Although the series has unique love story, and the chemistry between Asli en Ferhat was convincing, yet the series has several fundamental en irresistible flaws. And because I searched the whole internet en didn't find any plausible answers for my questions, so I mention just several weak points (not all of them! ) below:
1. Sahin cigal came across as smart en manipulative person who followd Namik for more than a decade. Is it really believable that such a person behave that foolishly en doesn't predict Ferhat's reaction for good??? He was so persistent to take revenge of Amirhan's family en all of his decisions were on precise plans. But unexpectedly he surrendered himself to Ferhat en got murdered... I mean seriously??!???
2. Ebru's story has the same breaches as well... At first place she appeared sssso clever en behaved completely acceptable. Moreover her grudge looked really sharp as everyone thought that she would stay manipulative till the end en finally take her revenge... But again, the director left us with a great wonder... Actually her death scene was entirely ridiculous.... She could just murder Asli a long time before Yigit's arrival. But she postponed the crime by telling pointless (till Yigit arrived en killed her).
3. Who the hell sent that letter to Ayhan? En what was his/her purpose? I checked those Eps again en again, but i found nothing!
4. Again similar problem for Azat bey! For pity's sake, why such oldman who servailed Namik family that professionaly en juggled tasks Simultaneously, easily got deceived by a dumb person like Cuneyt?!???!???!
5. After Idil's disappearance for more than a week, considerind our awareness of her murder, no one from home didn't suspect about her sudden leave en that typed letter! At the end, no one notified about her murder en even police didn't find anything!!! I mean if julide is that professional in killing people en hiding their bodies, so why the hell she couldn't kill her aunt??!?!?!?
6. This series emphasizes on reckoning en compensation very strictly; so, is Idil's sin really outweighed Cuneyt's that she deserved death but that filthy murderer didn't??? It is not rational!
7. Asli gas poisoning scene was just ludicrous as well!!!! A 10 year old child just knows that when he/she confronts with gas leakage, he/she must plug gas valve at first place, en then open the window!!! (the kitchen had a bloody window, so there's no excuse!) but a skillful specialist surgeon just didn't know what to do in that moment!!!! It's completely absurd!!!! :D
Overall, in spite of the fact that I don't deny the perfect acts of both leading en supporting roles (specially Yeter en Ferhat) , yet the series has many goofs en falsifications... But I really don't want to mention them all. I didn't have any plan for commenting at first, but seeing loads of compliments en positive reviews made me to write this long critic. I'm still in wonder whether people's taste in cinema en TV-shows is really that degraded nowadays??? In the most optimistic case, this show could get 6 out of 10. (it is mentioned that i didn't write this review for getting positive/negative feedbacks from users; yet, i hope that everyone could have a fair judgement on my comment.) Thanks.
2. Ebru's story has the same breaches as well... At first place she appeared sssso clever en behaved completely acceptable. Moreover her grudge looked really sharp as everyone thought that she would stay manipulative till the end en finally take her revenge... But again, the director left us with a great wonder... Actually her death scene was entirely ridiculous.... She could just murder Asli a long time before Yigit's arrival. But she postponed the crime by telling pointless (till Yigit arrived en killed her).
3. Who the hell sent that letter to Ayhan? En what was his/her purpose? I checked those Eps again en again, but i found nothing!
4. Again similar problem for Azat bey! For pity's sake, why such oldman who servailed Namik family that professionaly en juggled tasks Simultaneously, easily got deceived by a dumb person like Cuneyt?!???!???!
5. After Idil's disappearance for more than a week, considerind our awareness of her murder, no one from home didn't suspect about her sudden leave en that typed letter! At the end, no one notified about her murder en even police didn't find anything!!! I mean if julide is that professional in killing people en hiding their bodies, so why the hell she couldn't kill her aunt??!?!?!?
6. This series emphasizes on reckoning en compensation very strictly; so, is Idil's sin really outweighed Cuneyt's that she deserved death but that filthy murderer didn't??? It is not rational!
7. Asli gas poisoning scene was just ludicrous as well!!!! A 10 year old child just knows that when he/she confronts with gas leakage, he/she must plug gas valve at first place, en then open the window!!! (the kitchen had a bloody window, so there's no excuse!) but a skillful specialist surgeon just didn't know what to do in that moment!!!! It's completely absurd!!!! :D
Overall, in spite of the fact that I don't deny the perfect acts of both leading en supporting roles (specially Yeter en Ferhat) , yet the series has many goofs en falsifications... But I really don't want to mention them all. I didn't have any plan for commenting at first, but seeing loads of compliments en positive reviews made me to write this long critic. I'm still in wonder whether people's taste in cinema en TV-shows is really that degraded nowadays??? In the most optimistic case, this show could get 6 out of 10. (it is mentioned that i didn't write this review for getting positive/negative feedbacks from users; yet, i hope that everyone could have a fair judgement on my comment.) Thanks.