Someone got a hold of the tried and true tween movie script. You know the one, you've seen it a billion times before. Main character is new at school (either a freshman or a new transfer, or sometimes both). She's shy, unconfident, out of place! She clashes with the mean popular girl and falls for the handsome yet down-to-earth heartthrob; together with her new quirky friends she solves whatever problem is happening in the plot and learns to be true to herself.
Yep, some guy got hold of that script and inserted the names of Monster High characters into it. And made it a musical.
I don't need to rehash the hundreds of critiques that discuss just how unfaithful it is to its original source material. That's been covered enough, but I do agree with the other reviewers that any and all changes made to the concept/story only made the end product worse.
Instead I'll take a shot at a different review, reviewing the movie itself, which was still awful.
First off, it was a huge mistake making this movie a musical. Production definitely wanted to make this as standard modern kids' fare and looked to Descendants and Zombies for inspiration. But you really need a reason to make a movie a musical. You need a talented choreographer and song team and actors who have experience in musical productions. If you don't have that, then the movie ends up... well, like this one. With forgettable, terrible songs, minimal choreography, and actors who don't seem to grasp they should be performing a song with their whole body and not just moving their lips when they lip-sync the track.
Second, the costumes/makeup. This movie gets a lot of hate for its costumes; I actually think most of the hate is undeserved, or at the least misplaced. When the basis for the costumes comes from dolls (hyper skinny ones at that) who dress in platform heels and wear outfits appropriate for twenty-year olds, it's impossible to replicate that style for real teenagers. I think for the main characters, the costumes were fine and I had no issues with them. It's the background characters that were atrocious. They looked awful. Embarrassing, actually. I don't know whose idea it was to paint the extras from head to toe but it looked terrible on camera. And oddly, they put so much effort into painting them, yet their hair and outfits looked like no effort or thought was put into them at all. Without exaggeration, the background monsters looked like the background townspeople from Halloweentown, which was made over 20 years ago.
There wasn't a coherent plot. And the characters! They took some of the most fleshed-out, interesting, unique characters ever created for a tween-oriented audience... and just flat out cut them all from the story. No character in this film bears any resemblance to any of the established Monster High characters. They used the stock archetypes in every tween movie instead, which made every character flat and unlikable. There wasn't a single character who I liked throughout the film, except possibly the main character. Draculaura as the "sarcastic goth friend" archetype was my least favorite, and I really wish they kept her established personality which is almost the exact opposite to how she is portrayed in the film.
So... If it was this bad, then why didn't I rate this a 1 out of 10? Well... there's actually a few sparse moments in this film that surprised me by being actually quite good that I should mention.
The most notable one is the scene involving the song "True Monster Heart". Everything about that sequence worked; the choreography, the cast's performance, and notably, its importance in the film. Clawdeen's motivation to transfer to Monster High was to find a place where she could be herself (half human, half monster), free of judgement or hate. Disappointed by the human world and its hatred of monsters, she begins the movie by performing the song "Coming Out of the Dark" explaining her expectations for Monster High: "Here I am, I'm comin' out of the dark/Not afraid to show my secrets or my scars/This is where I'm finally free". However, Monster High wasn't the utopia she imagined, and what she finds is the same hate and judgement, only towards humans. This song expertly conveys this through its exaggerated, goofy lyrics ("Humans are unbearable, altogether terrible/Just a bunch of freaky creeps) " and the characters' (excluding Clawdeeen) notable enthusiasm during the sequence. The scene is akin to "A Girl Worth Fighting For" in Mulan, where the characters' common attitude regarding women are established via song and Mulan has to join in for fear she will be discovered. I wish the same high quality and thought was put into the other musical sequences; sadly, this is the only one of any quality or importance.
The other sequence that really worked was the sequence where Clawdeen had to break into the principal's office, and through magic, had to impersonate the principal in front of Cleo. Marci T. House really sold her performance as "Bloodgood but actually Clawdeen" and the comedic timing of the sequence worked well. Again, if the whole movie was paced and executed like this it could have been great, but this was the only scene that worked.
Overall the movie was a solid one out of ten with the exeption of the scenes that I mentioned, which raised its rating slightly. I really, truly wish it was better, but alas.
1 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends