Liv and Maddie (TV Series) Choose-A-Rooney (2016) User Reviews

Are you kidding me?

[gjenevieve · 5/10 · 17 November 2016]

I cannot believe that they brought Diggie back. To make things worse, they have Maddie choosing to get back with Diggie and leaving Josh. This is ridiculous! I have really enjoyed the dynamic between Maddie and Josh. I like how he had to win her over. The talk that she had with her dad that helped her decide to give the relationship with Josh a try. And then, they suddenly bring Diggie back and he doesn't really have to do much at all. This was ridiculous. They should never have had her choosing him. The way that Josh and Maddie get along together was so nice. The moments that they shared were great. Their first date was the best. The writers made an enormous mistake with this episode. I totally agree with itzFantasy's review. However, I did like parts of the episode so my score is a bit higher.

Just awful.

[itzFantasy · 1/10 · 30 July 2016]

As an older person watching this show I get that its a kids show but Diggie x Maddie had run it's course... Are you kidding me? After he did that whole spectacle about "Having to see the world" and "This town is too small' last season he just comes back and she gets back together with him instantly? You would think the clearly feminist writers of this show would've actually tried to make her a smart woman and stay with Josh but no, cause screw a good relationship if you can get back together with your trashy ex after he literally chose Australia over you. They should've at least made him earn getting back together with her... yet it literally took 1 episode.

If Friends managed to pulled the will-they-won't-they for 8 seasons, I think this show could've managed a few more episodes or at least till next season.

Needless to say this is my stopping point for this show. Most episodes are painful to watch but this pushed me over the edge. This isn't about "ship wars" it's about common sense.

This episode made me stop watching

[pinkparis-50380 · 1/10 · 27 December 2021]

I loved Josh with all my heart. He did everything for maddie. He conquered he fear if heights for her. He was so selfless. And digging was so so selfish. So when this episode aired I thought for sure she'd pick josh, after all he won all the voting. Then diggie comes up and sings a song, and all is forgiven? After everything that diggie did to her she picks him? Like Josh was clearly the better option. I was soo pised. I loved the mosh Chemistry was way better, And he has a boyfriend was just way better. So after this episode the show just went downhill and the last season was just really boring not much happening. #moshforlife.

This episode shouldn't even exist.

[ZekT · 1/10 · 23 June 2020]

I get that its a sitcom type show but Miggie had run it's course. After he did that whole spectacle about "I got to see the rest of the world" and "My home town is too small, there's so much more out there" last season, this is just an idiotic decision by bringing him back so he can get back together with Maddie instantly. I wanted The writers of this show to actually make Maddie be the intelligent person she is and think about it clearly so she could make the right decision that was with Josh but no, cause they screwed up a good relationship in the very end. The whole story that involved that If you can get back together with your ex after he literally chooses AUSTRALIA over you and then you can forgive him for everything he did a season in less than 1 episode, was for the last straw as a viewer. It literally took a two parter episode to ruin the whole season for me.

Most episodes are painful to watch after this episode so It's just wrong and sad to watch.