Common adjectives used in reviews of this film were words like "charming", and "charismatic" - adjectives used to describe the main character, Sutter Keely (played by Miles Teller). I will use neither, because quite frankly I found Sutter's character to be neither charming, nor charismatic. In fact I felt he completely lacked depth and character (ironically enough), and thus found it extremely hard to empathize with him - which, for a film relying heavily upon empathy to get its message across, does not bode well.
In the early stages of the film you're told (by Sutter himself) that he is the life of every party, that he has tons of friends etc., but you never really see any evidence of this. The only time I ever saw a resemblance of friendship was during his conversations with Ricky, which sort of undermines the entire point of Sutter being 'popular'. At one point in the film it's noted that Sutter is thought of as a 'joke' by several people, but we never see any mention of this so it's hard to make sense of this comment, because we're not given any context. His mom also claims that 'everybody loves him', but again we're shown no examples of this and, hey, what mom doesn't say that to her kids?
The love interest is played very believably by Shailene Woodley (what a weird name), and is a redeeming feature of this film because she makes the main character realize what a complete douche he is (even though it takes a while). However, their relationship feels extremely like a case of "Hey, I can get with this girl - though I don't really want to, but there's no one else around at the moment - so why not?', and I don't really see that lasting, even though Mr. Neustadter and Mr. Weber insist in the final scenes that 'common, why not? Stranger things have happened, right?'.
Sutter does finally realize that he's a total tool by always keeping things shallow, and literally being buzzed all the time as a defence mechanism (which I thought was a nice touch), and tries to turn things around. This final realization was good, but the film had yet to show any redeeming qualities of Sutter's personality to make me really care for the guy (I mean they did try to shove it in our face by saying "Hey, he totally carried this kid's books when he was in third grade and really didn't have to", but that's just lazy storytelling). In the end, it just felt like too little too late.
In my opinion this film comes off as too shallow to truly pack the emotional punch needed for it to work (though there are some nice scenes here and there), and as an example of a better coming-of-age story combined with personal drama I'd strongly recommend the fantastic Mud (2012) instead.
2 out of 4 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends