"Genius" Einstein: Chapter Seven (TV Episode 2017) Poster

(TV Series)

(2017)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
"Relativity is At My Fingertips!"
lavatch18 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
In this episode, Einstein's long search for the proof his theory of relativity comes to fruition. But it is a bittersweet moment for him as the Nobel Prize is awarded to Max Planck in physics and Fritz Haber in chemistry. The Great War, which has made use of Haber's experimental poison gas, finally comes to an end in 1919. But it is during this tumultuous period that "one of the most resplendent achievements of human thought" is due to the tenacity of Albert Einstein.

In intense personal competition with his fellow scientist David Hilbert, Einstein is devastated when learning that Hilbert completed the final calculation: "He's defeated me," laments Einstein. But in another one of his brilliant thought experiments, Einstein realizes that Hilbert made an error. He rejoices, completes the calculations himself, and receives credit for proving his own theory.

In a subplot, Einstein's good friend Fritz Haber has made stunning discoveries in the synthesis of ammonia from nitrogen gas and hydrogen gas. The implications were unprecedented for food production and the survival of the human race. But Haber was also working closely with the German military in the manufacture of poisonous gasses used in World War I. In one of the most shocking scenes of the series, Faber's wife Clara, who was also a good friend of Einstein, is so appalled by her husband's work that takes her life.

Indeed, Einstein agreed with Clara that the uses of noxious gasses and chemical warfare were crimes against humanity. As Einstein succinctly remarks, "Peace cannot be kept by force; it can only be achieved by understanding." Such a realization also comes to Einstein's friend Max Planck when he learns of the death of his young son during the war. In the fog of war, "right and wrong become blurred." The filmmakers offer a gruesome demonstration of the release of Haber's poison gas during a battle with the resulting carnage of bodies scattered on the ground at the Second Battle of Ypres through "the death cloud."

By Armistice Day, November 7, 1919, the program addresses once again the personal life of Einstein. Maleva still refuses to give Einstein a divorce, raising the concerns of Elsa, who is cohabiting with her "cousin." It is clear as well that the troubled family life has taken a toll on the little boy Eduard.

By this time, Elsa's live-in lover is becoming a household name when Sir Arthur Eddington verifies Einstein's theory during an eclipse: "Gravity bends light passing next to the sun by approximately 1.7 arc seconds, just as Einstein predicted." At this point, it was becoming clear in the scientific community that Newton's laws must be reconsidered, due to the breakthrough discoveries of Einstein.

At the Prussian Academy in 1919, Einstein congratulates his friend Planck, as well as Fritz Haber, both of whom were awarded Nobel Prizes. Still, Einstein candidly tells Haber about his abhorrent uses of poison gas that "life cannot be balanced like an equation." In postwar Germany, antisemitism is on the rise with Dr. Lenard joining with "Einstein killer" Paul Weyland to defame Einstein and his ideas. In a packed lecture at Philharmonic Hall in Berlin, Einstein is attendance to defend himself against Weyland's contention that relativity is a "hoax" and that the public has been "hoodwinked." While Einstein goes on the attack, writing to officials in the newly formed Weimar government, Elsa recognizes that men like Weyland and Lenard are dangerous in the current climate.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
about Albert, Mileva and Elsa (sorry for the spoiler)
bema-bvba-16 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
the switch between the 'Johnny Flynn' Albert and the 'Geoffrey Rush' Albert happens in this episode and is - as to my opinion - much to soon. Albert Einstein had in the roaring twenties younger (and more serious) looks than the G. Rush interpretation of him. For the moment, I am not convinced either with the other new portrayals of Mileva and Elsa by resp. Sally Dexter and Emily Watson.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
****
edwagreen7 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The end of World War 1 brings about the change in the cast with Geoffrey Rush taking over as an older Einstein. His long-suffering wife is also changed; although, the older wife, appeared younger and prettier than the wife who played opposite Johnny Flynn. The latter must be commended for an absolutely devastating performance in the title role.

We sure learn in this episode what nitrogen and oxygen can do when mixed together. Even my high school chemistry teacher never explained it this way. The Germans begin using all sorts of poisonous gases against the enemy.

We see plenty of anti-Semitism around in Germany at the end of World War 1. They, the Nazis, use as an excuse Einstein's refusal to go along with the German war effort.

His anti-war attitude also costs him the friendship of Fritz, referred to by Einstein as a war-monger. At a dinner party, Fritz's wife puts a bullet in her head to protest what he has done during the war regarding the nerve gas.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Jump the sharkish
headly6610 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I was really enjoying this series until the end of this episode. The change from actor Johnny Flynn to Geoffrey Rush is confusing because there is virtually no time change from wartime to the end of the war and yet Einstein looks like he aged 30 years. In 1919 AE was 39 years old, thin with slightly graying hair. Geoffrey Rush is 65 years old and 6ft tall. AE was 5ft 9in. They should have had it just start with Rush at the beginning of the next episode.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed