Where to start? While not anywhere near as good as the original trilogy, nor Rogue One, the movie is still far superior to the other clunkers put out in the last 20 years embarrassingly branded Star Wars films.
Having said that here is the good and the bad:
The good:
Chewbacca. Everything from how he looks, moves and acts was perfect. So perfect in fact that I was surprised to find out it wasn't Mayhew I. The make up, his mannerisms and even his expressions were spot on. How he was introduced and how he and Han met was actually really enjoyable EXCEPT (more on this later).
Lando: another excellent casting. There were times his voice and style were almost exact. He captured the character and stole every scene he appeared in. He made the entire movie worth watching.
The BASIC storyline. Its not that bad. The problems weren't the story as much as it was the details (more on this later as well).
Now the bad:
Han. There was just no way to win this one. He's not Ford. Let's be honest, Ford isn't even Han anymore. While the actor got the swagger and there were some nice subtleties (like the striped pants, the blaster and the gun belt) some things were just over done. The effing dice need to go. The little homages to the originals are nice when they can go unnoticed. To point them out CONSTANTLY ruins their significance and meaning to the true fans that like these insider secrets. The other big issue is he in no way even remotely resembles HF. Additionally, he can't shoot it seems until the last scene and no one that is born of that sort of trauma is really that naive. Lastly. Wookiee?? Come on. Just have him speak English and understand Chewie. It's insulting and stupid. It very nearly ruined a great scene. It was unnecessary.
The story. Why have we never heard of this extremely expensive and sought after energy source before now?? Couldn't it just as easily have been something everyone is familiar with?? Also, why must EVERYTHING that we know about the character of Han happen in one mission?? It's like everything interesting about him happened at the same time and then he just chilled out in a bar somewhere until we found him in Star Wars.
The pirates. Why? They added nothing to the storyline OTHER than to illustrate Han's innate "goodness" and that of course totally ruins the redemption that happens in Star Wars (I refuse to call it a new hope. It's Star Wars. Period.).
Emilia Clark: I love her in GOT but she is worthless as anything else and really cannot act. Her character was pointless as the betrayal was just as significant from Woody Harrison's character. It was just redundant at that point.
Woody Harrison: should have been a smuggler. Could have been Talon Karrde(sp?). In essence, all the interesting characters of that crew were killed off nearly immediately.
Darth Maul. I get that people want to see more of him but he really serves zero purpose. He's not part of the empire. He just doesn't fit in.
Here is the big one. The Falcon. Why are we messing with perfection? Even after it was beat up a bit it still didn't look right. I would have been ok with the shielding being ripped off, everything being shiny and new or some of the other cosmetics but a lifeboat/escape pod? On the nose of the ship? I get that it looks like McQuarrie's original drawings but still, to take something iconic and screw with it... They ruined the concept of being the "fastest hunk of junk in the galaxy" by "cheating" with this new energy source jumpstart. Haven't we seen this very thing in a myriad of other venues?
So while there are some pluses; its enjoyable and entertaining, the comedy is much like the originals AND it's better than 5 of the 6 latest movies, it still leaves A LOT to be desired.
2 out of 4 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends