Belief: The Possession of Janet Moses (2015) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
18 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Sad, so sad
veerle-3319223 April 2021
Warning: Spoilers
As I have always been fascinated by possession and excorcism I couldn't resist watching this documentary. Even though I was warned by other reviews. Let's start with the story. Janet is a young women from a close knit Maori family in New zealand. She is known as a happy go lucky spirit who's biggest problem in life is asthma. Things change after her partner, and father of her two young children, cheats on her and her grandmother dies. On a family party in a hotel she shows signs of depression, staring in front of her without emotion and desinterested in the party she worries her family. In the hotel the family steals a statue of a lion, one of a set off 2 ,that holds symbolic and spiritual meaning for them. They take it home with them to the house of one of Janet's aunties. Janet still seems withdrawn, stressed and worried. The family decides to call a family meeting to discuss the atypical behavior of Janet and decide to call on a Maori priest. He says that they shouldn't have stolen the lion and that Janet will heal when they reunite the lion with his twin. He says Janet is cursed/possesed by the lion for separating them. On the trip to reunite the lions Janet suddenly becomes angry at her surviving grandmother and shows very aggressive behavior, threatening to kill her grandmother. After the lions reunion she seems calmer and the priest leaves the family. Although Janet seems calm, tired and worn out, but calm and coherent the family is not satisfied. They don't seem to be able to rest until Janet is a shining example of total bliss. The movie describes this restlessness as love. I have my doubts. Seems to me that if they had let her be sad, angry and withdrawn accompanied by some extra attention, good food, sleep, a daily walk and regular counseling for a few months, what followed could have been avoided. Trust me, you will wish they had just accepted the situation instead of trying to 'cure' her. It is hard even to try and describe what comes next. The extended family gathers at the house, they put her to bed and start chanting 'go in peace and love' trying to excersise a demon from a girl that was totally calm just 5 minutes ago. Can you imagine being depressed after a bad break in your love life and the death of a lost one? And your family surrounding you with twenty committed to exercise your demon by rithmic chanting and stomping of feet? Just that noise would be enough to push your nerves to the edge. Not surprisingly her symptoms start to become worse. She becomes more agitated, talking to herself and starts showing signs off psychosis, muttering within herself about things that seems nonsensical. This encourages the delusion of the family who dubbele their efforts to excorcise her. They start giving her copious amounts of water and putting her in cold showers because 'the demon does not like hot water.' In one off those showers Janet throws up. Her family says she threw up the demon, they mop op the spit and declare, the only, bathroom a no go zone. At this stage everyone has been without sleep for 2 days. They have hardly eaten. Some of them haven't seen their children. So they decide to go get the kids. Increasing the population off the small house in thirty degree weather. Turning the house into an oven where no one is allowed to use the bathroom. Doing there business in diapers and towels. Janet isn't well. So they keep trying to excorcise the demon. The third/fourth day mass histeria seems to take a deadly hold of the family. They start seeing demons everywhere, in their other children too. They keep force feeding Janet liters and liters of water. When she doesn't swallow it anymore they just start throwing cups and plates full of water over her and her bed. Another girl is deemed possessed too and they start doing the same to her. After 5 days of this insanity we have 2 young woman being forced to the floor by their family, held down with the strength of 5 to 10 people, begging their family to stop drawning them. They do not listen. Instead of turning off the ever running water they drill a hole in the floor to relieve the flood that is all over the house. And they keep chanting, throwing water, force feeding water, yelling at the girls, sorry, the demon and pinning them down. When Janet actually draws on dry land after undergoing extreme water boarding for a week she swallows her own tongue causing her jaw to shut down. The family breaks her jaw open to give her more water and she dies. You would thing the tragic,pointless death off their loved one by their own hands would break this psychotic frenzy. But no, they keep going with the other girl. Finally, after almost a week, a spiritual advisor comes knocking, seeing the state of the family he declares the evil has gone and orders the second girl to the hospital. Hereby ending this tragic series of events. 5 off the family members where found guilty ofher death and received communist service punishments.

The documentary was well made, they capture a devasted community that fell victim to some kind of mass hysteria in a great serrenity. A serrenity uncommon for true crime drama. You can feel the the struggle of the two main victims piercing heart and soul. Interviews with bystanders capture your own understanding, grieve and doubts while seeing this happen to otherwise normal people. They only force judt one tear jecking moment. The message would have been clear whitout it but as a whole they showed restrained and respect for the people involved. They did not resort to a gritty, grindhouse horror look for which I thank them.

Because this is not a horror film. It is a portrait off the human condition.

Personally I am left with an overwhelming feeling off pointlessness. And although I have no doubt that nobody started this thing with the intention of hurting Janet I cannot (yet?) forgive them. It seems to me that if certain members of the family had checked their ego and had simply accepted that their perfect, warm family could be affected by something as unsettling as depression, Janet would still be alive and able to be a mother to her children.

Rest in peace dear girl.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Haunting but...
borgolarici31 December 2020
Basically the story of yet another woman sacrificed on the altar of her family's beliefs and internal dynamics. The documentary is well done but these things should be condemned with a lot more decision.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A film determined to reinforce myths rather than undertake any meaningful analysis
visitorq274 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This 'documentary' is determined to sensationalize and reinforce the myth of 'makutu' rather than offer any real insight into the tragic death of young women Janet Moses at the hands of her own family, who believed she was possessed by a 'makutu', or Maori curse, and ruthlessly drowned her to death in an exorcism ceremony.

The film contains dramatizations of the events that occurred, that are powerful and generally well done. However, where it falls short is in the commentary by those who had nothing to do with the case but happily offer their 'expert' opinions on what was happening to Janet.

Every single one these people support the theory that Janet was cursed by makutu. The film doesn't once seek the opinion of any actual medical professional such as a psychologist or neurologist, that could offer an informed view as to Janet's condition, but instead replies on the bias views of spiritual leaders, new-age types and pseudo scholars. Janet clearly suffered from a serious mental breakdown and the fact that nothing is done to explore this does no justice to her or her family.

A sad missed opportunity that in it's efforts to be cultural sensitive to Maori at all costs legitimizes bizarre and dangerous believes.
24 out of 51 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
This woman was murdered by superstition
misscath-0266817 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Very sad story about a woman who was severely mentally ill and being treated for some sort of Maori curse or possession. Did no one in this family think to call a doctor or psychologist when she kept getting worse? Praying over someone is fine but it's not enough, if they are having hallucinations. What was the sense of forcibly holding her in the shower under cold water? She was in danger from the beginning and this family killed her.
11 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Frustrating and depressing
rpaleschi18 April 2020
This is basically the story of a woman with severe mental health issues who is tortured by her family to rid her of a "demon" rather than get her any real medical help.

There is no basis for their mumbo jumbo beliefs and the family come across as loving people, but also a bunch of bloody savages.

This movie is depressing with no real redeeming features. One to avoid!
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Well worth your time to view.
mastrait8 December 2017
This documentary only gets 5.3 stars on IMDb, I give it 9 stars. It is probably one of the best and most disturbing documentaries I've ever watched.

There is a lot of very good reenacted scenes, not easy to do unless you have superb actors and a great director. Which this movie has an abundance of.

It also has a lot of footage of the actual people who were involved in the investigation and trial of this tragic event. Their incite is very important and is well balanced.

This was not sensationalized but really digs into what happened. It is hard to watch for sure, but without really getting a sense of what Janet really endured, along with this poor family, it would not serve any of them well.

I encourage you to try to not jump to quick judgment on these folks, that is what most of us do when we do not understand cultures different than our own, or people we really no little of.
17 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Absolute Nonsense
graceharata29 July 2019
The movie depicted a storyline that was nowhere near what happened. It's sad that the director went against the whanau's wishes to not exploit the life of Janet Moses. They went off of stories and he said she said instead of full factual evidence. I'm appalled in the least that this was even created. If you want a thriller that states it's based on a true story when in actuality it's not true at all, then by all means watch it. But personally after watching that I would rather eat my own foot.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
what the hell is this?
minnieweathernatalie9 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I know cultures have their own spirituality and superstitions...but what the hell? Their attempt to cleanse their family member...resulted in them water-boarding her to death and a packed house crapped their pants for 5 days while doing it. This seems like an exploitation of whatever people this is. Idk what else to take away from this ughh
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Slow and boring nonsense justifies murder
dariaovcharova21 February 2021
First of all its super slow. This movie deserves no more than 45-50 mins of your time. The plot itself is interesting. But we get zero understanding from psychological point of view wth was going on with the girl and how the whole family can turn into psychos. It almost felt like they were trying to justify a gruesome murder. Waste of time.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The line between mental illness and religious acceptance.
It's funny, how in an era where we grew up hearing about Gee-Hadist terrorism since we were children--living through one in NYC in 2001--and we still can't talk about it nearly 20 years later... because we are too busy importing the idealism that lead to that terrorist attack in the hopes it will generate more votes for 'our' team.

Well, if 'our' team really included 'you', then 'you' would be allowed to discuss the topic of religious fanatics outside of one religious (Christianity) like hollywood is trying to force you to do, by paying millions and billions of dollars from who? the same people with idealism that lead to the 2001 incident we no longer talk about. Try thinking for yourself. If you're going to watch something telling you how to think, then you probably didn't know how to in the first place. You should stop watching if that is something you need instructions on... there's a reason they don't teach it in school, you're suppose to know how already: CRITICAL THINKING.
5 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Sad and beautiful
joannmwoodward10 July 2018
I really don't understand the harsh reviews! In my opinion, this is a beautifully done film. It is a heart breaking story, but also such an interesting insight into Maori culture and spirituality. I thought the actors did an amazing job with the dramatic reenactments. Give it a watch, it's worth it!
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Slow and fearful documentarians
blondesensed17 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This is a documentary about a Maori family who tried an at home exorcism on a mentally ill young mother and killed her in the process.

When you think 'exorcism' you think of the kind you see in movies where a priest goes into a room and fights the devil. The subject of the exorcism writhes, vomits, fights and it looks painful and it can take a long time, but then it's over. Janet's torture lasted weeks. Possibly months or years when you think of the lack of adequate medical care. It is a gruelling journey.

My problem with this documentary is that the makers were utterly fearful of pressing the participants on their actions and beliefs. In Maori culture, there is a demon called Makutu and this was what the family believed was the cause of what seemed to be Janet's untreated schizophrenia. I can respect those beliefs. I don't agree with them and think they should have combined their faith with mental health treatment, but what I cannot respect is the fact this family made up their beliefs and rituals as they went along and they were barely questioned about it during the two hours.

Experts testified at trial the things they did and said had no basis in any Maori tribe or culture, but the interviewers never bring this up with the family. I would argue they denigrate Maori culture and people by disseminating these ideas and defending their actions and the wider abuse of Janet and other family members (numerous children were harmed during the exorcism) by not separating this conduct from real traditions developed over thousands of years. Just like the people of Salem who burned women at the stake as witches claimed to be acting for the church, it was a perversion of the faith.

There is also a young lady interviewed heavily in the documentary, I'm not sure if she is 18, if she is she is very childlike, but she is clearly traumatised and doesn't want to be there, hiding under a hoodie the whole time. It feels exploitative watching her. It's also unclear who is interviewing the participants and ends up being confusing. The setup is a police interrogation room but the camera is professional quality and from the POV of the interviewer. The interviewer is blurred and labelled 'interrogator' but one of the participants says at one point 'I wish I could say this to the police' so the person she is speaking to is not a police officer, the 'interrogator' is in no way, shape or form 'interrogating' and the questions are of a compassionate nature, not fact finding. Is it even legal to create footage and represent it as a police interview? Maybe New Zealand just has very high quality interview room cameras and very odd interrogation techniques?

This is a very important story that needs to be heard, but you will be justifiably angry by the end. I really, really hope that the attention this case didn't make water exorcisms something that other people try at home. I wouldn't be surprised if the family themselves didn't try it again. RIP Janet. I have never meant that so wholeheartedly about another soul.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A different documentary
kurtnorthman16 July 2018
I loved this!!! Shows the the thin red line between mentally illness and the peoples religious understanding of it. Not worth a 5. I gave this 9
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Ignore the negative reviews and watch it asap
INTJMind3 April 2019
Ratings on IMDb have always been a mystery to me, and I don't think this is ever going to change, I wasn't going to watch this documentary because as always I trust the ratings -although I know I shouldn't- but they kind of give me an idea on how good or bad a movie is, specially when the number of voters is very few as in this case, but I couldn't resist watching it because the plot is so real and I've heard about hundreds of incidents of that kind all over the world, so I watched it and I wasn't disappointed, and I think you should too. These kind of things happen everywhere and in every religion, some people only believe what they believe in and they blindly act upon it not giving any attention to science or medicine. In my opinion this documentary should be watched by everyone because it's educational in the first place, I don't care if it's reenactment and I am not gonna say that the actors did deliver an amazing performance, because it doesn't matter, the message from this document is what matters, it's critical and it could save someone's life one day. P.S. If the documentary makes you angry at what the family did, do not take it out on the documentary! Rating it low is unfair and it'll result in a lot of people missing out on watching it. Also people who say the documentary are forcing you on believing in superstitions, that's not true, they're just telling the story as it happened and as it was told, you have a brain to think for yourself what's wrong and what's right!
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Superbly put together documentary
kiwaussie17 October 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Found this at a film festival purely by accident. I was familiar with the story having grown up in NZ. It's really well done, but this film made me so angry. My plot summary would be as follows:

"Family in the outskirts of Wellington murder one of their own because she is suffering from depression."

Whether they thought they were trying to help or not is irrelevant, they murdered someone because of a religious belief. ISIS do the same. It was such a shame that there was nobody with an education in the room that day.

That aside, the acting was amazing, particular by Kura Forrester (normally a comedienne - so this was a great change of pace for her!). If you get a chance to see it, do so - it's refreshing to see a film that doesn't depict life in New Zealand as perfect.
12 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
What an extraordinary documentary, what a complicated situation...
RosanaBotafogo15 October 2021
What an extraordinary documentary, what a complicated situation, how belief and faith can at the same time emanate so much strength and so much pain, love and hate, life and death, I was able to feel very sorry for this family, it seemed impossible, unlikely, but they killed for love to think that they were saving the, so much so that the sentence of the condemned family was social services, revolting what the church and certain sects can cause...
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Very well done
jackiemcdonald-8523921 October 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I couldn't tell if the people bring interviewed were actors or the real life people involved. Every actor and non actors were amazing. Very sad because her death could have been prevented if someone spoke up and broke from the mass hysteria going on.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
I loved it and it made me cry.
ktpelzfeltner15 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
It's crazy to think how long ago the witch trails were. You think that kind of thing wouldn't happen anymore. Well in 2007 it did happen again. I had to stop it in the middle just to google if it really happened because I just can't believe it. Now I really do not know which parts are accurate or if some is false but it really did hit me. I think a lot of us go through times in our lives where we are really afraid of something supernatural. And I also have a very close relative with schizophrenia which really does scare me a lot of the time, if it was up to her she really would go along with all of this and truely she believes her disorder is all from demons. It's so sad that all it took is one other person to say it's not them, it's a demon to a loving spiritual family, and this is the result.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed