5/10
Susan plays another tough gal with a heart of gold...
1 January 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Based on J.D. Salinger's short story, "Uncle Wiggily in Connecticut", the story has been revamped into an unabashedly sentimental soap opera with a wartime background (WWII) and turned into a tear-jerker for SUSAN HAYWARD and DANA ANDREWS. It uses the favorite device of '40s-era romantic dramas, the flashback, to tell how Susan meets and falls in love with soldier Andrews, a bittersweet affair that ended when he died at the front.

The story is framed by the present, with Susan married to KENT SMITH (an actor who always played second leads despite his enormous talent and good looks), a rocky marriage that forces Susan to remember what true love felt like during her brief affair with Andrews.

It's a sudsy affair with Susan as a strong-willed woman, tough on the exterior but supposedly warm-hearted beneath (the kind of role she almost always played) and she did get an Oscar nomination for her starring role opposite Andrews--but it was a year when Olivia de Havilland was tough competition for THE HEIRESS.

Hayward fans consider this one of her best, while J.D. Salinger fans resent what Hollywood did to his short story by turning it into a weepie for women who liked their wartime stories to be deeply romantic.

Victor Young's popular tune, a haunting ballad called "My Foolish Heart", adds to the romantic sentiments of an already tender story.
21 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed