Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Five Parts/ One Story
12 June 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Not always an easy watch, but worth the effort.

If you walked away after the drug addled first episode or the horrendous day in episode two, one could hardly blame you.

The beautiful scenery and acting may have seemed a way to disguise the ugliness in the life of an unsympathetic misanthrope.

But if you were able to see it through to the end you were rewarded, just as the protagonist might be by the time the credits roll at The end of episode five.

The easiest episodes to watch are, not coincidently, the optimistic episodes three and five. As in life, there is often more cast upon us to make us bitter than is given to us to make us happy. Is what is withheld from us going to define us? Is what is cast upon us going to shape what we are for our entire life? Can we truly find redemption and hope in the arms of another person when we loathe ourselves still?

Patrick Melrose asks those questions better than anything else I have seen. It is never too shy to show the cause of bitterness, rage, and deep sadness. Nor does it hide what the effects can be.

While being ironic to a brilliant degree it is not cynical however, which would have been the easiest route for the creators to take.

The beauty of the series is that after a lifetime of bad occurances and bad choices, a person can decide to change his mind.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
True to the Novels But Strong on it's Own
15 May 2018
I finished the novels only a few weeks before watching the first episode and my rating thus far is only based on the first episode. The genius of the novels is turning such ugliness into something beautiful. The bookend decision to start the first episode with the second novel was a smart one from the overall story standpoint as well as thematically. However, the downside, is that the second novel/ first Espinosa is probably the toughest watch/ read as it is Patrick at his worst. Having said that, in a mannner true to the source material, the show creators have managed to take license where necessary in order to stay true to the character as well as the themes. The "plot" is not relevant. It's takes a long term view to realize that. If you had to pick the worst day of your life and watch it, that would not be pleasant either. But the genius of the source material as well as the first episode is that we can relate to Patrick- warts-and-all. Self loathing is relatable to manner, no matter how extreme. This is the first chapter in the story of a man deciding to stop reacting to life and start responding. If you can see past the "ugly" you will find the beauty. Much like in life. I look forward to seeing the upcoming episodes and watching the brilliant Benedict Cumberbatch play the role that I can no longer see anyone else in.
52 out of 66 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed