Dustin's pickup truck remains pristinely clean and shiny despite the amount of snow on the ground.
The inset pictures taken when they complete an item do not match the actual scene for which they posed.
During the Christmas-cookie scene, an exterior shot of Bel's dad's (Tom Arnold) house is shown. In the shot, the lights of Logan's rental car are still on although it's some time after he was shown pulling up.
The leads fail to take a picture of the item on the list involving the boy's mother.
When Belinda sees that one of the menu items at Jennie's Diner is named after her father's chili, she reads it as "Carl's Fire Crackling Chili", but the name on the menu board is "Carl's Crackling Fire Chili".