Victor Fleming and the cast were my main reasons for seeing 'Test Pilot', the cast also playing a major part as to why the film is as good as it is. It is hard to resist a director responsible for two of the best films ever made ('The Wizard of Oz' and 'Gone With the Wind'). Nor a cast that includes the likes of Clark Gable, Myrna Loy, Spencer Tracy and Lionel Barrymore, just having one of those four in a film is reason enough to see it but all four in the same film really does wet the appetite.
'Test Pilot' was in no way a disappointment in my view, actually found it on the most part a delight. After seeing so many films etc recently that completely squandered their potential, which always leaves me very frustrated, it was great to see a film that actually lived up to one's expectations. It does fall short of perfection, just, and it is not quite one of Fleming's very finest. 'Test Pilot' does though entertain, move and charm throughout and the cast are on top form here, which does make up for the second half being not quite as good as the first.
Will start with the strengths. Which are a great many, the best brilliantly executed, and vastly outweigh the debits. It looks great, with it being handsomely photographed and the aerial sequences still hold up very well today in this regard. More so than a lot of aerial sequences in a lot of films made in a similar time frame. The music doesn't feel too melodramatic or intrusive, while Fleming directs with an assured hand throughout. The dialogue is very amusing in the first half and when it gets deeper it manages to excel just as much in the dramatic poignancy too. The story always absorbs, with a first half that is genuinely entertaining and also the exciting aerial sequences, sparkling chemistry between Gable and Loy and a charming, sympathetic one between the former and Tracy.
Gable balances authority, humour and pathos beautifully, bringing a twinkle and depth to his role. Loy has perhaps 'Test Pilot's' most difficult role and one of the most demanding in her career, she gives a poignant and sincere performance without going overwrought. Tracy's character is the least interesting of the three but his sympathetic charm is a beautiful match for the chemistry he shares with Gable. Barrymore's crusty demeanour, in a way that only he could do it to this great an extent, really stands out in the acting department.
Sadly, this review is coming onto the debits. As said above, the not as entertaining and deeper second half is not quite as good. It's well meaning and moving, handling seriousness with enough tact, but did find some of the events rushed, the romance (which can lack the same amount of spark that the aerial sequences have) unrealistically so, and the momentum is not always there.
It also did feel a little too much of a different film to the first half, heavier, deeper and more serious, not bad things exactly but tonally it doesn't gel as much as it could have done.
Altogether, delightful on the most part but just falls short of being completely great. Instead settling for a very strong very good. 8/10
'Test Pilot' was in no way a disappointment in my view, actually found it on the most part a delight. After seeing so many films etc recently that completely squandered their potential, which always leaves me very frustrated, it was great to see a film that actually lived up to one's expectations. It does fall short of perfection, just, and it is not quite one of Fleming's very finest. 'Test Pilot' does though entertain, move and charm throughout and the cast are on top form here, which does make up for the second half being not quite as good as the first.
Will start with the strengths. Which are a great many, the best brilliantly executed, and vastly outweigh the debits. It looks great, with it being handsomely photographed and the aerial sequences still hold up very well today in this regard. More so than a lot of aerial sequences in a lot of films made in a similar time frame. The music doesn't feel too melodramatic or intrusive, while Fleming directs with an assured hand throughout. The dialogue is very amusing in the first half and when it gets deeper it manages to excel just as much in the dramatic poignancy too. The story always absorbs, with a first half that is genuinely entertaining and also the exciting aerial sequences, sparkling chemistry between Gable and Loy and a charming, sympathetic one between the former and Tracy.
Gable balances authority, humour and pathos beautifully, bringing a twinkle and depth to his role. Loy has perhaps 'Test Pilot's' most difficult role and one of the most demanding in her career, she gives a poignant and sincere performance without going overwrought. Tracy's character is the least interesting of the three but his sympathetic charm is a beautiful match for the chemistry he shares with Gable. Barrymore's crusty demeanour, in a way that only he could do it to this great an extent, really stands out in the acting department.
Sadly, this review is coming onto the debits. As said above, the not as entertaining and deeper second half is not quite as good. It's well meaning and moving, handling seriousness with enough tact, but did find some of the events rushed, the romance (which can lack the same amount of spark that the aerial sequences have) unrealistically so, and the momentum is not always there.
It also did feel a little too much of a different film to the first half, heavier, deeper and more serious, not bad things exactly but tonally it doesn't gel as much as it could have done.
Altogether, delightful on the most part but just falls short of being completely great. Instead settling for a very strong very good. 8/10