When I was a kid, back during the Cleveland administration (second term), whenever a particularly thick, or particularly challenging, book crossed the required-reading list, there was always at least one kid who'd stand up and give a report not on the book but on the difficulties of writing a report on the book.
The strategy itself was doomed by its own design, and its result was neither a good introduction to the book nor a good book report in itself.
This movie adopts the same strategy, with the same result. Some of the people involved in the production seem to have thought that this was the whole joke of it--but then that may have been a last-ditch attempt at salvage by Stephen Fry, who with Gillian Anderson and the curator who shows us around the real Shandy Hall is the only person who seems to have heard of the book before.
And, anyway, Tristram Shandy does make sense: on its own terms, of course, but then what great work of art does not make sense on its own terms.
Read the book. It is Mozart in print; so don't worry if at first you cannot follow the plot. By the time you get through it, by the time you get all of the jokes on all of their levels, on all of their levels intertwined, you'll be an educated person. And a very funny one.
The strategy itself was doomed by its own design, and its result was neither a good introduction to the book nor a good book report in itself.
This movie adopts the same strategy, with the same result. Some of the people involved in the production seem to have thought that this was the whole joke of it--but then that may have been a last-ditch attempt at salvage by Stephen Fry, who with Gillian Anderson and the curator who shows us around the real Shandy Hall is the only person who seems to have heard of the book before.
And, anyway, Tristram Shandy does make sense: on its own terms, of course, but then what great work of art does not make sense on its own terms.
Read the book. It is Mozart in print; so don't worry if at first you cannot follow the plot. By the time you get through it, by the time you get all of the jokes on all of their levels, on all of their levels intertwined, you'll be an educated person. And a very funny one.
Tell Your Friends