Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Flyboys (2006)
9/10
Visually Stunning ... Historically Accurate
28 August 2006
Warning: Spoilers
On Saturday, August 26th, I saw the first public screening of "FLYBOYS" at the Warner Theatre in Torrington, CT.

For those of you who don't know the story of the Lafayette Escadrilles, they were a squadron of Americans who, during World War I, went to France before the US joined in the fight. The Escadrilles were trained there and flew missions against the Germans. They are credited with helping to stop the German advance into France in the early stages of the war.

James Franco plays Rawlings...a cowboy whose ranch has been foreclosed. As he's watching a newsreel about the Lafayette Escadrilles, the local sheriff tells him that he has an arrest warrant for him and tells him to leave town. Then we see the other pilots-to-be as they leave for France: the all-American guy with the pretty fiancée, the rich guy who's been a disappointment to his dad, the black American who is already in France making a living as a boxer, etc...

At the Escadrilles' airfield, they meet up with the Escadrilles leader, Captain Thenault (Jean Reno, who is really under-used in the movie) and Squadron Leader Cassidy. Cassidy is known for flying extra missions after their main missions, so that he can try to exact revenge for any pilots that they lost during the main missions (I actually found him to be more interesting than Rawlings).

They are dropped off at the American barracks, which is a mansion that's been taken over by the military. As soon as they get into the mansion/barracks, Rawlings is jumped by a young lion…the Escadrilles' tame mascot "Whiskey" (which is a true part of the Escadrilles' history). Then we are shown the pilots' flight training in a fairly short montage which ends with each of them taking off on their first solo flights.

After that, their real missions begin. Their first mission is a bust when they are ambushed by the Germans, but with each following mission, the pilots improve. After awhile, they begin to earn the respect of the more seasoned pilots. As their missions continue, some of the pilots are killed and replaced by newbies with their own unique personalities, including a Bible-carrying Christian who sings "Onward Christian Soldiers" as he shoots down German planes (I liked this guy). There is also the cliché pilot who loses his nerve early on in the film, only to come back strong later (but this is still handled well).

We are introduced to the German ace Wolfert, who has the sense of honor and chivalry that other movies about World War I pilots always overplayed a bit too much for my liking. Thank God, Flyboys doesn't make the same mistake...they make it clear that Wolfert will kill the allied pilots when he has the chance. We are also introduced to the "Black Falcon", who is Wolfert's counterpart in the German squadron. He is sadistic and has no qualms about shooting a pilot who has crash-landed, walked away from his plane, and is no longer a threat. Although all of the Germans are the Escadrilles' enemies, the Black Falcon is the real "bad guy" in the movie. He is used sparingly in the film, but to good effect.

There is also a love story...and, just like most movies based on history...this love story is unnecessary for the telling of the Escadrilles' story. Rawlings meets a pretty French girl after he crashes during a training mission. Rawlings is taken with her, and tries to build a relationship with her. She is afraid of getting too attached to him, afraid that he's going to be killed in combat, but eventually she gives in to his advances (as if she wouldn't ...come on). The love story could have been worse, could have been more sappy, could have been Pearl Harbor, but it wasn't (at least I give the filmmakers credit for that).

Now, if you've seen the trailer for Flyboys, you've already seen glimpses of the high quality of the visual effects. I was reading that the movie cost somewhere around $60 million…and these days, that amount of money doesn't usually lend itself to a visual effects-heavy movie. But this movie is LOADED with long visual effects sequences of the highest quality. Except for some shots of the pilots in the cockpits that you just KNOW were shot on a sound stage, everything else looks fantastic. The big scene with the zeppelin that is in the movie's trailer is great. The flight scenes in general are exciting and tense. The flight characteristics of the planes are very realistic, and they don't do anything that the real planes couldn't have done. Also, the sound effects and editing are fantastic. I'll say right now that this movie should easily be nominated for Oscars in the visual and sound effects/editing categories.

I know enough about the Escadrilles to know that the filmmakers didn't stray too far from historical reality (Tony Bill even mentioned that the black character wasn't in the film as the "token black guy"...the first black American fighter pilot WAS a part of the Escadrilles…and except for in the beginning of the movie, they don't make a big deal out of it). Again, putting aside the love story part of the movie, the story is very well-told and the acting is solid. Even James Franco, who I have always found to be wooden in past films, seems relaxed and comfortable in his role as Rawlings, and he gets the job done (although I might have gone with someone less well-known who was just a better actor in general). The actor who played Cassidy (Martin Henderson) and Jean Reno are excellent (although Reno's role is a bit too small).

DON'T WAIT FOR THE DVD!! See this movie in a THEATER, to get the full effect of the amazing work done by the filmmakers.
66 out of 105 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I Always Liked This Movie
25 October 2004
Warning: Spoilers
I first saw "The Quiet Earth" on Cinemax in the late-1980's (every Wednesday night, Cinemax would show foreign films). Yeah...as many other users have pointed out, this isn't your typical sci-fi flick (no monsters, no extended action scenes). But this movie is unique in that way -- it's a sci-fi flick without much sci-fi in it.

Don't get me wrong -- I'm a huge sci-fi geek -- but the thing that kept my interest while I was watching this movie the first time (and what makes it stick in my mind to this day) is the realistic way this movie deals with a totally unrealistic subject. Bruno Lawrence's reactions to his situation were not your usual Hollywood teen flick "Hey, there's nobody else in the world...let's party!" reaction. Instead, you see Zac (Lawrence) change from a man who couldn't care less about people into someone so desperate for companionship that it drives him temporarily insane (to the point of where he thinks that he's God).

Yeah...strangely enough, the addition of other characters into the picture actually hurts the story a bit, but it also allows Zac to explain to everyone what may have caused the world's population to disappear. It also gives Zac a reason to try to right a wrong that he had a hand in (thus redeeming himself).

The amazing beach/planet-rise visual at the very end of the movie is an image that has stuck in my head for all of these years. It's one of the few actual sci-fi elements in the film, and it has a great look to it (almost a modernized version of those classic "Forbidden Planet" backdrops). As enigmatic as the ending is, I always felt that it was a perfect ending for a movie that had an enigmatic beginning -- it basically brings the movie full-circle.

Sure, "The Quiet Earth" isn't your classic sci-fi movie...and it definitely is NOT for all sci-fi fans, but if you're looking for something different without all of the overdone Hollywood flash, you may want to check it out. I'm on a bit of a search thru my local DVD stores to find a copy of it, myself (I'm sure I'll find it in one of the bargain bins...because I doubt any video store manager will appreciate the quality of this forgotten gem).
76 out of 84 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed