, clichéd and rambling, but it's Tim Allen's delivery of it that fares worse, it talks down to the viewer and the humorous approach is jarringly juvenile, an approach that is a very ill fit.

What didn't quite work in 'The Penguin King' is still present here too. The 3D itself is good-looking and sharp, the penguins and the rest of the animals being cute and majestic, but it never properly enhances the experience and 'The Penguin King' would have worked just as well without it (also saw the 2D version and that fared better). Again it does tread familiar ground and doesn't really say anything new.

There is also some content that was clearly included with a younger audience in mind and sadly it not only doesn't fit with the rest of the programme but it also adds nothing and distracts, making older audiences question its maturity.

On the other hand, 'Adventures of the Penguin King' is beautifully filmed, done in a completely fluid and natural, sometimes intimate (a great way of connecting more with the penguins) way and never looking static. In fact much of it is remarkably cinematic. The editing is always succinct and smooth and the scenery is spectacular.

Music score fits very well, never overly grandiose while never being inappropriate while also being a beautiful score in its own right.

Despite treading familiar ground, the information is still educational and informative to especially younger audiences, while there is some delicate pathos, a lot of charming cuteness and even moments of intensity. The story is very stitched together and has some forced and unneeded moments, but it is also very heart-warming and sweet. The penguins do look great, and are more than just 3D creations. They have personality and soul and one roots for them.

On the whole, worthwhile but the narration in particular stops it from being better. 6/10 Bethany Cox

Bad narration, ok 3d, but sad to watch

[joiningjt · 3/10 · 20 May 2020]

This is NOT for children I know it happens in nature but we dont need to see it!! It was just ho hum seen far better. Watched the 3d version it was ok nothing great but ok.

absolute classic

[jasonpbeutler · 10/10 · 23 December 2014]

Do you enjoy the Planet Earth documentary, but wish the piece's narration was a bit more colorful, perhaps livened up by one of the western world's leading comedians? Do you wish it perhaps had vivid action sequences that left you as bewildered and amazed as Transformers 3? Then Adventures of the Penguin is for you! David Attenborough directs this stunning piece of nature documentary spanning across the beaches of South Georgia (though sometimes you might think it's Hawaii!). The real standout of this film, though, is Tim Allen, in what might be his greatest role yet. Allen narrates from the first person perspective of a young king penguin named Rex. Throughout the film I found myself forgetting that it was a person telling me about penguin life, it was such a convincing portrayal of penguin thought! And it's not just a boring nature movie. It's full of intrigue, romance, heartbreak and joy. My favorite scene may be Allen's Rex saving his young penguin son from an attacking bird. Talk about suspense! If you only watch one penguin focused, celebrity narrated documentary/comedy this year, make it Adventures of the Penguin King!!!!