Full disclosure. I watched one full episode and half a second before it was time for me to stop. I will try to finish the second one... but probably won't.
These type of "reality" shows perplex me. The first episode may perk your interest if it's unique, but after awhile it becomes " same thing, different story". Thus was my thought here.
Beyond that, like so many of these type of shows, the purpose is of course to show "Successes" and .... then move on. Of course success is great, but this is a bubble and I'm not so sure that the successes may be long lasting. Also, because it's so condensed, the reintroduction into the homes seems.... nothing. I would assume that, like the training, it would take time, not just the happy feel good we corrected the problems. Here's your dog, let's show what she/ he has learned... yah.... move on. As for the training, I'm not an expert, so... but would not the owner need more that a home visit to learn them?
Many shows of this nature do the same. Queer eye ( never shows/ talks about the backlash or those opposed to what they do, like one episode a teacher, many students stayed home that day rather than be shown to be so loving, or home shows like extreme makeover, never talk about the people whom loose the homes because they can't afford the property taxes etc) are two examples.
My point is, these shows are designed to showcase success, leave you with a warmed heart or a tear, but many are a bandage fix that festers again after the episodes air.
I may sound heartless, I'm not. I want success for all the outcomes, but let's maybe try to ground these shows in more reality... show follow ups, show the ones that don't work. That's life.... but that's not the reality most people want in these type of shows
These type of "reality" shows perplex me. The first episode may perk your interest if it's unique, but after awhile it becomes " same thing, different story". Thus was my thought here.
Beyond that, like so many of these type of shows, the purpose is of course to show "Successes" and .... then move on. Of course success is great, but this is a bubble and I'm not so sure that the successes may be long lasting. Also, because it's so condensed, the reintroduction into the homes seems.... nothing. I would assume that, like the training, it would take time, not just the happy feel good we corrected the problems. Here's your dog, let's show what she/ he has learned... yah.... move on. As for the training, I'm not an expert, so... but would not the owner need more that a home visit to learn them?
Many shows of this nature do the same. Queer eye ( never shows/ talks about the backlash or those opposed to what they do, like one episode a teacher, many students stayed home that day rather than be shown to be so loving, or home shows like extreme makeover, never talk about the people whom loose the homes because they can't afford the property taxes etc) are two examples.
My point is, these shows are designed to showcase success, leave you with a warmed heart or a tear, but many are a bandage fix that festers again after the episodes air.
I may sound heartless, I'm not. I want success for all the outcomes, but let's maybe try to ground these shows in more reality... show follow ups, show the ones that don't work. That's life.... but that's not the reality most people want in these type of shows
Tell Your Friends