Fish Story (2009) Poster

(2009)

User Reviews

Review this title
26 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
"Fish Story" - Intertwining stories over the course of 60 years
ChungMo17 January 2010
Smart and witty movie about how a forgotten punk rock song (with a mystery within the song) links the lives of several characters who mostly never meet each other. The elements include, of course, a failed punk rock band in the late 1970's, a meek college student in the 1980's, a doomsday cult in 1999, a ferry hijacking in 2009, and a trio of people in a used record shop in a deserted city awaiting a comet strike in 2012. Plus some flashbacks to post WW2 Japan. Much of the movie revolves around the idea of a "champion of justice"

The movie is paced with a natural style so despite the sci-fi aspect the whole film is very low key. Virtually no special effects. That's not to say that there are no hidden pleasures, especially during the ferry hijacking which has excellent action scenes. The film is well-shot, well-acted and well-written. The music is good as well.

An unexpected little gem.
21 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
New Wavish Comedy
crossbow010627 June 2009
This story is about a comet which is due to hit the earth in a matter of hours and how a song from 1975 called "Fish Story" will save the world in 2012. How? Thats part of the fun in watching the film. The film has some comedic moments in that you have references to superhero(ine) series from Japan, as well as other cultural mores. You see what appears to be a series of unconnected events somehow gel. The song itself is a proto punk song, recorded before the Sex Pistols, and its actually a good song. The acting goes all over the map, as there are flashbacks with disparate characters, but it is pretty much all good. Whatever the ending, you have to stay for it to see how things tie together. The world could come to an end (Japan would be pretty much submerged) if the comet hit, so just watch. It has a kind of new wavish sensibility, especially the scenes with the band who recorded "Fish Story". Not perfect, it drags slightly at times, but its worthwhile. I recommend it.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
What did I just watch?
Leofwine_draca27 April 2013
I have to say, FISH STORY is a very strange film. It's a Japanese apocalyptic tale featuring four separate story lines that are woven together in such a way that'll have you scratching your head and trying to figure out how they all intertwine. It's all very low key, with zero sci-fi elements and an extremely slow pacing that's doubtless to put off plenty of viewers expecting something more, well, energetic.

However, something about this kept me watching. It's the sense of whimsy, perhaps, or the sheer long-winded shaggy-doggedness of the storytelling. The fact that the production values are high, the script is very funny, and the actors nail the characters, too. About halfway through, I relaxed a little when I realised I was enjoying what I was watching, and then I started having fun.

Things get better right up until the big reveal at the ending, which is so stupendously good that I can say, right here and right now, that FISH STORY features one of my favourite endings in a film, full stop. It's that good; a tremendous resolution, like that of THE SIXTH SENSE, that turns the whole film around and makes you realise that, actually, this is a great little film; unique and uniquely entertaining with it.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
What if I told you that a song would save the world...
Koyama2210 April 2010
In short: Fish Story will take you on a wild, improbable ride that will leave you smiling once the credits begin. It is a film that rewards multiple viewings as it will leave you thinking and desiring to watch it again almost immediately. Great acting and an incredibly well put together set of events leads to a movie that definitely should be seen. My favorite film of 2009 so far.

If you haven't seen Fish Story yet, you may want to stop reading this review after this paragraph. There aren't spoilers in my review, but it is one of those movies that is best viewed with no preconceived ideas about the plot. Watch the film and enjoy the twists and turns that the story takes. It is a ride that most will undoubtedly enjoy.

Fish Story is about a punk band named Gekirin that recorded a single called "Fish Story" in 1975, a year before the Sex Pistols popularized punk music. Despite knowing that their music won't sell, Gekirin and their supportive producer decide to record this song knowing that one day it will impact the life of at least one person. The film jumps around different time periods ranging from 1975 to 2012, where a meteor is on a collision course for Earth. Going through the movie, the viewer is shown different stories without knowing what is going on or how they factor in to the main narrative.

Each part of the film is captivating, despite the fact that we don't really know what is going on in the film as a whole. Every new story reveals a piece to the puzzle and when they all come together at the end you'll feel like jumping up, running outside, and telling everyone that they NEED to watch Fish Story. Then you'll want to watch it again. This movie has one of the most satisfying endings that I have ever experienced.

I love the cast in this film. Acting was solid, but no award-winning performances. I particularly enjoyed Omori Nao, who played the producer that discovered Gekirin as well as a music shop owner whose store is open despite the pending destruction of Earth. I also thought Kora Kengo, playing Gekirin's singer, and Moriyama Mirai, playing a guy trained since birth to be a "champion of justice" (his action sequences were really cool) stood out. Based on a novel by Isaka Kotaro and adapted by Hayashi Tamio, Fish Story has a great script. Also, the cinematography is good (though certainly not groundbreaking) as well as the directing. Music is great, especially the song "Fish Story" which was written specially for the film.

I can't really name many faults with this film other than it was a little bit draggy in some spots. Also, some may not enjoy the girl's (Tabe Mikako) overenthusiastic acting but I found that it fit her character. The film was just under two hours, but I felt that length was not a problem.

Fish Story jumps around to different genre's (thriller, martial arts action, comedy, music documentary, etc) which I think keeps the movie incredibly engaging, constantly changing up the pace. During my second viewing, I couldn't help but think that I would enjoy watching a film that just took any one of the multiple stories presented and made it feature-length. All of them are that interesting. Having each individual story in the span of a single film, though, is what helps make Fish Story a magical experience. From beginning to end, you will be engaged and entertained. I advise everyone to see Fish Story.

--John Kincaid @ jkfilmjapan.wordpress.com/
44 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Nutshell Review: Fish Story
DICK STEEL20 August 2010
What the Fish!!! So I'd thought that it'll be somewhat of a chore to sit through almost two hours late into what's left of a Friday night with Fish Story, directed by Yoshihiro Nakamura and based on the novel by Kotaro Isaka. But I was utterly blown away, leaving me feet tapping and head bobbing all the way through to the end credits roll, and a smile plastered on my face all the way home. It's an Armageddon film done with pizazz and creative flair, and not to mention that dash of comedy and great music, that I'd feel is a hard act for the rest of the festival lineup to keep within touch for the Audience Choice. I know it's still early in the festival, but Fish Story has established itself as one of the best films I've watched this year, and one of the rare few that will likely give you that familiar fuzzy feeling after you've sat through an awesome film.

The story unveils itself in non-linear fashion, and somewhat like Sandcastle, has a little lingering mystery - a punk rock song that contains a minute's silence - to what it actually all means, which comes altogether as a climax when everything gets to show hand. It tackles that wonderment of how events in the past will inevitably shape what's to come in the future, even if it doesn't make sense in the present. And Nakamura takes this premise, and through the narrative structure enables the audience to experience just that. We're brought from timeline to timeline that at the point of presentation the scenes seem disparate to one another and don't make much sense, but contains enough in their individual segments to entertain.

Hinging on a song called Fish Story that's performed by a punk rock band called Gekirin, it's amazing just what this one song can do to carry the entire film, not only because it sounds great (those not into punk rock, I'd think you'd find it hard not to enjoy this, especially when the cast members go into overdrive in their performance), but has an intriguing story on how it got produced, that forms the bulk of the film. Like most songs that seem fated to fade into obscurity without proper promotional or marketing power or fans to ensure some longevity, or worst, a band that's being condemned as talentless and to be let go by their record company, little do the band members know that one day this song will just about save humankind.

And in that respect, with Japanese fantasy/sci-fi stories in a similar mould such as the Twentieth Century Boys trilogy, Fish Story tackles the same doomsday scenario, and that plot element of a song of hope yet unfulfilled and unexplained, in a succinct fashion that doesn't meander unnecessarily. Spanning almost 40 years, we're treated to one off stories such as a timid driver (Gaku Hamada, resembling a youthful looking Jackie Chan with that hairdo he spots) who finds some resolve to stand up for himself and for others after being told of a prophecy about saving the world, and another tale where a young cook onboard a ferry saving a schoolgirl (Mikako Tabe) and other passengers from gun totting hijackers. They're as disparate as they can get, and if you're wondering just what's going on when you see recurring characters or instances in each, I'd say to enjoy the moments crafted, from a tinge of horror to an all out action-adventure, before the payload at the end truly hits you.

All these and more, based upon the single introduction set in the year 2012, where the world is threatened by a comet on a collision course for Earth, and a group of strangers gathering in a niche music shop. It's 5 hours to impact, and the shopkeeper whips out the rare Fish Story vinyl record for them all to give a listen to, thinking that it's quite futile to head toward Mount Fuji to avoid an impending tsunami scenario, and of course hoping for a miracle to come from a country that on one hand is not expected, and on the other totally plausible for the maths and science experts it produces.

There are references to other Japanese icons such as Godzilla and Go-Rangers, and for fans of Hollywood films, you'll probably be able to identify the oh-so-funny references and cheeky dissing of films from The Karate Kid (not the Jackie Chan version though), and Michael Bay's Armageddon, in fact "quoting" the what-if scenario of having the nuclear bombs on the comet, but yet to be exploded because, well, of what happened to Bruce Willis. Some stories are played out in tongue-in-cheek fashion, and they complement one another really well, which of course makes the finale all the more fun, especially when everything starts to make sense, and goes the full circle.
31 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Just see the film and don't worry about what it is or more importantly how it is, just know its worth your time
dbborroughs3 July 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Sweet charming shaggy dog story about how a song saves the world from destruction. This is film that is rather impossible to describe simply except with the opening line of this review (to say more would either give too much away or require too much explanation). Beginning in the last five hours before a giant comet is set to hit earth and wipe everyone out, the film starts in a record shop (still open because "its business hours") where a discussion of punk music leads to the album and song called A Fish Story. The film then spins out telling the story of the song, the group that created it and the sequence of events, of which it is but one part, that lead to the saving of the earth and to the men standing in the record store.

A frequently funny and smiling producing film this is a movie that will occasionally confuse you (you will wonder how it all ties together a mystery which remains until they reveal how it all ties together at the very end). It's a film with enough plot for five or six movies as threads are spun out and dropped once we see the relevant bits. We could have probably followed any one of them to the conclusion as well but many are just stops in the greater scheme of things.

I liked this whimsical little film a great deal. My only real reservations come from my unhappiness with the over selling that the film got from the staff of Film Festival where I saw it. Many people went out of there way to tell everyone how great it was. Don't get me wrong it's a good movie, but its not quite the religious experience that at least one person inferred. Over selling or not I don't think I would have ever raved about the film. It's too rambling and too fragmented to ever be a full meal of a movie (I think some of the threads, especially the story of the band, would have been a better focus), it's really good after dinner piece of chocolate. This isn't to say that there is anything wrong with it, there isn't, its more something that you need to discover for yourself and not have handed to you with an impossible level of expectations. See the film if you get a chance, just don't worry about how it is, just know its worth your time.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of those rare films that make movies worthwhile
stevejjackson20018 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I came across Fish Story by accident, recording it from late night Film 4 because it looked slightly odd - I mean, you never know, right? Well I came up trumps this time! This film tells a single linear story but breaks it up into sections and shows them in reverse links, to build up the story and create tension - will the world end? what had punk rock to do with it? why is the song cursed and why is there a 1 minute silent bit in it? All will be revealed, there are no cheats in this film and it has that rarest of creatures, a completely satisfying ending without loose ends. So why have some had difficulties? the structure is part of it, but so is the basic concept - that some major events (such as the efforts to destroy a comet shortly to obliterate earth) can be resolved in the tiny, tiny events and steps that combine to do so - the butterfly effect, if you will. Yes, major spoiler - the comet is destroyed! But we are telling the tiny stories here, the tiny grains of sand that rolled downhill to become the inexorable avalanche... So from a 1950's man desperate for work, translating a book into Japanese via a dictionary - to that book being recalled and pulped - to the single surviving copy - to a struggling band using that copy as the basis for their one and only album - which has their one great song - which has a mysterious silent minute - which allows a boy driving home to hear a scream - which lets him save a girl from rape - which leads to him marrying her - which leads to their child being raised as a defender of justice - who then saves a lost schoolgirl from murder - who is the maths genius that makes the plan to destroy the comet... The story is built in little layers until it makes a magnificent whole. i rate it 9/10, very rarely will i go that high. Enjoy!
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
My loneliness is a fish...
goto-kazoku-48 September 2013
In 1975, an unpopular punk band releases Fish Story. In 1982, a young man saves a young woman from a strange man. He listened to Fish Story before he saves. In 2009, a high school girl and chef meet on a ship. The ship is seajacked. In 2012, the limit of earth is 5 hours because of a comet. At a music shop, 2 men listen to Fish Story.

I am a fan of the original author of this film. I like coincidence which he writes. I had read the original book once before I watched the film. The story crosses several date. Therefore film is easier to understand than book. I was caught up in the scene which the story was related to the end. I could clear my head. The song, " if my loneliness is a fish…", is not far from my head. I think that the author is good at writing daily lives. I recommend everyone to watch the other films of the writer.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Unusual story
d_m_s14 February 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Fish Story has a very unusual and rather daft sounding plot that boils down to how a song recorded in 1975 saves the world. The film was on TV recently and when I read the plot I thought it sounded silly but for some reason was curious enough to watch the film.

As a curiosity piece, it is definitely worth a watch. It's a very unusual, multi-character, multi-era film that was a lot more enjoyable than expected. The down point for me, hence only giving it a 6, is because the sequences that focus on the band that wrote the song in the 70's are really dull and drag on for far too long. All the other plot lines (featuring a hostage situation on a ferry rectified by a kung-fu expert; a current-day record shop employee who discusses the said band's history with a customer and; a strange chance meeting seemingly orchestrated in part by a legend of a screaming girl in a song) are quite entertaining.

It's still silly overall, as you would expect from such a premise, but it was enjoyable nonetheless.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Punk music that saves the world
klausming10 September 2013
Japan 112m, Colour Director: Yoshihiro Nakamura; Cast: Vincent Giry, Gaku Hamada, Atsushi Itô, Kengo Kôra, Mirai Moriyama, Yoshihiro Nagata, Nao Ohmori, Mikako Tabe, Ken'ichi Takitô

It is 2012 and the world is about to end. An obscure Japanese punk song entitled Fish Story is possibly the only thing standing in the way of total annihilation of all life on the planet. The song, which includes a mysterious minute long break where the guitar solo should be, is cleverly interwoven into a number of intriguing stories throughout seven decades of seemingly disconnected events. As the end draws near, the stories are drawn together in spectacular fashion in the film's closing minutes. A brilliantly written, intelligent and charming multi-genre film, Fish Story is a tall tale brimming with fun, warmth and comedy that you will surely want to watch again, and again (Klaus Ming July 2013).
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Frustratingly close to being great... it just never clicked for me
Jeremy_Urquhart27 December 2021
Has a story that spans five different decades and about as many genres, too - action, comedy, music, thriller, and even sci-fi.

As it was all over the place, maybe it's natural that I'm a little mixed on it. It has a low-budget charm to it, sort of like Sion Sono's films, but like with that director sometimes, I found Fish Story occasionally looked distractingly cheap, with sitcom-esque lighting and some fairly flat cinematography (at times).

Some sequences work better than others. I'd say the only one that didn't really work for me was the section near the end focusing on the band who made the titular song. It dragged a bit, and I was also a little sick of the tune by then, to be honest.

But negativity aside, the premise is fun, and the other segments were largely enjoyable. Not in love with how it looked or the song in the end (you hear it so much!) but the film gets points for how unique and carefree it is in its attitude.

Can definitely see why it's become something of a cult movie, but I couldn't quite find myself loving it.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Will a punk song save the world?
Tweekums19 March 2013
Warning: Spoilers
In the opening scene of the film we learn that a giant comet is hurtling towards the earth; impact is inevitable and most people have fled to the high ground. One man has stayed behind and he is surprised to find that he isn't alone; there are two people in a record shop. He can't understand why they are there; who wants to buy music on the day the Earth is destroyed? The man behind the counter isn't concerned though; he is convinced that the Earth isn't doomed and more than that he is sure that an obscure punk record that nobody bought will somehow he the cause of the planet's salvation. The then see a variety of stories intertwined with the story of how the record came to be made and why there is a one minute silence in the middle of it. The stories involve a shy young man who stops his car and hears a woman being assaulted nearby, a group who foresee the end of the world and a school girl who falls asleep on a ferry, misses her stop and gets caught up in a hijacking only to be saved by a man who had just told her he had been raised to be a 'champion of Justice'.

This film was a lot of fun; it successfully mixed genres so that we had moments of action, a main plot that directly referenced the film 'Armageddon', plenty of laughs and finally a nice link that explained how each of the separate stories was related. I loved how the song, which the band thought was deep and meaningful, was based on a book that was so badly translated it no longer made sense. The actors seemed to do a fine job although relying on subtitles to understand them I can't judge them as well as somebody who speaks Japanese could. The way the story skips about kept things interesting; none of the individual stories went on too long and the way we weren't shown how each ended till the end of the film kept me eager to find out what happened in each case. Overall I'd say this is well worth watching if you want to watch something rather different and don't mind subtitled films.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Outstandingly Dull
AirPlant3 May 2010
Fish story –Back in the 70's proto-punk band 'Gekirin' records a single album that no one buys. They split up and go their separate ways, their seminal work destined for the scrapheap of musical history until fate plays a hand in rekindling the fire of rebellion. This is not a great movie. It's not even a good movie. It's not even a bad movie; shot through with tantalising flashes of brilliance. It is a very dull movie. Scenes which should in all sanity last a few seconds are pointlessly extended to the point where even the actors look embarrassed. The dialogue is appallingly dull –I can only suppose that the editor gave the actors the stuff he cut out; so consistent is the flat, monotonous character of the script. The acting is strange – as if the actors are constantly thinking of something else -Presumably, how long till they can escape; as will the audience.

I do not work for a film company I am not paid to write reviews
8 out of 91 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
If this film were a fish, it would be a big-hearted delightful fish
LunarPoise20 August 2011
A comet hurtles towards Earth, and Tokyo is abandoned as people head to high ground. A cynical one-time guru comes across two otaku, a record shop owner and his customer, who believe an obscure seventies song, Fish Story, will save the world. Many years earlier, a timid young man laments his inability to stand up for himself. Some years after that, a narcoleptic high school girl finds herself trapped on a hijacked ship, where a pastry chef is her best hope for a champion for justice.

Director Nakamura fashions a likable, engaging human drama here, but deserves most credit for the naturalistic performances he elicits from his actors. Too often Japanese films are sunk by TV-style mugging from the principles, but here, there is a subtlety and nuanced portrayal evident throughout the ensemble cast. In the band, leader Atsushi Ito and Vocal Kengo Kora have betrayal and remorse to deal with between them. The tension is played out in a series of looks and never over-cooked. Kiyohiko Shibukawa as the drummer takes a while to speak, but when he does, it is with reason and tact. It would be so easy to have proto-punk band members sink into spats and histrionics. These portrayals resonate and convince. Gaku Hamada is especially effective as the meek friend who loses the girl (a spooky, sexy Mai Takahashi) to his overpowering alpha-male 'friend.' His tormenting of himself in the car after that particular episode is tragic and comic in equal degree, and proves the trigger to his redemption.

The portmanteau structure is an over-used trope these days and detracts from the drama here. However, the film succinctly ties it all up at the end, and visually too - the lack of expository dialogue here as compared to other J-cinema is refreshing. A wonderful soundtrack tops it all off, the best use of a song for thematic purpose since Gimme Heaven. "Summer Days" is now the anthem to my August.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Saving the world with a smile
paul2001sw-127 September 2014
A punk song with some very obscure lyrics ends up saving the world: a fishy story indeed, and in the beginning, I was afraid that 'Fish Story' would turn out as one of those wilfully bizarre Japanese films which seem to be driven by nothing more than the director's desire to make something odd, no matter how little sense it makes. But the idiosyncratic charm of Yoshihiro Nakamura's movie soon grows on you. An odd combination of low budget movie, comic book story and sci-fi, set over 40 years, it nonetheless feels surprisingly unforced, and the longer I watched it, the larger the smile on my face. I even liked the song.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Review of "Fish Story"
cledorurun21 October 2013
The characters of this movie each lives in different generations of Japan. The members of an unsalable band named "Gekirin", a timid collage student, a high school girl who is caught up in sea-jack. First their stories each go on without any connection, however, facing the world's end, their stories starts to link.

First, the structure of story is full of surprise. For a long time I like the original novel before watching this film. Sometimes movies which based on novels betray the original fans, this movie do not. The casts each suit the characters (especially I like Masashi!) and the song which"Gekirin" performs is taken charge of Kazuyoshi Saito and more than just a movie sound.

This movie describes an imaginary miracle but shows us the importance of taking an action actively. When I am puzzled with something, the scene of Masashi always inspires me with courage.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Not really a story about fish
dorit-eliyahu14 November 2014
I am not the type of person to like Armageddon movies, but I truly enjoyed Fish Story. Though this movie is about how the end of the world is near, there are so many twists and unexpected turns of events, that I was fully immersed in the film for the two hours it played. And like other reviewers, by the end of it, a huge smile has been smeared on my face by the time the credits started rolling.

In this unique Japanese apocalyptic story, the world is going to end by meteor strike. But somehow, a punk song called Fish Story, with a mysterious a minute of silence in it, might just offer the salvation the whole world has despaired from expecting. To find out whether it will, and how, four seemingly separate tales need to be told. But don't worry, writer and director Yoshihiro Nakamura does a great job: the four tales are all entertaining on their own, and when I realized how they are connected, I was not disappointed at all. The unfolding events, though weird and unusual, made complete sense, and none of the plot twists seemed contrived in the least.

There aren't many downsides to this movie, and the only thing I would complain about is some scenes with slower pacing. But I enjoyed it so much that I still remember it fondly, many months later, as an extremely well-done, unique, and entertaining film.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Brilliant!
ElNapalmo12 September 2019
Brilliant! A series of unrelated characters and events, spanning 34 years, following some kind of butterfly effect allied to the seven degrees of separation, that end in saving the world from a comet. That final sequence is priceless.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
music saves the world.
vladiator23 November 2013
Fish Story mixes end-of-the world sci-fi scenario with rock band "mockumentary" and action-packed drama. If you like the movies about music, such as High Fidelity, This Is Spinal Tap, The Blues Brothers, you would appreciate this film which tells elaborate story about how the music saves the world.

The title song makes viewing very energetic and enjoyable. The official Trailer does not give this movie full justice but instead contains too many spoilers. However, I recommend to watch the video clip with the main song of this movie, available on YouTube (search for qGzIOs4jjVk string), and if you like that video clip, you'd love this movie. I watched it on on Netflix streaming, but I don't think it is available there anymore.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
"Mangatique" in the bad sense of the word
tpgill-968-717224 February 2011
I came to this movie with high expectations since I had heard it loudly praised. Alas -- Ozu, Kurosawa and Mizoguchi must be spinning in their graves. Each of them had more talent in his little finger than the entire staff and cast of this profoundly silly movie. We are supposed to be impressed by the way the 4 stories are twined together at the end -- in fact, all we get is a handful of mini-films, each of them fairly ridiculous, cobbled together by a flimsy plot device. Everyone acts like a plank -- they might as well be reading from scripts sometimes. And the characters are cardboard cut-outs who appear to have stepped off the page of a cheap manga. Look at the exaggerated poses in the martial arts scene for instance. The old man in the record shop gloating because the human race has no chance of survival was especially irritating, and the moment when he got punched in the face was a rare highlight. This is sophistication? This is avant-garde? This is life-affirming humanist cinema? Lord save us all.
3 out of 57 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
One Of Those Films You Just Can't Forget.
dondau125 July 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Flawed? Yes. Not Quite a Masterpiece? Certainly. But one of those rare films that renews your faith in how delightfully a motion picture can portray the human condition.

The Bad? Just two scenes. One which I would have cut severely and another where the Director let an actor down and should have gone for realism rather than comic petulance. You see if you can figure out which scenes I mean. *hint* One of them is with my favorite and brilliant Japanese character actress. An instance where a director took someone's strength and turned it into a weakness.

Having said that, all I can say watch the film and be thankful that there are directors and producers and actors who participate in film like this. The payoff is magnificent, but getting there is half the fun. I love the way the Japanese look at themselves...the way they hold the mirror up...the way they look at redemption.

Let me see if I can make this easier. If you like Wes Anderson, you'll probably like this film.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Fragmented story tied up despite all...
laojim29 March 2011
Warning: Spoilers
The fish story is indeed a punk rock song cribbed from a book by an incompetent translator who did not appreciate the significance of the English term, "Fish story." It is also a collection of seemingly diverse people loosely related to the punk rockers who cut the record. It is not at all clear what most of these people have to do with one another. All, however, is clarified in the end.

I don't know that I have ever seen a movie structured in quite this way in which the actual relationships among the characters is all sorted out in a sort of coda. There is a comet that seems about to destroy the planet until it is blown up by an Indian space crew with one Japanese member, who is, of course, related to all the punk rockers in an unlikely way.

The Japanese have made other films based on the "rock and roll song that saves the world," motif. I can't think of a single on from America but there must be one somewhere. The other great example that comes to mind is The 20th Century Boys III in which the hero gets to sing his song and there is a truly touching scene in which he is reunited with his niece whom he raised.

There is little or nothing so touching here and there is one loose end in which the first character on the screen, a man in an electric wheel chair wanders into a record store, open for no logical reason on the day that the comet strikes, but he is simply shuffled aside at the end and really has only the role of a sort of chorus.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Exciting
FounHUGO26 February 2019
Ideals, beliefs, philosophy, stories, actors, performances, settings, art, directors, editing... especially theme music and its related ones - all of which are among the best movies I have ever seen.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Still reminisce on this movie
georgiaboy20626 December 2021
I saw this movie years ago, and I revisit it in my mind every so often. I love it. The movie is well directed with it being greater in whole than its individual parts.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Glad I found it..
sheepnumber3424 December 2019
So nice to watch a different film..

So many stories in the world, everyone wants to tell them the same way..

Great story, title is irrelevant really on the grand scheme.. funny, heartwarming, clever, well acted and most enjoyable! Sweet.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed