First off, the title. Making "gay" a noun reinforces that people who are attracted to persons of their own gender are different and need a label. But ten minutes into episode 1 you realize the extreme shallow and superficial nature of this program, since the only contestants they really want are either young and cute or fit the gay stereotype. The repartee between the judges is horribly catatonically boring and the pauses are long and awkward. The host Jonathan speaks like a puppet with unmatched fake emotion. So fake. I just know he was picked on in school, and not for being gay, but for being creepy. There is little real "competition" as contestants are asked the same questions over and over and over and......time to fix a sandwich. The sets are cheap and the audio is so awful they didn't even bother to tell people in the background to stop laughing. There is virtually no off-the-set interaction among the contestants. There isn't even any fake drama - c'mon, 12 gay guys on a show together. 90% of it is Jarl and Michael Billy jawing clichés like "you guys are all awesome" (but one of you really stinks) and "this is the hardest decision I've ever had to make" (but I'm picking the cute one). One of the rare entertaining bits is them being unintentionally hilarious by saying "we'll see you next year" well, not on television, baby. Seems that other people noticed how truly painful it was to watch this sludge, crowned by the fact that the host got the winner's name wrong and they didn't bother with another take or editing in post-production. Waaait... post-production, what's that ? Cousin It did that in his basement during lunch. Some shows are funny to watch because they're bad, but these people take themselves waaaaay too seriously to allow even a glint of hope. It's not even worth watching because it's so bad. It's just.......boring.