I am conflicted (warning spoilers ahead)
I liked the three new girls and Gilbert (and Cobweb) was hysterical but the film seemed to lack the charm the original had. It was also almost too slapstick in a way (and seemed to try over do it with all of the pop culture references). I had read the sequel book that Disney published a few years ago and I don't understand why they didn't just go with that story and bring back max and Allison and Dani. I enjoyed that they brought back Billy but it didn't make sense he was "awake" all of this time because he literally went to sleep at the end of the first movie. Also SJP's makeup was not the same (it wasn't pale enough) as the first movie and she didn't give Sarah the same voice either (she wasn't supposed to sound like Carrie Bradshaw!!) . I will let Mary's mouth being crooked slide.
It was cool but also strange how they showed footage of the first movie on someone's tv but if it was done as a loving tribute to Gary and Penny Marshall, I actually think it's kind of heartwarming.
I liked the musical numbers but I also missed I Put a Spell on You. And the DRAG contest was amazing!!!
I am confused as to exactly who Hannah Waddingham's character is supposed to be? I was thinking it was the girls mother but I am not so sure...could it just have been some random witch?? Since it only showed the girls in a house alone I was like where are their parents?!
I also thought at the end of the movie when Winnie was thanking the girls was very out of character for her, but perhaps it was written that way because Disney is on a "villains are good" kick. I had also heard that the mayor was supposed to have some villainous alter ego that teamed up with the witches so I was confused when that didn't happen. Maybe it was just a rumor??
I am all for a hocus pocus 3 but I just hope it addresses all of the many plot holes this movie had. It also needs to have Max and Allison and Dani (and Max and Allison's child) in it. Perhaps they could team up with the other girls??
Somewhere between 5.5 and 7.0 for me.
I liked the three new girls and Gilbert (and Cobweb) was hysterical but the film seemed to lack the charm the original had. It was also almost too slapstick in a way (and seemed to try over do it with all of the pop culture references). I had read the sequel book that Disney published a few years ago and I don't understand why they didn't just go with that story and bring back max and Allison and Dani. I enjoyed that they brought back Billy but it didn't make sense he was "awake" all of this time because he literally went to sleep at the end of the first movie. Also SJP's makeup was not the same (it wasn't pale enough) as the first movie and she didn't give Sarah the same voice either (she wasn't supposed to sound like Carrie Bradshaw!!) . I will let Mary's mouth being crooked slide.
It was cool but also strange how they showed footage of the first movie on someone's tv but if it was done as a loving tribute to Gary and Penny Marshall, I actually think it's kind of heartwarming.
I liked the musical numbers but I also missed I Put a Spell on You. And the DRAG contest was amazing!!!
I am confused as to exactly who Hannah Waddingham's character is supposed to be? I was thinking it was the girls mother but I am not so sure...could it just have been some random witch?? Since it only showed the girls in a house alone I was like where are their parents?!
I also thought at the end of the movie when Winnie was thanking the girls was very out of character for her, but perhaps it was written that way because Disney is on a "villains are good" kick. I had also heard that the mayor was supposed to have some villainous alter ego that teamed up with the witches so I was confused when that didn't happen. Maybe it was just a rumor??
I am all for a hocus pocus 3 but I just hope it addresses all of the many plot holes this movie had. It also needs to have Max and Allison and Dani (and Max and Allison's child) in it. Perhaps they could team up with the other girls??
Somewhere between 5.5 and 7.0 for me.
Tell Your Friends