7/10
a meticulous description of religious decision making
26 September 2010
This semi-documentary based of true historical facts, tries to recreate the state of mind of catholic monks. They know the consequences of their choice : if they stay in their monastery they will be killed by terrorists; if they return to France they can save their lives. In the beginning three of the seven monks want to survive, and want lo leave. At the end of the film they unanimously choose to stay. Why ? Decision making is all what the film is about. So this is a psychological film. It is hardly fiction. We see them praying, singing, working, eating. Behaviour determines conviction. Rituals, psalm singing, silence, charity create and harden the monks belief. Their merciful God is the product of their way of live, and that God is the warrant of their decision. The decision of self destruction. A great example of religious horror, the catholic version of religious suicide. Brilliant social cinema.
12 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed