Cate Blanchett is reason enough to see this oddly malfunctioning film. Johnny Depp, too. And the film is pleasant enough to look at. But Ms. Ricci is a distraction. She's miscast as the heroine, and badly. I kept waiting for her to ditch that dumpy hair style and start belting out songs. After all, she's supposed to be gorgeous and a chanteuse to boot. Frankly, I think young Ricci has some killer eyes and hints at disarming vulnerability but it's sad to see her so out of place here and it's almost laughable how when she lifts her skirts to show off her supposedly great legs the director has to go to long shot. Her singing isn't very convincing either. That's no big sin but her character's voice is supposed to be exceptional enough to lift her above the childhood crowd and even wow the big singing star himself. Her singing here wouldn't land her a solo in your average high school choir. I kept thinking, "Is that her real voice? If it is, why didn't they hire a real singer and dub it? If it isn't, why didn't they hire a decent singer for her?"
I kept hoping Blanchett and Depp would leave their dumb partners and run off together. Now that coupling would have been worth watching.
I kept hoping Blanchett and Depp would leave their dumb partners and run off together. Now that coupling would have been worth watching.
Tell Your Friends