Review of The Gift

The Gift (2000)
8/10
Highly entertaining supernatural murder mystery with Cate Blanchett as both admired and vilified small town psychic
20 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Before his success with 'Sling Blade,' Billy Bob Thornton showcased his talent as one of the co-writers of 'The Gift.' What makes this supernatural thriller so captivating is its setting in the real modern-day Southern town of Brixton, Georgia. The film boasts a stellar cast, with Cate Blanchett delivering a standout performance as Annie Wilson, a woman known in town as a "psychic," although some derisively label her a "fortune teller." Annie, a widow raising three young sons after her husband's tragic death, uses her enhanced intuition to offer guidance and counsel to those who seek her help, supplementing her income from social security survivor benefits.

The story takes a dramatic turn in the second act when Annie advises Valerie Barksdale (Hillary Swank), a victim of domestic abuse, to leave her abusive husband Donnie (a convincingly menacing Keanu Reeves). Donnie, representing the reactionary element of society, targets anyone different or considered an outsider, vilifying Annie and even resorting to his own brand of supernatural belief by using a voodoo doll to threaten her.

Annie also assists Buddy Cole (Giovanni Ribisi), a gas station attendant suffering from mental illness due to childhood abuse by his father. However, as Annie becomes preoccupied with other events, she is forced to neglect Buddy, who tragically reaches a breaking point, tying up his father, dousing him in gasoline, and setting him on fire. Buddy's instability, caused by his history of childhood sexual abuse, is poignantly portrayed by the skillful screenplay.

The plot further intensifies when Annie meets Wayne Collins (Greg Collins), the principal of one of her sons' school, following a fight at school. Although Wayne appears to be an upstanding citizen, his involvement with his promiscuous girlfriend Jessica King (Katie Holmes) raises suspicions. When Jessica goes missing and the police exhaust all leads, they turn to Annie for possible insights into her disappearance.

J. K. Simmons delivers a perfect performance as Sheriff Peal Johnson, initially skeptical of Annie's psychic abilities but eventually convinced of their authenticity when she has visions of Jessica's murder and directs them to a pond on Donnie's property, where the body is found.

Initially, Annie's intuition led her to believe that Donnie was an "insecure redneck" but not a murderer. Interestingly, when Donnie is arrested and stands trial for Jessica's murder, he candidly testifies to his infidelity and history of domestic violence. However, as circumstances turn against him and he is found guilty, he reverts to blaming Annie and labeling her as an agent of the devil.

Given the circumstantial nature of the case against Donnie, it raises questions about whether he would have been convicted in real life. It's worth noting that Annie never claimed he was guilty; she only located the body through her dark visions. One can speculate that her personal antipathy toward Donnie clouded her intuition regarding his innocence.

Eventually, Annie has visions suggesting Donnie's innocence, prompting her to request the District Attorney to reopen the case. To complicate matters further, Annie discovers that the DA was romantically involved with the murder victim, leveraging this information to demand a reopening of the investigation.

'The Gift' delivers a wholly satisfying climax with a twist ending! It is revealed that the real murderer is Wayne, who lures Annie to the spot where Jessica's body was found. He wants to test Annie's psychic powers to see if she has identified him as the killer. As Wayne realizes that Annie is aware of his guilt, he is on the verge of murdering her, but is suddenly stopped by Buddy, who appears out of nowhere.

At this point, the unlikely escape of Buddy from the mental hospital and his presence at the pond raises some doubts. Nevertheless, when Annie returns with an unconscious Wayne to the police, Buddy mysteriously disappears. The twist occurs when Sheriff Johnson reveals that Buddy couldn't have aided Annie because he had hanged himself hours earlier at the state mental hospital. One can only surmise that it was Buddy's spirit that assisted Annie in overpowering Wayne.

Blanchett's excellent portrayal includes a convincing Southern accent, capturing the quiet dignity of a woman both admired and vilified in her hometown. Ribisi also shines in his role as the mentally ill Buddy. Despite the trial's implausibility, 'The Gift' remains highly entertaining, thanks to the masterful direction of Sam Raimi, who skillfully weaves all the elements together, complemented by an effective homespun musical score.

In conclusion, 'The Gift' is a riveting supernatural thriller that keeps viewers engaged with its intriguing plot and outstanding performances. The film's atmospheric setting in a real Southern town adds authenticity to the story. While some aspects may stretch plausibility, the overall experience is highly entertaining and showcases the talents of its cast and director.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed