My Heart Belongs to Daddy (1942) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Cecil Kellaway Owns This Programmer
boblipton23 June 2019
Cecil Kellaway is driving Martha O'Driscoll to the hospital to have her baby. The taxi gets caught in a snowdrift and they take shelter in the home of widowed Nobel Prize laureate (Physics) Richard Carlson. The physician says she can't be moved, so there she rests, much to the anger of two sets of in-laws: her snobby in-laws who want the baby taken from his ex-bubble-dancer mother; and his in-laws, Florence and her daughter, Frances Gifford, whom they have been scheming since the funeral to marry Carlson.

It's a slight comedy, nothing compared to stronger works like BALL OF FIRE, but then, it's all B talent in front of and behind the camera, except for two. As it chugs its way soddenly through its rote plot, Kellaway, who seems to have been every man in his time, is the single shining bright spot -- although if you wanted a malicious harpy for a comedy, you couldn't do much better than Florence Bates. Despite their efforts, it's a programmer, and the couple at the core are two busy reciting their lines in character to be of much more interest than the realization that they're what this movie is supposed to be concerned with.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"This is my kitchen! Stay out!" "I wouldn't brag about that. I've seen cleaner kitchens on Tobacco Road!"
mark.waltz22 October 2016
Warning: Spoilers
I use that quote as my summary to describe the atmosphere of this screwball comedy that mixes knife thrown acidic barbs with a dramatic and sentimental set-up. Martha O'Driscoll plays a young pregnant widow fighting to prevent her in-laws from taking the child away from her. Stranded in Cecil Kellaway's cab during a snowstorm and ends up delivering her baby in the home of scientist professor Richard Carlson who has allowed his fiancée, Frances Gifford, to move in with her imperious mother, Florence Bates, and bratty sister, Velma Berg. The presence of feisty, no-nonsense nurse Mabel Paige, who insults everybody except O'Driscoll, Kellaway and Carlson.

It's Paige who gets to utter the insult to the temperamental cook, and it is her who pretty much steals every scene, even from the lovable Kellaway and the deliriously funny Bates. Berg gets some good lines as well, getting over excited when the staff fights with the nurse who has no reluctance in grabbing her by the ears to prevent her from nosying in on the new mother. The household set-up is pretty surprising considering the production code, but the script makes it pretty clear that nothing is going on between Carlson and Gifford in spite of being engaged. It works better that that way so the intended romance between Carlson and O'Driscoll can take off without a nasty issue of divorce or infidelity from taking place.

As for the use of the title of a popular Cole Porter song, that is never heard, and the meaning of daddy is quite different. The fact that the audience is supposed to believe that Berg is Bates' daughter is unbelievable but amusing. Gifford plays passive/aggressive very well, but it's very clear what her motives are, while Bates could have you laughing hysterically as she takes great pleasure in slamming the stereotypical shrewish mother. There's a twist involving O'Driscoll I did not see coming, making this an obscure gem that ends up being a delightful surprise.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
My Heart Belongs to Daddy
CinemaSerf20 February 2024
It's all about the spelling! "Prof. Inglethorpe" (Richard Carlson) is a renowned educator whose life is turned upside down when a pregnant woman comes to say with them. She - "Joyce" (Martha O'Dricoll) is a showgirl who is probably going to put her child up for adoption as she cannot afford to bring it up properly. Romance takes an hand though, of course, but this is where it gets a little interesting. He likes her and she likes him, but "Mrs. Saunders" (Florence Bates) has designs on the man for her daughter "Grace" (Frances Gifford) and so starts to make waves. Some of these waves prove big enough to drive the new mother from their home and him on a track for the wrong nuptials. Fortunately, he has a sort of fairy godfather figure in his life. The scene stealing Cecil Kellaway ("Alfred") is on hand to prod him in the right direction and try to pluck triumph from disaster. There's nothing really very original here, but that wouldn't have mattered so much had there been some chemistry on screen. There isn't. Though O'Driscoll has a little more scope with her character, the Gifford/Bates double act - augmented (?) by the younger "Babs" (Velma Berg) - is just over-played, and Carlson is nowhere near his best with this rather shallow role. It's watchable enough, but I doubt I will ever remember it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed