I always like to look at a film years later to see if my original thoughts on the film still stand, in this case 2022 compared to 2006.
Seeing that Returns is more a sequel to the second film they kind of forgot the finer points of what came before it. For example in the first film the conversation between Superman and Lois in the original interview "Can you read my mind" sequence Clark refers to Peter Pan, in the same sequence Superman says "Peter Pan flew with children Lois". In the new film Superman asks who Clark was in another CYRMM type of sequence.
It was like the story tellers picked and chose elements from the original 2 films, incorporated them into the new script without realizing that the accompanying elements when told didn't connect with the original plot points. Too many continuity issues.
There are things that the story lacked and that's what made the film a little bit more mediocre for me. The action sequences were very well done and you could see that they put money in the film.
My only other complaint about the film and I remembered this when I saw the film in 2006 was that at times Brandon Routh was trying to be Christopher Reeve rather than make the role his own. He even cracks a joke in DC's Legends of Tomorrow when referring to Supergirl "She looks like my cousin" while not even playing the part of Superman anymore.
Seeing that Returns is more a sequel to the second film they kind of forgot the finer points of what came before it. For example in the first film the conversation between Superman and Lois in the original interview "Can you read my mind" sequence Clark refers to Peter Pan, in the same sequence Superman says "Peter Pan flew with children Lois". In the new film Superman asks who Clark was in another CYRMM type of sequence.
It was like the story tellers picked and chose elements from the original 2 films, incorporated them into the new script without realizing that the accompanying elements when told didn't connect with the original plot points. Too many continuity issues.
There are things that the story lacked and that's what made the film a little bit more mediocre for me. The action sequences were very well done and you could see that they put money in the film.
My only other complaint about the film and I remembered this when I saw the film in 2006 was that at times Brandon Routh was trying to be Christopher Reeve rather than make the role his own. He even cracks a joke in DC's Legends of Tomorrow when referring to Supergirl "She looks like my cousin" while not even playing the part of Superman anymore.
Tell Your Friends