A film on the refugee crisis is definitely needed. So I appreciate the writers and directors courage on this issue.
As much as I like the film, I will mainly address the concerns I had while watching the film, so it might seem a bit harsh. (I do recommend this film with all my heart.
The film is certainly informative. The conversations between the girl and the smuggler have an additional explanatory function. I sensed the effort in explaining to, sometimes confronting with, the western audience. Some of these conversations made me think of the real world politics and how the refugee crisis incited the right extremists in Europe later on. But that's not the film's flaw. It's the subject itself.
Another concern I had while watching: I could not help but notice that the girl is in fact, a relevantly "privileged" one among the refugee. Her family was rich before the war, and her sisters all seem to have received very good education. But this again another hard class issue that is hard to confront in life. I am not sure if this is a theme that the writer intentionally want me to pick up, or I am just coming from my own background.
But the film does remind me to face the tough questions.
As much as I like the film, I will mainly address the concerns I had while watching the film, so it might seem a bit harsh. (I do recommend this film with all my heart.
The film is certainly informative. The conversations between the girl and the smuggler have an additional explanatory function. I sensed the effort in explaining to, sometimes confronting with, the western audience. Some of these conversations made me think of the real world politics and how the refugee crisis incited the right extremists in Europe later on. But that's not the film's flaw. It's the subject itself.
Another concern I had while watching: I could not help but notice that the girl is in fact, a relevantly "privileged" one among the refugee. Her family was rich before the war, and her sisters all seem to have received very good education. But this again another hard class issue that is hard to confront in life. I am not sure if this is a theme that the writer intentionally want me to pick up, or I am just coming from my own background.
But the film does remind me to face the tough questions.