"Tales of the Unexpected" The Surgeon (TV Episode 1988) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A lighthearted, clever, intriguing mystery.
Sleepin_Dragon22 February 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Mr Robert Sandy is a hugely capable Surgeon, proud to be part of the NHS, he performs a routine operation on the hugely wealthy Prince Zawi, after he's been smashed up in an accident. Zawi tries to give a fee to Sandy, who refuses, instead he gifts him a fabulous diamond. Robert takes the stone to jeweller Harry Gold, who explains it's hugely valuable. Having something of such value scares Robert and his wife Betty, so he sets about hiding it in a safe place. The couple head out, but discover they've been robbed. The couple have to explain the diamond story to the Police.

Cambridge makes for a great setting, it's as always a very classy backdrop. The buildings, the river, the bikes, it's a cracking combination.

John Alderton's great in it, a cracking performance from him, it has been some eight years since he appeared in the episode Georgy Porgy.

A baffling, intriguing and deliciously clever episode, one that will keep you guessing til the very last, I've watched this for the first time to review it, and I had no idea which way it was going to go, Series 9 on the whole is proving to be of a rather high standard.

7/10
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Gentle, light hearted but fun episode!
omendata1 March 2021
Tales Of The Unexpected are usually gruesome or have a seedy ending but this was a rather light-hearted and fun episode; with excellent performances it is one of the better episodes.

This final season 9 seems to be the best of the entire series so far as I have been making my way slowly through every episode now on Sky Arts+ channel re-runs from the first episode of the first series to the last of this series and it has been a wonderful travel back in time to my favourite gentle era of the 70's and 80's where explicit violence, swearing and nudity was not necessary to make a great series or movie, where actors were truly great and this episode exemplifies all that was "good" about the "good old days"!
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Decent Tales of the Unexpected episode.
poolandrews26 May 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Tales of the Unexpected: The Surgeon is set in Cambridge as a rich prince named Zawi (Raad Rawi) gives the surgeon Robert Sandy (John Alderton) who saved his life a large diamond as a gift. Sandy accepts the diamond & takes it to Harry Gold (Thorley Walters) a jeweller who says it could be worth up to a half a million pounds. Obviously excited by the news Robert tells his wife Betty (Allison Fiske) & they begin to make plans in regard to what they're going to do with the money once they sell it, Robert decides to hide the diamond in case they are burgled which actually happens that very night. Was Robert's hiding place good & clever enough to prevent it from being stolen?

This Tales of the Unexpected story was episode 3 from season 9 & originally aired here in the UK during January 1988, the seventh of seven Tales of the Unexpected episodes to be directed by Graham Evans this is an OK time waster but like most of the stories from this show nothing that special. The story by Roald Dahl was dramatised by Robin Chapman & unlike many of this show's latter stories it's a watchable way to pass 25 odd minutes but little else, the show went downhill after Dahl's involvement ceased but in taking one of his stories The Surgeon is at least quite fun if slight entertainment. Personally I think anyone familiar with the series & the way it's stories generally pan out will not have a great deal of trouble predicting how The Surgeon will end, it's relatively predictable & simplistic storytelling & considering the standard of season 9 I'm in no way surprised Tales of the Unexpected didn't return for season 10...

This one looks alright, the low TV budget obviously doesn't help & while it looks cheap it's generally well made I suppose. On a personal level I would have just kept the diamond in my pocket rather than try to be too clever, I mean then it would have been close to me at all times & I could actually psychically touch it & hold it just to reassure myself as opposed to a silly hiding place which was never going to totally safe. As usual another fine British cast of familiar TV faces turn up.

The Surgeon is an adequate time waster if you have nothing else to do but it lacks any real punch, it's more than a tad predictable & at the end of the day utterly forgettable.
2 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed