I think the documentary SiCKO was very well done. Mr. Moore takes us down the road of the current status of what the medical care is in this country and other countries he travels to places like Canada, France, Great Britian, and lastly Cuba. His statistics are fairly accurate throughout the whole documentary (according to news reports that I have heard) that runs about 2 hours long and does a wonderful job of interviewing many people in this documentary so you have the opportunity to hear their views. This documentary is NOT ABOUT Mr. Moore but rather ABOUT the people that are affected by the medical care that they get or give in this country and abroad.
I could not believe the number of 1 star ratings that are ahead of me. Their feedback is full of bias and hate towards Mr Moore calling everything he does propaganda thus their feedback is very opinionated and unintelligent. This is proved by the feedback on the readers of these posts (for example: 19 out of 136 people found the following comment useful) These people are just plain Michael Moore haters, period! Maybe these one star posters are from the medical insurance companies or from the right wingers but you can see all the readers feedback sending out a strong message to them here.
Please keep an open mind people when posting feedback from a movie you have watched and give feedback pertaining to the movie and not your personal opinions on Michael Moore. I genuinely think Mr. Moore cares about what happens in this country and to the underprivileged and he has a constitutional right to express his opinions in whatever documentary he releases. Good for him. He is practicing capitalism with these documentary movies. You know, the thing that Americans love to do? I'm sure all of you one star voting people have had to deal with the health insurance companies at one point. I know I have.
I'm not going to talk about this documentary too much because by the time you've gotten to my feedback here, I'm pretty sure you have a good idea of what this documentary is all about. I truly recommend that everyone see this, myself. It will put you through an emotional roller-coaster ride of how patients in the USA are treated and, or, denied medical care.
Lastly, to critique, I think I Mr. Moore missed on a few very important issues.
I am a 50 year old man and I pretty much know how the American medical care system worked before the HMO system was put into place and the status of where we are now. This is what Mr. Moore missed putting in his documentary or left out that would have made a big difference and here they are:
1. Doctor abuse. When I was young, a teen-ager, I remember that doctors were abusing or charging the insurance companies for performing unnecessary procedures or charging for procedures that weren't performed. Add to that the over-prescribing of new and expensive medications and referrals to specialists that cost a lot of money. This was happening in large numbers by doctors all across this country. It was total blatant physician greed to make most dollars and it was getting WAY OUT OF HAND. As a result, the insurance companies profit margins were were getting eaten up by all these crazy medical bills. Medical insurance companies had to do something to combat their profit loss. So what they did was to pass this increase in cost to their policy holders causing employers to pay more then, eventually, making their employees pay a co-pay and contribute to annual deductibles. I remember this vividly. It was broad casted on the news all the time back then. This brought about the need for medical insurance companies to take control over these cheating, corrupt and greedy doctors. Thus the birth of HMO's (managed health care) came about like Kaiser Permanente and the like were put into place to control these outrageous doctor bills that insurance companies had to pay. Mr. Moore neglected to mention that fact. Now that medical insurance companies are now in charge of everything, the shift of blatant greed for money has gone from doctors to HMO's.
2. I would have liked to have seen a paycheck from an average middle class citizen in Canada, France, Great Britian and Cuba showing how much they have to pay in taxes towards this National Health Care system. He did not do that thus we don't have a picture of the costs involved per individual.
3. Lastly, I would have loved to see Mr. Moore interview the citizens those 4 countries on why they hate the National Health Care system so they can provide us two perspectives on a tax paid National Health Care system.
With these three things missing, the documentary is sort of one-sided and doesn't give us two sides to the story. This is where Michael Moore fails and I hope he can learn from this omission. I gave this documentary 9 stars instead of 10 because of the 3 missing things I mentioned above.
Even with the 3 missing things I mention, SiCKO hits its mark. Michael Moore is brilliant, successful and he cares.
7 out of 14 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends