I don't have much to say about the film, I know that it is a remake or something similar of a film that deals with the difficulties that African Americans have to integrate into a society until recently I considered them as outcasts, however, when doing it in the form of a musical I feel that it takes away the seriousness and depth of the characters in the story and we are left with only the most superficial layers that each character can give us. I don't dislike musicals, on the contrary, I want to think that I like them, but it is unwise to occupy them in a story that could have been so interesting. I'll watch the original movie and I think it will be a good starting point.
With this film in mind, we begin with the promise of knowing the story of several women: sisters with an abusive father, a singer with a religious father, a liberal woman, etc. They all suffer and we hope to see how they overcome their adversities, but instead, it seems that they magically solve their problems so they can move on and tell us that they always believed, that they always had faith. This without telling us why they endured and why they had faith. In addition to the protagonist, the other characters do not seem to have development or growth or anything that warrants their problems being resolved, it seems as if everything happens by magic, but with the real implications that the resolutions of the problems can bring.
Unfortunately we live in a world that is not magical, on the contrary, it is cruel and it seems that the film intends not to demonstrate cruelty towards one of the groups that perhaps historically have been most punished by human cruelty, it only strives to show us the cruelty that the same group has among themselves.
With this film in mind, we begin with the promise of knowing the story of several women: sisters with an abusive father, a singer with a religious father, a liberal woman, etc. They all suffer and we hope to see how they overcome their adversities, but instead, it seems that they magically solve their problems so they can move on and tell us that they always believed, that they always had faith. This without telling us why they endured and why they had faith. In addition to the protagonist, the other characters do not seem to have development or growth or anything that warrants their problems being resolved, it seems as if everything happens by magic, but with the real implications that the resolutions of the problems can bring.
Unfortunately we live in a world that is not magical, on the contrary, it is cruel and it seems that the film intends not to demonstrate cruelty towards one of the groups that perhaps historically have been most punished by human cruelty, it only strives to show us the cruelty that the same group has among themselves.
Tell Your Friends