5/10
Very good acting ,...
17 April 2008
...especially Alice Krige! The directing, however, I would have liked more without its over enthusiastic surreal demeanour. The story and essence of the picture as well as its atmosphere and its meaning in reference to the real world fall much to short. What a waste of attitude and art as the ideas of presenting and most acting were captivating. But in lack of a coherent story the movie became what it is...art, with a meaning somewhere to find (Dalí meets a narcissistic form of Kafka) - instead of a beautiful and moving picture with deep meaning.

All just for art's sake? e.g. why is she speaking Dutch and other languages several times? Why overdoing it? Why this shabby and in a way arrogant symbolism?

Didn't read the book by Robert Walser (Jakob von Gunten) - but now I'm interested and hope it's better.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed