Very interesting character development for Shaun Murphy, and it covers a common issue for women in the workplace. I don't ever get to see such an accurate portrayal of such. I really enjoyed it.
10 Reviews
A great episode
MadMischief27 March 2021
"Sacrifice" (#1.10)
aaronredis14 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Before I watched this episode, I was highly concerned. Here is what I was thinking to myself: It looks like all the progress Dr. Shaun Murphy has made thus far will be squandered. I have really enjoyed this show, and it has been chronicling all of the progress the character made, but it looks like it's about to be ruined . . . ?
After watching, sadly, I was correct. Why can't they just leave good enough alone?
It was great that Shaun stood up for himself . . . but acting out? Really? No way. Shaun was doing so well and came so far with learning how to communicate better.
Excellent casting of Manny Jacinto as Bobby Ato, which Shaun and Jared treat. I loved how he confronted Shaun and encouraged him, but the way Shaun took it definitely was, in some way, misinterpreted.
Clair treats her patient Hazel, but when she is teamed up with Dr. Coyle . . . difficulties arise. Not only does he not know his physical boundaries, but he also doesn't know his social cues. Claire signaled several times that she was not interested in him, but he obviously didn't care. I do appreciate the writing team raising awareness to this issue of sexual suggestion in the workplace. Dr. Coyle acted in a way that was so unprofessional and inconsiderate that it was maddening. He is the true definition of a pig. I am hoping that, as viewers, the message was well received and people are able to witness when someone is crossing a line and when to intervene. Claire does confront Shaun and Jared and asks to swap with one of them, but neither are interested. This issue is especially important to us viewers when we see how hesitant Claire is, because she knows that her male counterparts will be far less understanding and likely not even interested in listening. I am hoping that this story gave a voice to those women in need and I am also hoping that it opened eyes for those who were in need of confronting the thought of circumstances like this.
When Jared finally realizes what Claire was suggesting, Jared decides to take matters into his own hands and deal with Dr. Coyle himself. This, of course, leads to Jared getting fired. Had Jared just swapped with her in the first place, maybe none of this would have happened. This is also an important message for viewers to see and confront. Women should as equally be respected and heard the first time rather than when it is too late. Picture this: what if Jared was asked to swap with one of his guy buddies? I would almost bet that he would have no problem with it. I appreciate the writer's also depicting this.
Here is where "Sacrifice" becomes a problematic turn of events: Shaun and Dr. Glassman. I am incredibly disappointed with what has happened between these two. Excuse me for saying this . . . but what the HELL is going on with these two? Why is Dr. Glassman suddenly pushing a life coach on Shaun? It makes no sense to me. Shaun has every right to be perplexed by this, and even more so when Dr. Glassman even bribes Shaun. I think Shaun was confused by the sudden change of heart. To be more clear, that is Dr. Glassman pushing Shaun to be independent and free-thinking to suddenly wanting Shaun to be tethered to someone else. I am extremely disappointed by the fact that Shaun's progress is being ruined by the once supportive and encouraging Dr. Glassman. Shaun reaches such a point of discomfort that he would rather sleep in the hospital basement rather than at his own apartment.
Bobby -- Shaun's patient -- does encourage Shaun to stand up for himself. Shaun listens to him intently, and acts strongly on his suggestions. Dr. Glassman definitely crossed a line, though, and when he confronts Shaun, Shaun slaps him . . . I really don't know what to think about this. While Shaun does stand up for himself, he has been learning to communicate his feelings. Him acting out kind of goes against all the progress he's made . . . doesn't it? I mean, yes, he stood up for himself, but he also took to less beneficial alternatives. Shaun is so bothered that he ups and leaves from his apartment. This whole situation just bothered me greatly. I was feeling so happy for Shaun and this just goes against how far he has come.
How awful it was to see Claire dismissed by everyone. I truly felt so bad for her. Dr. Coyle was manipulative in the sense that, if Claire declined his offer, it would come with punishment. I could only imagine how this made her feel. People wonder why victims never say anything and the reason why is the fear of not being believed. That is enough for someone to want to hide it, which only further infuriates me when people say why only bring it up now when it happened so long ago? Because it took THAT LONG to build the courage to say it,not to mention some feel as though they are at fault, whereas, in reality, the person of authority -- the perpetrator -- is the one who is at fault. A victim sometimes feels as though some things are better left unsaid, because when you speak up, you can't take it back . . . and what if you just add insult to injury? I praise the writers for bringing the viewers' attention to this.
While I completely understand all the pressure Shaun is under, the bigger picture is Shaun has made so much progress, and now that this happened . . . what now? Was that progress for nothing? Is he going to be knocked back to square one? This bothers me a lot. Character development is crucial, and this situation makes for an extreme lapse in said development that it is almost appalling. I thought this was the Shaun he left behind months ago.
Also, I am still not at all invested in Jessica. What is the point of her character? She just comes and goes and there is barely any continuation of her reveal with Dr. Glassman. Additionally, I am not at all bothered by her "news" of not wanting to have children with Dr. Melendez. Their relationship doesn't feel organic in any way.
If it wasn't for Shaun's outburst and all the disappointment that came with it, I would be inclined to say that this was the best episode yet . . . but I am so appalled by how out of place this felt for him. Yes, he stood up for himself, but not in a way that felt fitting for all the progress he has made that has since been ruined.
I give "Sacrifice" a 7.1/10.
After watching, sadly, I was correct. Why can't they just leave good enough alone?
It was great that Shaun stood up for himself . . . but acting out? Really? No way. Shaun was doing so well and came so far with learning how to communicate better.
Excellent casting of Manny Jacinto as Bobby Ato, which Shaun and Jared treat. I loved how he confronted Shaun and encouraged him, but the way Shaun took it definitely was, in some way, misinterpreted.
Clair treats her patient Hazel, but when she is teamed up with Dr. Coyle . . . difficulties arise. Not only does he not know his physical boundaries, but he also doesn't know his social cues. Claire signaled several times that she was not interested in him, but he obviously didn't care. I do appreciate the writing team raising awareness to this issue of sexual suggestion in the workplace. Dr. Coyle acted in a way that was so unprofessional and inconsiderate that it was maddening. He is the true definition of a pig. I am hoping that, as viewers, the message was well received and people are able to witness when someone is crossing a line and when to intervene. Claire does confront Shaun and Jared and asks to swap with one of them, but neither are interested. This issue is especially important to us viewers when we see how hesitant Claire is, because she knows that her male counterparts will be far less understanding and likely not even interested in listening. I am hoping that this story gave a voice to those women in need and I am also hoping that it opened eyes for those who were in need of confronting the thought of circumstances like this.
When Jared finally realizes what Claire was suggesting, Jared decides to take matters into his own hands and deal with Dr. Coyle himself. This, of course, leads to Jared getting fired. Had Jared just swapped with her in the first place, maybe none of this would have happened. This is also an important message for viewers to see and confront. Women should as equally be respected and heard the first time rather than when it is too late. Picture this: what if Jared was asked to swap with one of his guy buddies? I would almost bet that he would have no problem with it. I appreciate the writer's also depicting this.
Here is where "Sacrifice" becomes a problematic turn of events: Shaun and Dr. Glassman. I am incredibly disappointed with what has happened between these two. Excuse me for saying this . . . but what the HELL is going on with these two? Why is Dr. Glassman suddenly pushing a life coach on Shaun? It makes no sense to me. Shaun has every right to be perplexed by this, and even more so when Dr. Glassman even bribes Shaun. I think Shaun was confused by the sudden change of heart. To be more clear, that is Dr. Glassman pushing Shaun to be independent and free-thinking to suddenly wanting Shaun to be tethered to someone else. I am extremely disappointed by the fact that Shaun's progress is being ruined by the once supportive and encouraging Dr. Glassman. Shaun reaches such a point of discomfort that he would rather sleep in the hospital basement rather than at his own apartment.
Bobby -- Shaun's patient -- does encourage Shaun to stand up for himself. Shaun listens to him intently, and acts strongly on his suggestions. Dr. Glassman definitely crossed a line, though, and when he confronts Shaun, Shaun slaps him . . . I really don't know what to think about this. While Shaun does stand up for himself, he has been learning to communicate his feelings. Him acting out kind of goes against all the progress he's made . . . doesn't it? I mean, yes, he stood up for himself, but he also took to less beneficial alternatives. Shaun is so bothered that he ups and leaves from his apartment. This whole situation just bothered me greatly. I was feeling so happy for Shaun and this just goes against how far he has come.
How awful it was to see Claire dismissed by everyone. I truly felt so bad for her. Dr. Coyle was manipulative in the sense that, if Claire declined his offer, it would come with punishment. I could only imagine how this made her feel. People wonder why victims never say anything and the reason why is the fear of not being believed. That is enough for someone to want to hide it, which only further infuriates me when people say why only bring it up now when it happened so long ago? Because it took THAT LONG to build the courage to say it,not to mention some feel as though they are at fault, whereas, in reality, the person of authority -- the perpetrator -- is the one who is at fault. A victim sometimes feels as though some things are better left unsaid, because when you speak up, you can't take it back . . . and what if you just add insult to injury? I praise the writers for bringing the viewers' attention to this.
While I completely understand all the pressure Shaun is under, the bigger picture is Shaun has made so much progress, and now that this happened . . . what now? Was that progress for nothing? Is he going to be knocked back to square one? This bothers me a lot. Character development is crucial, and this situation makes for an extreme lapse in said development that it is almost appalling. I thought this was the Shaun he left behind months ago.
Also, I am still not at all invested in Jessica. What is the point of her character? She just comes and goes and there is barely any continuation of her reveal with Dr. Glassman. Additionally, I am not at all bothered by her "news" of not wanting to have children with Dr. Melendez. Their relationship doesn't feel organic in any way.
If it wasn't for Shaun's outburst and all the disappointment that came with it, I would be inclined to say that this was the best episode yet . . . but I am so appalled by how out of place this felt for him. Yes, he stood up for himself, but not in a way that felt fitting for all the progress he has made that has since been ruined.
I give "Sacrifice" a 7.1/10.
S1.E10 - Mental Breakdown [9/10]
panagiotis199325 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
(S1. E10) My Live Reaction / Review for The Good Doctor Season 1 Episode 10 ''Sacrifice''. The previous episode was good and I gave it a rating of 9/10. Let's see if this one is better or worse. Does Shaun really need a life coach / psychologist? I don't know. Shaun is avoiding his meeting with the life coach, I don't know if that's good. That doctor was being too friendly with Dr. Browne, he is a creep. It sucks that this guy has a tumor in his head. They are saying that even if the surgery is successful he will be disabled, that sucks. Damn, Shaun has a mental breakdown, I feel bad for him. He really doesn't wanna meet this life coach. Overall this episode was good and I enjoyed it. My rating is 9/10.
plot thickens
Logomark8906 December 2017
this is the best episode so far in terms of emotions and main story line. every thing was going smooth till last episode. but that changes in this episode.
all characters face emotional crisis and take drastic turns. which makes me wonder why they decided to challenge all characters at once. since it is a TV series they could have taken one character at a time. any way next episodes are gonna be awesome since the plot thickened.
all characters face emotional crisis and take drastic turns. which makes me wonder why they decided to challenge all characters at once. since it is a TV series they could have taken one character at a time. any way next episodes are gonna be awesome since the plot thickened.
outstanding episode
hoffmanaz7 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The roles of Manny Jacinto as the game player and the (apparently) uncredited janitor demonstrate the fine writing and acting in this series. When told he has a brain tumor, Jacinto faces the news without speaking, letting his expression change from shock to acceptance to courage, finally saying he's had a good run. When the janitor finds Murphy in the storage closet, and is asked about the quality of his life, the janitor, only on screen for a minute or so, reflects on his life and decides that he has had a good life. Both of these scenes were exceptionally moving.
I would like to add that we have a family friend whose son is a person with autism, and Murphy's meltdown at the end of the episode was not only astonishingly realistic, it mirrored the occasional meltdowns our friend's son has experienced. This is one of the best program on TV I have ever watched.
I would like to add that we have a family friend whose son is a person with autism, and Murphy's meltdown at the end of the episode was not only astonishingly realistic, it mirrored the occasional meltdowns our friend's son has experienced. This is one of the best program on TV I have ever watched.
too much drama
petersjoelen15 June 2019
Warning: Spoilers
The Shaun storyline with his new therapist i think is ot very good storytelling ,
i think his reactions are exaggareting i would prefer to see him confronting her
and make the story go further on that .
The other thing i liked even less is the claire metoo story that did not convince me at all it felt forced and her and his reactions were overdramatic .
Please get a better medical consultant for your screenplays.
krkoby6 November 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Malignant Hyperthermia isn't just some random thing that happens with anesthesia it is extremely dangerous. The treatment once a surgery incident occurs is far more involved and recovery is much more involved. Please check MHAUS website for more information.
Bad, bad, bad and then bad some more.
jongriffin101114 February 2018
Allow me to start by saying that I have loved this show so much. I was convinced that it was the best of the best and it was easily my favorite. Now?
Forget it. It's turned into a mess.
Words cannot describe how bad this episode is. Political agendas abound, and fake ethical dilemmas everywhere. And it only gets worse. Keep watching and every episode has an even more obvious political agenda.
And about Shaun...are you KIDDING ME?! Talk about character assassination. WTF.
This is EASILY the WORST episode. I cannot begin to explain how upset I am with this crap.
...
I am DONE and the people who think this junk is good should be beyond grateful. 0 out of 10!
I am DONE and the people who think this junk is good should be beyond grateful. 0 out of 10!
Should be titled 'The Woke Show'
this_is_mike13 March 2022
Usual amount of modern wokery - men bad, women oppressed. Another show trying to push metoo bs that we've seen hundreds of times already, but only going one way. Still waiting for any show to portray men being harassed by women, having their entire lives ruined when women walk free.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
