Arkansas Judge (1941) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Thou Shalt not bear false witness
bkoganbing12 June 2013
I once wrote to Roy Rogers, Jr. about his dad's credits in the Weaver Family films at Republic and what he told me was that like all the other studio bosses Herbert J. Yates believed in keeping his contract players working. Even though by 1941 Roy Rogers was a full fledged film star he still got cast in support of the Weaver Family in Arkansas Judge. As befit his star status though he was billed first in the supporting cast.

The Weaver Family was just that three performers related to each other named Weaver who did essentially hillbilly music and were stars of the Grand Old Opry at the time. They did a few films for Republic at the time which were popular in what would become the red states. Leon Weaver plays a town judge who likes to cut back occasionally and do some jamming with the family.

His part was something that other Rogers named Will could have done had he lived. Weaver has worked hard to keep his valley both peaceful and harmonious. But war clouds descend when Eily Mahlon accuses poor widow Spring Byington of the theft of $50.00 she had hidden in her flour barrel. She has no proof mind you, but a weak circumstantial case.

Weaver is all for living and let living, but town banker Frank M. Thomas has his own reasons for wanting the blame to fall on Byington. It all gets quite ugly before the truth is learned.

As for Roy he is caught between two women, Pauline Moore and Veda Ann Borg. He gets to be in courtroom scene as a lawyer defending Leon Weaver from a slander suit brought by Thomas. It's every actor's dream and he fulfilled it. He also has one song to sing Peaceful Valley as most of the musical numbers were for the Weaver Family. Roy doesn't have that many scenes, but he makes what he has count.

Arkansas Judge coming from Republic Pictures doesn't have the touches and production values from a major studio. I wasn't expecting much, but I was pleasantly surprised in that this film was a powerful indictment against gossip and slander. And Spring Byington gets the accolades for best performance. She is quite touching as the poor, put upon widow whom the town of Peaceful Valley turns against and makes war on.

As for Roy Rogers this is a film he should be known better for.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not To My Taste, But....
boblipton19 July 2023
It's forty years since Leon Weaver found Peaceful Valley and started to clear out the stumps for what would become a prosperous farm and pleasant town. But when Eily Malyon discovers the forty dollars she has hidden in the flour barrel for decades missing, she accuses Spring Byington, who helps her clean for no pay, of stealing it. Soon, the entire town believes it, save Weaver.

Republic Pictures had a nice market for homespun movies that suited their rural audiences to a T. Not only did they have Judy Canova, but the Weaver Brothers and Elviry, who are the main draw here. Originally a musical-comedy act, Leon played the hick, who was wiser than he appeared; his brother Frank spoke only in bird whistles; and Elviry -- actually June -- was sharp-tongued and belligerent. After appearing in one movie for Warner Brothers, they were signed by Republic and made eleven films for them.

It's a pleasant little movie, with a message of compassion and thankfulness. Republic Pictures put their best foot forward, with Roy Rogers playing a lawyer with nary a sign of a horse. Pauline Moore, Veda Ann Borg, and Russell Hicks have significant roles. It's not really to my taste. I find it saccharine and obvious. But here's a case where I find it interesting, just as I do Frank Randle somewhere in England, for showing what a bygone audience liked in entertainment, and how director Frank MacDonald could turn out something that pleased them.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Roy, mostly out of the saddle here, shows he can play roles that Gene Autry couldn't.
horn-527 November 2005
Adapted from Irving Stone's novel "False Witness." Peaceful Valley town-founder, Judge Abner Weaver (Leon Weaver) is distressed when the townspeople begin gossiping and "bearing false witness'" against Mary Shoemaker (Spring Byington), the community handy-woman, who is charged with having stolen fifty dollars from Widow Smithers (Eily Malhon), and he and his wife Elviry (June Weaver)and brother Cicero (Frank Weaver)stoutly defend Mary.

The theft becomes a matter of community interest when a rumor is circulated that Hettie Huston (Veda Ann Borg), daughter of the local banker, August Houston (Frank M. Thomas), has stolen the money in order to buy an expensive evening gown with which to dazzle Tom Martel (Roy Rogers), a young lawyer whose legal education was sponsored by Judge Weaver, whose daughter Margaret (Pauline Moore) is also in love with Tom, and the young lawyer is torn between the sophisticated attractions of Hettie and the simple charm of Margaret.

In order to save his daughter's reputation, August Houston is eager to have Mary Shoemaker's guilt established and to induce her to quietly leave town. Judge Weaver (not on the bench)defends her so heatedly that Huston institutes a slander-suit against his old friend, charging him with having damaged Hettie's reputation. Ordinarly, a hard thing to do with characters played by Veda Ann Borg.

Margaret feels that inasmuch as her father has financed Tom's legal education, it is his duty to defend her father. But Tom is smitten with Hettie and proposes to her, and refuses to side against her in the trial.

As the trial proceeds, it becomes apparent that all the witnesses are testifying against Judge Weaver because Huston and his bank hold notes and mortgages on their homes and businesses. Tom can stand it no longer and determines to defend the Judge, even though it may mean breaking his engagement to Hettie, no matter how smitten he may be. When it is suggested that Judge Weaver started the rumor against Hettie because his daughter was in love with Tom and jealous of Hettie, Tom puts Margaret on the stand and asks her to refute the statement. Margaret cannot swear, under oath, that she doesn't love Tom; and, as a result of her admission of love, the case is lost. But Huston magnanimously declines to accept from Judge Weaver the judgement the court has awarded him, on condition that Mary Shoemaker be sent out of town. Judge Weaver, knowing that Mary was not the one who stole the money, declines the offer.

Meanwhile, a group of Republic's usual rabble-roused townspeople decides to run Mary out of town, whether she wants to go or not. When she doesn't respond to the clamor at her door , they decide she has already left and, just to show her how they feel about her stealing fifty bucks from Widow Smithers, they set fire to her house.

BUT, Mary is inside the house.

1. Can Tom and his unnamed horse save her? 2. Will Hettie confess? 3. Will Tom decide that Margaret might be a better choice than Hettie? 4.If so, will the citizens of Peaceful Valley mend their hen-house ways and resume their peaceful, happy lives?

Yes (I)...Yes(2)...Yes (3)...and probably not (4) to the last question unless gossipy Minerva Urecal moves out of town.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
An unusual film about a nasty little town where Roy Rogers plays a supporting role.
planktonrules3 November 2020
"Arkansas Judge" is a most unusual film. It stars the musical act 'The Weaver Brothers and Elviry' and Roy Rogers himself is there in a supporting role....which is quite unexpected since Roy was a big star by the time he appeared in this movie. I suppose Republic Studio wanted to use Roy's popularity to support the Weavers. It's also an unusual film because Rogers is not playing a character named 'Roy'....which he did in the vast majority of his pictures.

The story is set in a small town that seems, at first, as a nice place to live. However, when a woman loses some money, she begins wildly accusing someone with little evidence. Soon, other folks start accusing each other. And, ultimately, it results in a newspaper article blaming someone, without any real evidence! And, through the course of this, this nice town turns out to be an awful, ugly town full of hypocrites and scum-bags. The story is obviously a story about gossiping and lying....and it's not exactly subtle.

While not at all subtle, the film isn't bad....at least until the court hearing. The hearing is possibly one of the worst written courtroom scenes I have ever seen. Most of the evidence given is hearsay....and the judge even allowed a telephone operator to testify about what she's overheard while eavesdropping on phone calls! Not only is this hearsay but also highly illegal. There also is a woman who CONTINUALLY yells out at the witnesses...but she isn't tossed out of the courtroom. But even more ridiculous is when a guy shoots a gun off in court at one of the witnesses...and the man isn't arrested!! Insane...and badly written....and it really ruins the film...at least for me.

By the way, The Weaver Brothers and Elviry first appeared in the god-awful movie "Swing Your Lady". The film was so poor that it made it to the infamous book "The Fifty Worst Movies of All Time" by Harry Medved....an amazing and clever book if you can find a copy.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
When you point the finger, you have four fingers pointing back at you.
mark.waltz30 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
What appears at first to be a harmless cornpone comedy with songs ends up being one of those hoary old melodramas where someone suffers unjustly and their tragedy ends up being felt by the entire town. It stars the Weaver Family as good-natured folks who seem to be the only ones outside heroine Spring Byington who don't beare false witness. At a community party, the obviously bitter old widow Eily Malyon storms in and accuses Byington of stealing $50 from her potted plants. Byington protests her innocence but the town still snubs her, preventing her from getting work doing their cleaning and washing. When the town's 9:00 girl can't stand any more of being in the 5:00 town, townsfolk also believe she could have done it which results in a trial for slander. Even though this is going forward, Byington becomes the town pariah even though she had previously been known as the kindest woman in the community.

What had started as a nice comedy then turned into a slice of life drama all of a sudden becomes a depressing moral lesson that is as judgmental as those placing wrong judgment on Byington and possibly Borg. Roy Rogers is the town's hero, a young singing lawyer, who makes the mistake of becoming engaged to Borg while already in love with Pauline Moore. The Weavers become the town pariahs after the court case and decide to leave town even though they had been trying to stop the gossip. A good supporting cast of familiar character actors (Minerva Urecal, Frank M. Thomas, Monte Blue) help this out a bit, but the messy story gets far too out of control and the townsfolk too nasty to even care about after a while.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed