Air (2023) User Reviews

One of the most realistic war movie from the last decades.

[azarovilya · 10/10 · 21 January 2024]

A realistic dramatic picture of war. Rare in its realism and atmosphere. Many thanks to the filmmakers for their hard work.

Alexey German Jr. Has repeatedly received high awards at the best festivals in the world. The director's father, Alexey German Sr., is a great director known for his stunning realism films of the 30-50s, the terrible Stalinist era of the Soviet Union. The son inherited and developed this style of realism and immersion in history. For a long time in the post-Soviet space, war films were characterized by aggressive agitation (propaganda) or the use of heavy themes to attract the public. In this film, the ugly truth about war and tragedy, without pathos and slogans.

Among other things, the strengths of the film are the excellent work of the production artists and real, authentic wartime equipment.

Breathing Life into War: 'Air' Soars with Emotional Depth and Historical Sincerity

[azizkhujakk · 10/10 · 9 February 2024]

The film "Air," directed by Alexey German Jr., represents a significant achievement in Russian cinema, especially in the genre of war dramas. The plot immerses us in 1942, on the Leningrad Front, where a group of young female pilots joins a fighter regiment protecting the "Road of Life." From their arrival, they face a cold reception from the men, including the regiment commander, Lieutenant Colonel Astafyev, brought to life by Sergey Bezrukov, who doubts the wisdom of sending them to certain death due to their lack of preparation.

What makes "Air" outstanding is its ability to tell the story through the personal experiences of each character. The film skillfully uses close-ups, allowing actors to convey the emotions of their characters almost without words, which places high demands on their skill and involves the viewer in the intimate moments of the characters. This is not just a technical approach but a way to convey deep feelings and internal conflicts of the characters to the audience.

At the same time, "Air" is not without flaws. The film could have gained greater depth if the development of characters had been more balanced. Focusing on the main heroine at the expense of the stories of other characters creates a feeling of incompleteness in the world that the film tries to recreate. Some plot lines seem underdeveloped or overly simplified, reducing the effect of the viewer's empathy.

Nevertheless, "Air" deserves high praise for its sincerity and effort to immerse the viewer in the realities of wartime through the personal stories of its characters. It is a film that makes you think and empathize, highlighting the sacrifices and heroism in times of war. Alexey German Jr., drawing on his personal family heritage and a deep understanding of history, creates a film that, despite some shortcomings, remains an important contribution to the genre of war drama.

The movie from 1940s

[sashabraulov · 10/10 · 23 January 2024]

One of the most poignant films by Alexei Herman Jr.

Wonderful acting, wonderful work of the cameramen... I highly recommend it for viewing.

Very memorable and intense scenes with fights in the air. At the same time, without the affected pathos that is characteristic of such a kind of films.

At the same time, a love line is surprisingly intertwined in the film, which does not in the least trivialize other storylines. Everything harmoniously combines and develops, while the storylines do not interfere with each other, but complement each other perfectly.

The main disadvantage of cinema for me is the duration of creation. I had to wait a very long time). But it was worth it. The film is beautiful.