This is a very competently made silent film--with excellent direction, top stars and a decent script. And, overall it's a good film as well, but nothing exceptional one way or the other. For fans of silents, it's a great film to see. For those who are uninitiated or are afraid of silent films (a common problem), this isn't the best film to see, as there are more memorable and timeless movies out there for you to discover. Plus, both Ms. Swanson and Mr. Valentino appeared in better (as well as worse) films--it's sort of a middle of the road film for them both, though it's the only occasion where they appeared together in a film.
Also, and no one is to blame for this, but the version recently discovered in the Netherlands is not in pristine condition. While generally good, there are some small sections where the film has degraded so much further restoration just isn't possible.
Also, and no one is to blame for this, but the version recently discovered in the Netherlands is not in pristine condition. While generally good, there are some small sections where the film has degraded so much further restoration just isn't possible.