"Rumpole of the Bailey" Rumpole and the Golden Thread (TV Episode 1983) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Rumpole and the Golden Thread
Prismark109 November 2019
You remember the quote from Life of Brian: "All right, but apart from the sanitation, the medicine, education, wine, public order, irrigation, roads, a fresh water system, and public health, what have the Romans ever done for us?"

By the same token the British love to remind everyone of all the things they bought to their colonies. Culture, education, roads, railways, sanitation and the common law legal system.

However as one Indian critic said. The modern British government likes to criticise the Indian government about our laws against homosexuality. Before the British invaders arrived there were no laws against homosexuality. It was introduced by the British. Now they tell us off for having their laws.

This is something Rumpole learns as he arrives in Phillida. A country in Africa that used to be a British colony. Think Zimbabwe. He is defending a former student David Mazenze who rose to be a prominent politician. He is accused of murdering a bishop and had publicly stated that he would kill him. The prime minister of Phillida would like to see the back of David Mazenze. It is a country of tribal divisions.

Rumpole learns that David faces the death penalty and the trial is by the judge alone. It was the British who abolished trial by jury for murder. Rumpole soon finds out that the Judge is in no mood for Rumpole's games and he has done some homework on Rumpole. On the other hand, Rumpole concurs with David that the judge might be in the pocket of the prime minister.

The case against David looks weak. The whole state apparatus is apparently against him and Rumpole. Yet David requested Rumpole because of the way he deals with a jury, the way he talks about the law. Rumpole finds out he is a patsy. He is a tool in some complex political manoeuvres.

I did like Rumpole goes to Africa. It rather seems John Mortimer might have had a similar experience. A British legal system in foreign lands. The laws might be unjust, yet the judge, barristers and the police all had some some training in the UK.

There is a lot of humour here. The police tell Rumpole that David Mazenze is chained to the walls as he arrives to see David. In fact his cell is a luxurious room with plenty of wine and a record player.

Once again Rumpole shows his experience and cunning. He has his own games to play.

What does let the episode down is the production. It is obvious that this was all shot in Britain. The customs office of Phillida looks like a college canteen. There is even a cola machine. I never got a colonial feeling in any of the sets.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Rumpole in Africa
sjdrake20068 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
An interesting episode and one of only two I recall where Rumpole is abroad, the other being 'Bright Seraphim' where is with the British Army of the Rhine in Germany, but effectively its a British setting.

Here it's different. This is ex-British colonial Africa and whilst there are naturally budget constraints, I felt they did a pretty good job in conveying the ethos in the circumstances.

As ever, the story and Courtroom drama is riveting, though this time we don't really get the A-B storyline which takes place in most episodes. (The only hint of B storyline is that Dodo Macintosh is coming to stay with the Rumpoles so he's glad to go - only to find she's still waiting for him when he gets back!)

Rumpole must defend an old pupil in the state of Naranga, where his pupil is now a leader of a tribal division which is bitterly at odds with the ruling tribe. He is charged with murdering a Bishop. A death sentence is on the cards, so for Rumpole the stakes are higher than just keeping his client out of chokey.

The case itself is in my opinion, one of Rumpole's worst showings (I mean the character, not the ever-brilliant actor). He heads across with what seems like little preparation but an oft-repeated desire to show the locals just how wonderful is the 'Golden thread of British Justice' as if they haven't a clue what 'innocent until proven guilty' means.

In fact the local judiciary is extremely 'British' and well prepared and the Judge - no Jury here, courtesy of Britain - has done his homework on Rumpole, comparing him unfavourably with his late Father-in-Law!

Rumpole proceeds to give his usual Old Bailey performance, sniffing out the evidence to gain an acquittal for his client. Unfortunately he either doesn't communicate with his client at all or simply ignores his requests; his client is convinced that if found guilty he will be released from an already-light house arrest by armed uprising.

Rumpole ignores this to unleash evidence that his client is innocent by virtue of a second marriage to a member of the opposition clan.

Rumpole celebrates victory, but his released client is slain in short order by his horrified supporters and the Government makes it clear that the Master Barrister has been manipulated throughout to dispose of a very dangerous (to them) dissident and opposition, which is now riven and leaderless instead of facing imminent overthrow.

Not one of Rumpole's great moments - and just to add insult to injury he is arrested but finally released home to deal with a case in the Bailey. His failure to factor the local politics into the equation was in the end, fatal to his client.

The Judge and suave opposing barrister were wonderfully played with conviction.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Travels Rumpole East away?
lucyrf5 June 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Or is he taking a caravan to Samarkand? Just as he awaits the arrival of the dreaded Dodo Mackintosh, he gets a call from Justitia international, represented by a flaky lady in a hat who seems to have a feeble grasp of the facts. But somebody is in jail in a Central African country and has called for Rumpole - being a former student, now a government figure in the made-up country.

Rumpole sets off with a linen suit and mosquito net. Africa is mocked up on unmade-up sandy roads and pancake-like 70s cars. Many distinguished black actors (and James Villiers) play a part. The country has abolished jury trial, while retaining British judicial robes and barristers' wigs.

The country's rebellious citizens are less successfully impersonated by a small chanting crowd on the steps of what's probably a provincial English town hall. Several actors shine, apart from McKern, Peggy Thorpe-Bates and Villiers.

The stern judge, in particular, impersonated by Errol John. It's no surprise to find that he once played Othello. And Christopher Asante as the elegant prosecution council ("Old fellow!") with the long cigarette holder. The perpetually smiling solicitor. Are they just another set of stereotypes - more subtle than the usual? You decide.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Zimabwe 2020?
mike-rook26 February 2020
As an ex-Zimbabwean I found this edition of Rumpole brilliantly entertaining.and the character portrayals not entirely inaccurate.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed