The first 3 seasons of Babylon are among my favorite Sci-Fi ever made. I've rewatched multiple times. Despite a slow start and weaker and filler episodes mixed in, those seasons struck a balance of well-acted true thought provoking futurist science fiction, wonder, mystery, intrigue, drama, literary allusion, historical and social allegory, suspense, action, adventure, and character study. You realize from the first episode the bar has been raised - no shields, no teleports, no matter replicators, no androids. This is humanity itself and aliens representative of past and present human factions projected forward 250 plus years. Season 2's Coming Of The Shadows is the crowning achievement melding these themes together. Yet, rewatching recently, Babylon 5 is clearly a show with obvious shortcomings overlooked due to it's reputation as ground breaking for its "5 year story" compared to highly episodic shows of its era.
It starts to unravel in season 3 when Kosh is killed taking the mystery/wonder aspect with him. Stories become harder to suspend disbelief for with more reliance on plot contrivances and characters acting unexpectedly. This coincides with a general slide into the dreaded "space opera" motif, often nothing more than common military drama masquerading as sci-fi because it takes place in space/the future. Thoughtful interplay with characters and storytelling seem overtaken by CGI space battles with a detached video game feel (in contemporary quotes, the creator spoke often about number of effects shots, as if that were a measure of good storytelling or watchability)
Credulity slips further with the season 3 ending reveal of the Shadow homeworld. We learn the Shadows have made a 1980's background extra their key human liason, with no explanation of his origin or importance other than a flashback to a prior terrible film-school caliber inscrutable dream sequence. Soon thereafter early in Season 4 a badly costumed alien wearing jewelry is revealed as the first ever ageless living being.
This slide reaches its low point in this episode "Into The Fire", in which a 3 year build up to an epic galactic war through time foretold by prophecies of multiple species ends abruptly with Bruce Boxleitner, in his quest to win the award for most scenery chewed in a season, yelling at two races of nearly ominpotent aliens to get off his lawn. Naturally they go meekly on their way without a fight. But not before the Vorlons, previously portrayed as semi-formless angelic awe-inspiring light beings in one of the show's defining moments, are now presented as a common lifeless ceremonially garbed humanoid female, perhaps because they couldn't afford the CGI anymore. Or the cringe worthy moment of a demonic looking Shadow whimpering for it's quasi-parent alien to come along. And with that the epic mythological Chaos vs. Order struggle setup over the previous 60 plus episodes is all but forgotten.
Thee show still has its moments but when you slowly build to something for 3 years then wipe it away in one swoop its difficult for viewers to remain invested in what comes next.
3 out of 5 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink