I thought this was pretty good.
I will say out the gate that this seems a bit tamer than the book. Billy's drug addiction was kind of harrowing and a big part of the book at least for a decent portion of it, but the writers didn't delve all that deep in to it here, and I'm assuming he'll be sober and out of rehab in the next episode. They do have a whole 10 episodes in this show, so I'm just kind of confused why this wasn't explored a bit more? Maybe it doesn't have to be all that harrowing to watch, I just thought addition was captured a bit better in shows and movies like Euphoria and Trainspotting.
I also don't love some of the editing choices here. Why didn't we get to see The Six's performance to Teddy? This is a show about a band after all.
But for my criticisms and gripes, I've also found some things I quite like. I think Teddy constantly trying to get Daisy to work with him in the studio is great, and the two actors alongside each other in these scenes are quite good.
I also like that Camilla is pretty much the honorary sixth member of the band. Pete was an okay addition to the book, but he's such a minimal part of it in the grand scheme of things and I'm not too surprised that he was just cut out of the show going forward.
And what music and performances we do see are quite good. Hearing the music wasn't something I got to do for the novel, so hearing it come to life has so far been fun, and the production and musical performances are genuinely great.
And again, the acting and cinematography is very good!
This isn't 100% what I expected from the show so far, but it is fairly actuate to the book honestly. The few changes made haven't at all effected the story or how it will likely tie up. I'm not addicted to this series, but I am pretty excited to watch more.
I will say out the gate that this seems a bit tamer than the book. Billy's drug addiction was kind of harrowing and a big part of the book at least for a decent portion of it, but the writers didn't delve all that deep in to it here, and I'm assuming he'll be sober and out of rehab in the next episode. They do have a whole 10 episodes in this show, so I'm just kind of confused why this wasn't explored a bit more? Maybe it doesn't have to be all that harrowing to watch, I just thought addition was captured a bit better in shows and movies like Euphoria and Trainspotting.
I also don't love some of the editing choices here. Why didn't we get to see The Six's performance to Teddy? This is a show about a band after all.
But for my criticisms and gripes, I've also found some things I quite like. I think Teddy constantly trying to get Daisy to work with him in the studio is great, and the two actors alongside each other in these scenes are quite good.
I also like that Camilla is pretty much the honorary sixth member of the band. Pete was an okay addition to the book, but he's such a minimal part of it in the grand scheme of things and I'm not too surprised that he was just cut out of the show going forward.
And what music and performances we do see are quite good. Hearing the music wasn't something I got to do for the novel, so hearing it come to life has so far been fun, and the production and musical performances are genuinely great.
And again, the acting and cinematography is very good!
This isn't 100% what I expected from the show so far, but it is fairly actuate to the book honestly. The few changes made haven't at all effected the story or how it will likely tie up. I'm not addicted to this series, but I am pretty excited to watch more.