"Murder, She Wrote" Thicker Than Water (TV Episode 1991) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Brother vs. Brother, Fisherman vs. Fisherman, and Other Altercations
WeatherViolet8 January 2010
Well, for those of us attempting to keep track of the number of "MSW" episodes featuring a widowed father possessive of his only daughter, and teenage boys who must become "the man of the house" to support their widowed mother, the number of feuding families, the number of diner restaurants in Cabot Cove, the number of Adele Metzger sightings, the names of Louis Herthum's characters, the number of missing bodies, and an overall body count, then we're in for quite a challenge this time around.

On a flight of a small airplane from New York City to Portland, Maine, a young adult male passenger approaches Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury) from across the aisle to request her autograph upon a page in one of her books, which he carries, under her "Dedicated to Sheriff Mort Metzger" tribute.

Jessica and "Wayne Stern" (Bruce Abbott) exchange pleasantries although he remains guarded and evasive about answering her questions about his purpose for traveling to Cabot Cove other than his expressing a decision to forge a new life.

Wayne had been incarcerated for a felony conviction back in New York City and has now served his time, so Cabot Cove might prove as ideal a community as any to begin with a fresh start, to which Jessica heartedly agrees and wishes him the best.

In Cabot Cove, fisherman Zach Franklin (Pat Hingle) faces several problems of his own. He and his business partner, Terry Montagne (Luke Askew), retain a mortgage on the fishing boat which they've purchased from Captain Ned Keller (Ted Markland) and can't seem to meet payments. Terry also conducts a feud with Zach's daughter over ownership of the vessel.

Elaine Franklin (Marjorie Monaghan) dedicates her all to assisting her widowed father, Zach, as his fishing partner, while he controls her life because nobody's good enough for his daughter. Elaine isn't afforded a beautiful wardrobe, as she spends most of her time aboard the small craft, but she adds nice touches to her appearance with a French braid and the natural makeup look, and has a pleasant tenor tone to her voice, as though she has really spent a great deal of time sailing the bay around Cabot Cove.

Upon her return from the Portland airport, Jessica arrives in Cabot Cove to check in at the sheriff's station, at which she discovers Sheriff Mort Metzger (Ron Masak) initiating an altercation with the newly-arriving Wayne "Stern." After Mort orders Wayne to leave town, Mort accompanies Jessica outdoors, she pondering his uncharacteristic short fuse before a visitor, and asks Mort if Wayne might, in reality, be his brother.

Mort is marveled that Jessica has figured this out in short order, and he explains his history with baby brother Wayne Metzger. Mort and Wayne's father passed when Mort was a teenager, and Mort had to take on odd jobs to support the family, which led him to a career in law enforcement, while Wayne fell in with the wrong crowd, which led to criminal charges after Wayne's company held up a storekeeper during an incident which cost Mort's police partner his life.

Jessica believes Wayne's determination to prove his valor and honor toward his brother, and so Mort decides to give Wayne one last chance provided that he doesn't cause another murder spree, by introducing Wayne to Zach and Elaine Franklin, causing Zach to dislike him immediately for eyeing his cherished daughter, but taking Wayne on as a boat hand after Elaine says her feelings toward him are professional.

Wayne witnesses an altercation between Zach and Terry Montagne aboard the vessel in dock and soon discovers a blood-stained carving knife amid a twine of rope, causing Mort to believe that Wayne has done it again even though the body hasn't been discovered.

After consulting with Doctor Seth Hazlitt (William Windom), Jessica convinces Mort to question other suspects, and together they ride around Cabot Cove, before they discover the body of a second victim. Mort is furious with himself for trusting Wayne and giving him an extra chance to prove himself, and so he has his Deputy (Louis Herthum) to lock up his brother.

That evening, while Mort reminisces over a photograph album in his living room, Adele Metzger (uncredited actress) projects the time of day from upstairs, asking if Mort plans to stay awake for very long, to which he answers that this won't take much longer. (This marks the closest point during the series for the audience to witness the existence of Adele Metzger, who is often discussed as long-winded and capable of handling herself, as an ex-Marine.)

But with Elaine's encouragement, Jessica considers the possibility that Wayne might not have committed either murder, so Mort releases him, while the investigators scrutinize the boat for hidden secrets, which leads to yet another dangerous altercation on deck, causing a heroic gesture by one brother to risk his life to try to save the other, for all of that bleeding is "Thicker Than Water."

The cast is rounded out by Kenny Davis as Fishman and Carol Gustafson as Waitress, in one of Cabot Cove's many, many diners. (Background music seems to increase in volume this season, thus distracting from the dialogue and message, and it's particularly noticeable this time around.)

This episode marks Louis Herthum's third "MSW" appearance, and his first in a five-season, 23-episode, run as Cabot Cove Deputy although he has yet to be named "Andy Broom," which comes along later in the season, after his next appearance with yet a different character name.

This also represents the second of two "MSW" appearances by Luke Askew, the first of three for Bruce Abbott, and the third of three "MSW" guest roles for Kenny Davis, and also for Pat Hingle, who has since passed, after acting in film and on television since 1954.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The return of the wayward brother
coltras3520 May 2022
Mort's shady younger brother is a chief suspect when a fisherman vanishes violently. What makes this entry interesting is the strained relationship between Sheriff Metzger and his wayward brother. The sheriff is obviously bitter about how his brother acted in the past, so it's no surprise that he doesn't believe him as innocent when he's accused of murder. Being a light murder mystery series, that's typical and expected - there's a nice shipping atmosphere and some good suspense.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
It's a great episode.
Sleepin_Dragon13 September 2023
Sheriff Metzger is perturbed when his brother Wayne arrives in Cabot Cove, someone that attracts trouble, the pair had been estranged for some time, but a kind hearted Mort gets his brother a job, it isn't look before Wayne is implicated in a murder.

It's one of those episodes I know virtually word for word, it's one I watch quite frequently, it is one of my favourites, it's a feast watch, it's fast paced, full of intrigue, and gives us a good look at one of Cabot Cove's most loved characters.

Bruce Abbott is excellent as Wayne, I did actually believe in the pair of them as feuding brothers.

I really like that New York is primarily used as the setting, but it's great to see Jessica back on home soil, great to see the regulars too.

I like that we learn more about The Sheriff too, we've gotten glimpses of his past, but this is the first time we get a detailed look at his character.

There are a few nice touches of humour, of course they come from Seth, who's a little cautious with his cash, and not keen to pay his parking fines.

9/10.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of the better ones.
planktonrules2 February 2023
When the story begins, Sheriff Metzger's ne'er do well brother, Wayne, shows up in Cabot Cove. When Wayne goes to see him, the Sheriff is cold and angry...as apparently Wayne is the family screwup and he'd spent time in prison because of it. Wayne insists he's changed...but Sheriff Metzger tells Wayne he doesn't want to have ANYONE know they are brothers. So, assuming a new identity, he gets a job working on a local fishing boat and appears to be doing well...until the ship's Captain disappears and is assumed dead. Naturally, the Sheriff once again assumes Wayne is responsible. Throughout the episode, Jessica is her usual sweet self and she believes in Wayne. Whether or not she's right...no, wait,...she's ALWAYS right.

I really liked this one. It also showed excellent continuity, as you know the Sheriff quit the police force in New York City and this helps explain why. It also was pretty enjoyable and well written...and is well worth seeing.

I really lik.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Tale of Two Brothers
TheLittleSongbird21 October 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

Even though the weakest Season 8 episode up to this very early point in the season, "Thicker than Water" is solid regardless. There are certainly more memorable 'Murder She Wrote' episodes, the mystery itself is a little on the bland side and plays second fiddle somewhat to the conflict between Mort and Wayne. While suitably subtle and nowhere near as dumb as the character of Floyd played by Will Nye that he replaces, Louis Herthum has little to do as Mort's new "right-hand man". And yeah, there are a couple of introduced details that is not easy at first getting your head round.

On the other, Mort getting some development is always appreciated, he always has been one of the show's better recurring characters but it is always nice when he has a situation where he is more interesting than usual. The conflict between him and Wayne has some nice tension and pathos, and Jessica's role in how it ends was really lovely in one of the later episodes where she is more likable rather than the too perfect or sanctimonious one she was sometimes in the later seasons. It is definitely more interesting than the mystery, which is competent enough but lacks spark.

Angela Lansbury is terrific as always. William Windom is reliably the charming curmudgeon that makes him a fan favourite. Ron Masak has settled in beautifully and has an easy presence and hard edge that makes him much more than a sheriff cliché that's too bumbling or too much of a pushover (he has never been any of those things).

For a latter season (relatively) younger cast guest star, younger cast members were wildly variable in later seasons (some good, some really bad), Bruce Abbott is pretty good and shares good chemistry with Masak. All the supporting cast are reliable with Pat Hingle standing out.

Production values are slick and stylish as ever. The music has energy and has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune. The writing is thoughtful, cosy and light-hearted while taking itself seriously as well.

In conclusion, a solid effort. 8/10 Bethany Cox
5 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed