It's obvious that none of the other reviewers has read the book on which this disasters is supposedly based.
I've read the book, it's one of my favorites. This movie is very disloyal to the book and it's a big disappointment. No wonder Nelson Algren didn't even want to attend the premiere.
The only things about this movie that are true to the book are the characters' names (except Jo, who's not even in the book) and some of that plot elements.
Someone mentioned the absurdity of Dove being referred to as a boy and Kitty being referred to as a minor in the film.
That's because in the book, Dove is 17 and Kitty is 16. Hallie is biracial. Oliver is not disabled, but there is a disabled character in the book.
Teresina is perhaps the only character that's closest to the book. But the plot elements that surround the character in the film are slightly different than the book.
What I'm trying to say is that, if you're going to base a movie on a book, at least maintain most of the basic elements. Don't change the story, add new characters or combine existing ones.
This movie is a hack job and I would love to see a version that's true to the book. That would be a much better movie, one worth seeing.
I've read the book, it's one of my favorites. This movie is very disloyal to the book and it's a big disappointment. No wonder Nelson Algren didn't even want to attend the premiere.
The only things about this movie that are true to the book are the characters' names (except Jo, who's not even in the book) and some of that plot elements.
Someone mentioned the absurdity of Dove being referred to as a boy and Kitty being referred to as a minor in the film.
That's because in the book, Dove is 17 and Kitty is 16. Hallie is biracial. Oliver is not disabled, but there is a disabled character in the book.
Teresina is perhaps the only character that's closest to the book. But the plot elements that surround the character in the film are slightly different than the book.
What I'm trying to say is that, if you're going to base a movie on a book, at least maintain most of the basic elements. Don't change the story, add new characters or combine existing ones.
This movie is a hack job and I would love to see a version that's true to the book. That would be a much better movie, one worth seeing.
Tell Your Friends