Overall it's ok, sure there is a lot to improve but it's already much better than Picard & Star Trek Discovery actually STD and ST: Picard is nowhere near as good as Stat Trek Prodigy thats why i am ratingsit high becuse it doesnt insult me or make me mad !Characters are likable - I like that their strengths and weaknesses are shown bit by bit, unlike other NuTrek shows they all work together giving a helping hand, unlike STD where Saint Archangel Mickey Spock Bhurham is the savior of the galaxy every season sheding buckets of tears...! We don't know charactertheir past and background but it's not like in Discovery they show all kinda cool aliens, cyborgs in the background and never do anything with them, except killed off robot lady and make an episode about her - it failed because viewers weren't attached to her if she had previously been shown more and interacting with the crew!
4 Reviews
This series is pretty good
batmanforever-9324918 November 2021
This series manages to keep my interest very high. Prodigy is a pretty good Sci-fi series and even a very good Star Trek show,excepting the fact it hasn't any kind of alien race which can be recognized by the fans ,unfortunately. Well ,finally ,the secret of the ship is revealed.
A Senior Trekker writes.................
celineduchain18 November 2021
I'm sure that before long, others will give this the high scores that it probably deserves but I will be sticking with my neutral rating for the time being. This episode wraps up the two-parter that tells the story of the crew's first planetfall. Predictable? Well, yes of course, but nicely executed. For sure. I don't think Gene Roddenberry would have been disappointed with either the storytelling or the values expressed.
Terrible episode full of plot holes!
goggolya18 November 2021
This episode had so many plot holes and inconsistencies it was painful to watch!
This show has zero quality control.
It's clear as day that this series is written by people who never saw a Star Trek episode in their entire life!
This show has zero quality control.
- Why did the crew forget they have phasers to stop the vines from taking their vehicle?
- They have a GPS and need to go to a beacon. But somehow they keep going in circles which should be impossible when they have navigational equipment.
- Why is there a Klingon ship on the planet? And why are the people living in the delta quadrant familiar with species that lives very far away in the beta quadrant?
- Why does Jankom Pog take off his space suit mid episode when he states multiple times that he doesn't feel safe without it? Quote from Game of Thrones writers: "He kinda forgot."
- Why don't they ask the holo Janeway to beam them up to the ship? The bad guys can use the transporter. Why can't the good guys use it? Extremely bad writing!!!
- How does Gwyn know that her father was going to the ship when it was stated in previous episode that everyone has a different hallucination and they can't see each others? Terrible writing again...
- Why does the sensors say "lifeforms detected nearby" when the kids have their com badges on them and the ship can identify them with it?
It's clear as day that this series is written by people who never saw a Star Trek episode in their entire life!
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
