9/11: Heroes of the 88th Floor: People Helping People (TV Movie 2011) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Remarkable Story of Heroes Frank DeMartini and Pablo Ortiz
Michael_Elliott5 September 2011
9/11: Heroes of the 88th Floor (2011)

**** (out of 4)

Remarkable documentary about Frank DeMartini and Pablo Ortiz, two Port Authority workers who instead of fleeing the North Tower on 9/11 decided to climb up and look for more survivors even though they were just five floors from the impact site. Both DeMartini and Ortiz would end up dying in the towers but not before saving 77 people. As most people old enough to remember the events, I still have every memory of what I was doing on 9/11/01 and no matter how many times I see the footage I can't help but get emotional. The evil that was struck on that day is well-known but the remarkable thing is how many heroic stories are out there and this here is certainly an amazing one. There were several times throughout the documentary where it was made clear that both DeMartini and Ortiz could have gotten out of the building alive but instead they kept climbing up while everyone else was trying to get down. Even after rescuing dozens of people they could have left but instead they kept trying to save more. One often wonders what they would do in this type of situation and then you realize that only people extremely special could make these decisions. The documentary interviews the wife of DeMartini (who was in the building with him) and the ex-wife of Ortiz but also many of the people that they saved. Whenever one hears stories from the survivors you can't help but be amazing at what they had to go through in order to reach safety. All of them make it clear that they probably would have died had it not been for these two men and hearing their stories was quite remarkable. The documentary not only features the interviews but there's also a re-enactment of the events. The drama level and intensity of this footage is pretty strong and hard to watch at times. I always get rather depressed when I watch these sad events but in the end it's also very uplifting knowing that these heroes are around us. You probably don't know who they are but their stories are always fascinating and seeing people willing to give their lives to save others is something that will hopefully inspire others. This documentary is a remarkable story that should be seen by everyone.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Dramatizations...
rck-712 September 2011
Once again, the BBC is at it with yet another "documentary" that combines real footage with dramatizations and re-creations. The actual footage is nothing new and as been seen time and time again. The fake "footage" is just offensive. It's B-rate acting with mediocre sets. It assumes the viewer has zero imagination and requires every single thing to be "re-created" on screen.

This show represents the worst of two worlds. It can't provide actual footage of the event (inside the twin towers) and can't spend the money required to recreate the event. The end result is just an average "documentary" with some poorly-shot dramatizations. Why we need these fake shots is beyond me. Anybody with an imagination could easily visualize scenes without these awful dramatizations.

The only interesting part of this show (I can't call it a documentary with a straight face) is the REAL people talking about the events. Their stories are interesting and emotional.

Chris Noth narrates this train wreck. His voice is sorely wasted on this abysmal "performance."
3 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed