Towar (2006) Poster

(2006)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
1/10
Amateurs, and it shows
Krasnoludek8 April 2009
This film was done on a small budget and with actors that were clearly nonprofessional and probably just friends of the filmmakers. That alone does not condemn a movie to being bad; in fact, quite a few great movies came about in that kind of a setting (e.g. "Night of the Living Dead"). What matters is the story and the skill with which the filmmakers transform their simple surroundings into something interesting. Unfortunately, you don't get that in Towar.

The story deals with some petty criminals involved in sex trafficking and theft. They pose and act tough and try to have witty conversations in the chatty style of Quentin Tarantino or similar filmmakers with a preference for criminals. These depictions of the criminals all come across as individual imitations of other films strung together with little direction or attention to keeping audience interest. In imitating, the filmmakers tried to mimic physical executions of the scenes, thinking that would evoke the qualities they liked. But they failed to observe the purpose of adjacent scenes in these other films, which were important for setting mood, character development, tension, etc.

The camera-work and editing follow a similar sequence of flaws. Many initial shots in the scenes were clearly set up in imitation of shots from popular films (e.g. low angle shot of a car pulling up, stopping right in front of the camera), but the interesting camera angles don't persist past this initial conceit in the scene. Another imitation came through the use of CGI to zoom from one shot to another, which served no purpose other than to show off someone's graphics skills. And please, somebody inform these filmmakers that there are other ways to transition between scenes than a fade to black!

All together it's a poorly executed storyline by people who know which scenes they like in movies but don't understand why they like them. There's no horribly obvious flaws here, yet the movie still fails miserably at keeping the audience interested. The film collapses under the cumulative weight of the multiple amateurish mistakes. The inexperience shows through the inability to keep pacing or create any tension or cohesion. Best avoid this film.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This screenplay could well have been taken on by Quentin Tarantino or Guy Ritchie
geffen22 April 2005
Great story filmed on "zero" budget, yet keeping you so hooked by multiple plots, and so fast paced that I had no time to use the toilet at the cinema (which I usually do).I remember seeing the first feature by Abelard Giza "Wozonko" (Wannaride), I found it average, to say the least. Seeing how young writer/director progresses in "Towar", I wonder where his next movie is going to end up...? Academy Awards nominee? "Towar" (Stock) so far has been awarded at "Oskariada 2005" in Poland as second runner up for the best feature. The screenplay was also nominated to next year's edition of the festival by Jan Machulski himself.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed