Reviews

10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Seems an obvious conclusion to me
6 November 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Spoiler alert. Read the other reviews to determine whether you want to watch this movie. I definitely think it's worth the viewing, and my opinion of the answer to the main question raised might constitute a spoiler.

I won't bother to give a summation of this movie, which is been done already umpteen times. I'm surprised nobody seems to have drawn what to me seems an obvious conclusion. The forensics are fairly conclusive as to the authenticity. Why can't people just see that this probably (or surely) is a Jackson Pollock, just not a very good one.

That may even explain why he got rid of it. Not everything done by a master is a masterpiece, unless you just want an autograph. Marc Chagall used to write checks for everything, a loaf of bread, a cup of coffee, knowing that people would not cash his checks, preferring to have his autograph in their hands, also knowing his signature was more valuable than the value of the check.

Look at a Jackson Pollock in the Museum of Modern Art in New York. Pictures and posters of those same paintings never really capture it. There is an inexplicable power when looking at these paintings in person. I don't understand it, nor can I articulate what it is, but it is a visceral experience, supra rational. The painting in the movie did not have the same power. It was probably done by Jackson Pollock, but probably one he was not proud of.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Spend It All (1972)
10/10
Deserves to be preserved -- DVD please!
25 June 2007
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this great movie in a college theater 30 years ago. I was elated to get a VHS copy 20 years ago but disappointed to find the VHS edited out some very entertaining scenes. It was an increasingly raucous party as the barbecue developed, plenty of music and beer. And then it came time to roast the pig. Only one problem, the pig was not ready for roasting. What to do? First you have to catch it, and then ... it's a lot harder after so many beers. They were hilarious and honest shots. Were they really so politically incorrect to have to be removed?

Regardless, especially with all the great music, this movie deserves to be on DVD, not lost in a few memories. It's Alan Lomax quality preservation of musical tradition and more, with or without all of the barbecue scenes.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I have watched a great movie -- again
11 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
"32 Short Films About Glenn Gould" gets my vote for the year's Best Movie, Best Actor, Best Screenplay, Best Editing, Best Director, and as my friend David said, "Best thing since sliced bread." Glenn Gould was a Canadian concert pianist. When he was thirty-two he announced he would no longer perform live concerts. Instead he would record and broadcast only, as he saw the performance hall as an elitist and obsolete means of presenting music. He was the first noted classical performer to abandon formal performance attire, something radical at the time, opting for a business suit rather the traditional black tie and tails. But his ideas extended beyond performance sites and attire to the very nature of art, challenging the hierarchical distinction between "artist" and "audience." He wanted creative listening as well as creative performing. And like many geniuses he was full of peculiarities and paradoxes.

He would usually grant interviews only over the phone, and as Yehudi Menuhin said, created his own life and led it to the exclusion of the rest of the world, doing nothing but applying himself to his physical and intellectual work. He was a perfectionist in his recording and his music, yet would hum as he played and record with little regard for things like a squeaky chair or pianos with noisy works. He was a man who cherished solitude, but would talk for hours on the phone and is remembered as a kind and compassionate man. He disdained violence and competition. As a child he serenaded cows in a pasture; upon his death he left half his estate to the SPCA, the other half to the Salvation Army.

One of the many things this movie does well is to integrate actors portraying people, incidents and possibilities with real people speaking their own thoughts. A piano tuner, a chambermaid, an agent, cousin Jessie Norman and others talk about Glenn Gould. In one segment we see the depiction of the final moments before his last concert. Immediately following, Yehudi Menuhin speaks insightfully about Gould's reasoning behind discontinuing public concerts and elaborates on Gould's mindset. Menuhin's appearance makes the previous dramatization seem as real as cinema verité.

A Sociologist recalled being interviewed on the Canadian radio system by Glenn Gould. "It was a very penetrating interview, the most intelligent questions I think I've heard about the North, from experts, laymen, or anything else ... questions that required rather long answers and as I would start to speak or make a point, he would register his feelings not by voice, but by a smile ... All the time he was using his hands and conducting. And this was perhaps slightly off-putting when you're trying to think deep thoughts, because I had no idea what this was all about. He was continuously waving his hands, sort of as if to bring up this idea or so on ... I was his orchestra for that hour." And throughout the "32 Films", we see that conducting the sound in his world is no affectation, but an indication of how deeply attentive Gould's perceptions and musical sensibilities run.

In "Truck Stop" we witness Glenn Gould listening in on ambient conversations at the diner, subtly and almost surreptitiously moving a forefinger in concert with a conversation as it swells, subsides and blends with the other conversations and sounds throughout the highway restaurant. Such is just one example of the film's subtle yet magnificently effective structure, linking several of the "short films," in this case by displaying Glenn Gould's compulsion to conduct sound, whether while listening to an interviewee, a Beethoven sonata, or to the conversations at a truck stop.

Glenn Gould seemed to focus on sound as intently as a Zen monk would attend to his breath during meditating. As a child he listened voraciously to the radio. As an adult he played the radio even while he slept; in fact he could not sleep without the radio turned on. He was always listening. We know that sound conveyed extra meaning to Glenn Gould. After watching this movie it seems to me that he heard so much, he was compelled to organize it into music at least in part because he could not ignore it. He seemed to hear no sound in isolation. I have to believe he could hear no silence.

One of Gould's driving passions was solitude. He considered it to be a necessary element in the human equation and an important condition for nurturing the creative process. He linked the idea of solitude with the far North and explored it in an innovative radio format, a sound documentary, called, "The Idea of North." In the movie, the short film "The Idea of North" immediately follows "Truck Stop," showing us some of the inspirational link to the radio production. As in "Truck Stop," we first hear a single voice talking, which is then joined by other voices that mingle and intertwine as musically as a string quintet of voices.

This movie may not change your life, but it made me more elated and optimistic about the world than any movie I can remember. It woke up some of my curiosities and gave me a renewed shot of vitality. It made me think about how a person can use his capabilities and ingenuity to a creative purpose and how much better we all are for it. It reminded me that solitude need not be dark and lonely but can be fodder for the joy of creative imagination; that we need not have the artistic genius of a Glenn Gould to justify our efforts, nor a Bach cantata every Sunday morning to hear music. We have our own eyes and ears to use and our own curiosity to explore. Many drops make an ocean, and as Shakespeare said, "Sweet are the uses of adversity."
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
DVD please
14 July 2006
A great movie -- if only it could be released on DVD in US/Canada Zone format? I see it available on PAL in the UK for $70, but could we not get it in the US for a more reasonable price, please?

I'm still amazed as the Bushmen hunters chase down their prey, tracking and running through the Kalahari Desert after it for hours and hours and miles and miles until finally they catch up to it. By then the kudu is so thoroughly exhausted from the pursuit it cannot even walk away from the relentless hunters, who can now kill it and return home with the meat, probably another 100 miles.

I want to own and show this movie to my friends. Can it be made available on DVD?
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Attica (1974)
10/10
Historic event -- the best look you may now never see
31 March 2006
I saw "Attica" more than 30 years ago. I am distressed that it still has never been available on DVD (or even VHS). The movie documents the prison uprising at Attica prison, and the crushing suppression by the government.

This was no ordinary prison riot. The authorities faced something probably never seen before or since -- black and white prisoners were united, and at least for that brief period, considered, acted, and treated each other as brothers. Their unity became political, for once seeing that instead of remaining pitted against each other, they could resist by uniting. It was a unique and powerful event that scared the bejeezus out of prison and governmental authorities. The lowest of the under-classes became radicalized and united, and they exerted their new found power. It was not an example to let stand. It had to be quashed, and it was.

I don't remember the numbers, but the uprising was crushed, violently and brutally -- many, many inmates killed in the siege. Reports were initially leaked that hostages had been executed by prisoners, reports later proved completely false. There has since been a book or two about the events, but none from a perspective as inside as this movie gives.

We have this movie to thank for bringing some public light to this historic event. (Remember in "Dog Day Afternoon" when Al Pacino exhorted the crowd to resist the police by chanting "Attica, Attica"? This was the movie that told us why.) I can only hope and implore that this movie be released on DVD. I don't know the reasons, but one must question. It's enough to make me feel what David Foster Wallace once wrote, "I know I'm paranoid, but am I paranoid enough?"

Cinda Firestone's "Attica" is too important to just vanish. This is not a movie with an agenda, but a considered documentary of an important time and event. It may be the most important movie never released on DVD.
27 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
You can be more than your circumstances
25 January 2004
Remarkably good, thoroughly uplifting. Even a VA hospital file clerk in Cleveland can be an artist of stature and inspiration. This is an anthem to anyone who wants to do more than sit aimlessly on their ass. Harvey Pekar shows than anyone can be an artist, if you would just "live your life, deal with it, and try to understand" -- and do something about it.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Live Flesh (1997)
10/10
More real life wheelchair depiction than in any other movie
4 September 2003
As a new wheelchair user I learned more about driving a chair from this movie than from any other source. I've never seen any movie which shows as much detail of a guy in a chair and how he deals with everyday situations -- stairs, transfers, rough terrain, getting in and out of a car. Unfortunate translation of the title however.
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Better than the attention it got, true and unique.
21 December 2002
One of three American entries that year at Cannes, along with "China Syndrome" and "Norma Rae," it is a shame it has never been released on VHS or DVD. I know the people this movie is about. It is authentic, as much about the people and the land as it is about a unique man some say is the greatest dog musher who ever lived.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
subtle yet intelligent allegory of the Israeli/Palestinian quagmire
20 August 2002
It's Israel's 50 birthday as a State and a birthday for the film maker inside the film, Mr. Mograbi (More Grab I). He weaves an allegory of personal frustrations in his private and professional life that shines some insight on the bigger picture. Not holier than thou, but honestly introspective.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One woman's monumental toil for love, duty and survival
3 July 2002
Finally available on DVD. I had been wanting to share this movie with friends for more than 30 years. It has always been on my top 10 list of best movies ever seen.What I remember most are the subtle scenes which communicate so much, the woman wrapping her meat patty from her factory provided lunch in a napkin and slipping it into her purse in order to be able to give it to her son later on. Or after finally going to see a doctor, first making a last-minute detour into a department store to buy new underwear, too embarrassed that the doctor would see her in what she had on. Or at the very end, when the train passes by the billboard with the Mao graffiti on it (the most subtle of political comment). This is a splendid and brilliant movie, exposing the complexity of social circumstance without ever taking the easy way out, or suggesting there is ever an easy answer, in this case just a brief vacation.
16 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed