Muddled Spanish versions of a McCutcheon classic
3 February 2020
At least two Spanish films have been confused here. The film Los guapos del parque (properly Los guapos de la vaquería del parque, was made by Fructuoso Gelabert and first appeared in 1905. It involved an heiress who, after advertising for a husband, is pursued by a gaggle of boys ("guapos" is Spanish are lads not lasses). It has been confused here with an earlier film, made Oct-Dec 1904) by Segundo de Chomón for the Spanish company Macaya and Marro, L'hereu de Ca'n Pruna, which is the film we have. The 1905 film is not known to survive.

The confusion arose because many years later Gelabert claimed, wrongly, that the Macaya y Marro film was a copy of his own film with the genders reversed, since when the two films have been confused in many Spanish filographies. On the other hand Gelabert's recollection is not entirely incorrect in that the film was a parody of another film, but not by Gelabert, called Un joeen distinguido desea casarse (A distinguished young man wishes to marry). In that film which also appeared in Spain in October the main character is a "distinguished young man" arriving in New York who advertises for a wife. This is probably just the original American film (Personal or the Edison copy) but Gelabert has, when accusing Macaya y Marro of plagiarism, not very honestly replaced it, in his account, by a more original version (with genders changed) that he later made of essentially the same story in 1905.

Both Spanish films are based, like the Edison film mentioned by another reviewer, on Wallace McCutcheon's Personal made for Mutoscope and Biograph in June 1904 and one of the biggest international successes the company ever enjoyed.. Other versions include Lubin's Meet me by the Fountain (1904), British Gaumont's lost Personal (1905) and, quite the best in terms of quality of the surviving films, Georges Hatot's Dix femmes pour un mari (1905) for Pathé.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed