The show began on September 12, 2007 with Michael Riley and Chris McClain. The two would be the only members of the first season to do the show.
In the second season, regular cast members Taylor Scheid and Dane Forgione debuted. They would remain the main four cast members of the show for around a year.
In 2009, Michael moved to Austin, Texas where the show would remain for three years.
Near the end of 2011, Michael announced his return to Ohio with the 200th episode of the show. In March 2012, Michael did moved back and the show has remained in Ohio ever since.
Michael Riley was the main host of the show from 2007 through 2013. In 2013, Michael stepped down as regular host to become part of the regular host rotation. The regular host rotation has since been done away with, and Michael has returned to his regular duties as host, occasionally having someone else sub in for him while he participates as a regular.