"CSI: NY" Today Is Life (TV Episode 2013) Poster

(TV Series)

(2013)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
What a wonderful hurt
william-c-cutting25 February 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I just finished watching this season finale and my heart literally hurts. It hurts from something so well done, something so beautiful that I couldn't help but emotionally empathize.

Synopsis: (Taken from TV.com) A group of protesters breaks into the NYPD precinct after the police are suspected of killing an unarmed man. Mac and Flack find themselves caught up in the chaos as the team makes a fast move to try and solve the case.

I can't find a credible cast list so forgive me for not being able to give proper credit to the actors involved that have guest spots.

I found myself making a very arrogant snap decision about the girl playing the fallen victims girlfriend in the beginning. She was addressing the media in the midst of an angry crowd and her delivery just felt ill paced and unfelt. Maybe that's true in that moment but by the credit role I felt ashamed to have ever formed that opinion.

Later in this episode the girlfriend was asked back into the precinct so that Mac Taylor (Gary Sinise) could explain to her what really happened and that her boyfriend was the victim of mistaken identity leading to his death. This was such a beautiful moment played so well by the subtleties of pure emotional understanding by both the girlfriend and M. Taylor. My heart broke for both of them. I don't know what was going through their heads but it was real, and it hurt. I feel such a deep admiration for what they were both willing to experience in order to make this moment what it needed to be.

Back tracking slightly Don Flack (Eddie Cahill) explained to the suspected officer why he wasn't guilty of murder but killed an innocent man. This was another scene that could have easily played as melodrama but was beautiful in the subtleties. I felt the officer's guilt, him knowing that he had done the right thing but still was the hand that ended a good and undeserving man's life. Brilliant moment.

There are so many talented people on this show lead by Garry Sinise but I have to commend the brevity of them closing with two relatively unknown actors in such powerful roles. This is the type of spark that fuels emotional inspiration.

And the closing was just very simple love. The kind of love that let's you know everything will be all right, that bad things happen but we will endure and we won't do it alone. And in the final moment we see why Garry Sinise is so brilliant. Not because he's an amazing actor, but because he make us forget that he's an actor at all.

Will Cutting
29 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A touching end for a great series
redmaxdrive2 July 2013
Warning: Spoilers
CSI: New York is one of those shows where you come to care for the characters not just because of the work they do, but also because you can identify with many of the situations they deal with in their personal lives.

This episode touched on a few tender spots that everyone has: grief, loss, distrust of government and law enforcement, and pointless death. I could feel the protesters' anger over the death of an innocent man and the girlfriend's grief over losing her boyfriend. It was only through Mac's determination and gentle nature that the truth was heard and relayed to the public.

The moment at the end where Mac proposes to Christine had me tearing up; that's how touching it was. And it occurred to me that if the series was to be canceled after this episode, then at least it would end on a high note. It saddened me to learn that it was indeed the final episode, but I take some comfort in that I guessed right about it. This is one of the finest episodes of any TV show I've ever seen, and I certainly couldn't think of a better way for it to go out.
27 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
5+ stars
jkarmas-158-37000412 November 2014
This episode was an awesome finale to an awesome show. This series was my favorite of the CSI family of dramas. Well plotted, acted and delivered. The creative minds always kept the plots in line with real-life issues yet kept me guessing on who done it. It is greatly missed in my weekly TV viewing line-up. It's also very creepy that in a little more than a year later life imitates art and we witness the real life story in Ferguson, Missouri. Bravo to the cast of CSI New York. It's Curious to me the network could not find one more sponsor to keep this show running. Just how many viewers do you need to keep a series running? Perhaps it's not too late for another network to pick it up...? Thanks for the many years of entertainment.
30 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Disappointing series finale
LoveIsAStateOfMind29 December 2015
Warning: Spoilers
As a season finale it was moderate to poor, as a series finale it was poor and disappointing but as an episode it was …. okay. Don't get me wrong, I understand why the writers went with this sort of finale rather than a high intense action-packed episode which usually ends with a cliffhanger, but I wish they hadn't chosen this episode to have the focus on the perps + officer involved in the shooting etc. rather than spending the screen time on the CSI team, even if it was just seeing them in the lab processing evidence.

I thought it was melodramatic and whilst I felt for the poor girlfriend of the victim, I thought it would have been better if they had left it with the scenes between her and Mac in the precinct or if we heard the start of her speech to the mob outside and then it fade to mute. We are an intelligence audience, we don't need her to spell it out to us that the officer was innocent and it was all a case of bad timing and bad luck.

Although I thought Mac's voice-over was also too cheesy and unnecessary, I loved the scene with the gang on the rooftop and the acknowledgement of Sid's cancer treatment, Danny/Lindsay snuggling etc. And finally the proposal was perfect and I'm happy for Mac.
6 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed