"Murder, She Wrote" Shear Madness (TV Episode 1990) Poster

(TV Series)

(1990)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
One of the best of the season.
Sleepin_Dragon27 March 2021
Jessica's cousin is getting married, she's on hand for advice ... and murder.

A very enjoyable episode, the tone and story feel like that of seasons one and two. It's a clever story, which takes us back to an earlier murder, and gives us a few clues to solve a more current tragedy.

Makes a nice change for Jessica to be assisting a cousin, rather than a Niece. I like the set of characters here.

As a mystery it works well, you think you've worked it out, and find you're on the wrong path. Some well devised red herrings are here to throw you off the scent.

It's not a classic, but very good, 8/10.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Shears, murder and craziness
TheLittleSongbird9 October 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

"Shear Madness" may not be a high point of Season 6 or of 'Murder She Wrote', but it is nonetheless a good episode. It at times does descend a little too much into over-heated melodrama, like in the scene when the past murder is revealed and how it was done and written, and is a little too coincidence-heavy and reliant.

The mystery though does compel and has a lot of atmosphere. The identity of the murderer and the whole denouement (apart from the all too easy way the murderer is revealed, one of the biggest examples of the coincidences) is a surprise, with it pulling the rug from under the viewer after being surprised enough already by what the solution appeared to be at first.

Angela Lansbury cannot be faulted, and she has a strong supporting cast. While Robert Walker Jnr (especially his poignant and harrowing, if slightly melodramatic, acting in the past murder reveal), Barbara Babdock and Dennis Christopher make a positive impression, it's classy Shirley Jones who commands our attention.

Production values are slick and stylish. The music has energy and has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune. Apart from the moments of melodrama, the writing is thought-provoking and amiable, treating the subject with respect while not taking it too seriously mostly.

In summation, good episode but not a great one. 7/10 Bethany Cox
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Those Texas cousins
bkoganbing19 August 2017
Jessica Fletcher is in town for the wedding of cousin Shirley Jones to Sandy McPeak. Also there is Patrick Duffy another cousin who murdered her previous fiancé some 15 years earlier. He blacked out and has been in an asylum for years.

Now he's out and McPeak is murdered with the same kind of weapon in the same place as the original crime. Everyone thinks what they are supposed to think, except Angela Lansbury.

Of course the truth about the first crime is revealed under hypnosis in the same crime scene by prison psychiatrist Dennis Christopher. He usually plays some unhinged characters, nice to see him normal for once.

Learning about the first crime enables JB Fletcher to solve the more recent homicide.

As you would think it would.
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Shear madness
coltras3526 May 2022
Attending her cousin's wedding in Texas, Jessica finds more than the usual pre-nuptial jitters when the bridegroom is murdered. The bride's brother, who served 15 years for murder in a mental institution for killing her first husband, is under strong suspicion - but he has disappeared.

A suspenseful and engaging entry that benefits from a stirring performance by Robert Walker Jr; Jessica got a challenge in this one. She believes her cousin didn't kill his sister's bridegroom, but she has one helluva task to prove it. Love the word play of the title; of course, shears are used as a murder weapon.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Entertaining
rgxdzrybr19 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Jessica is to attend the wedding of a cousin played by Shirley Jones . Her brother has been getting psychiatric treatment for killing his sisters first husband. Shirley plays Ann and Doris Robert plays big sister Helen while Robert WalkerJr plays their younger brother who they raised. George is released just in time for Ann's new fiancé to be murdered. A little too convenient isn't it? It will take Jessica and George's doctor to set things right and get to the bottom of the first killing. Very entertaining episode. Some humor helps it from getting overly dramatic. There is an interesting element in that the episode is set in Texas in what appears to be one of the smaller cities and looks at bit like the old west when we get a glimpse of it. The accents are inconsistent. Ann and Helen don't have them neither does George. The city newspaper woman played by Barbara Babcock is dripping with one while her daughter has none and the sheriff's is rather toned down. Ann's fiancé is a local that's been in Alaska for over a decade and still has one. I guess they just left it to the actors.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Ways to Get Around those Awkward "I Do's"
WeatherViolet23 December 2009
Child star Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Theatre star Freyda Thomas, television actor Loren Blackwell, actress Yolanda Lloyd, and veteran film and television star Bryan O'Byrne are some of the performers each making his/her one "MSW" appearance in this episode, in which Doris Roberts, Shirley Jones and Robert Walker Jr. play siblings and Texas cousins of Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury).

The sisters have their hands full on the eve of a scheduled wedding when another body turns up in their basement, reminiscent of a similar stabbing fifteen years earlier, for which their brother, George Owens (Robert Walker Jr.) was considered the prime suspect and incarcerated in an institution for the criminally insane.

This time around, Fairville, Texas, sisters Ann Owens Arden (Shirley Jones) and Helen Owens (Doris Roberts) plan Ann's forthcoming marriage to fiancé Bill Spenser (Sandy McPeak), and invite their dear cousin Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury) to the festivities, a factor which sometimes indicates that another murder is soon to follow.

Reverend Simmons (Bryan O'Byrne) pays a visit to the residence shared by Helen and Ann, as Bill and Jessica also welcome him to rehearse for the ceremony.

When Fairville newspaper feature reporter Rosemary Taylor (Barbara Babcock) and her daughter, Meg Taylor (Linda Grovenor), the news photographer arrive, to obtain the scoop for the social event of the season, Jessica tells Meg that she appears familiar.

(This exchange may initially appear an inside joke, as Linda Grovenor has played Jessica's niece-in-danger in a previous episode, but the scene rather plays in conducive fashion with this episode's plot.)

(Shirley Jones also appears in an earlier episode as a dear old friend to Jessica, and Doris Roberts appears in a later episode as another such dear old friend, neither a cousin, as in this case.)

Festivities are soon interrupted by the returns of brother George Owens, who travels by bus to Fairville after his parole from the institution. The family receives him with open arms, laced with various ounces of caution, as George has no clear memory of the murder of Ann's former fiancé, Nathan Rollins (Loren Blackwell), a victim of a stabbing with garden shears.

After guests exodus the rehearsal reception, Jessica remains with her cousins, who suddenly realize that George is missing during a storm. Helen volunteers to search for him outdoors but misses his hiding behind the shrubbery near the porch, he later returning with a trail of blood.

The next morning, the wedding is interrupted when another body is discovered in the basement, near the refrigerator which Helen and Ann had installed after purchasing a new one for the kitchen. The murder weapon, once again, is found to be a blade of a pair of gardening clippers, thus indicating "Shear Madness."

Sheriff Barnes (William Lucking in his third of five "MSW" roles) and Policeman (Cody Glenn) put out an all points bulletin (APB) for the apprehension of George, whom they discover at the Owens' residence, which is marked by the arrival of eccentric Psychiatry practitioner Doctor Henry Carlson (Dennis Christopher), who insists that George has been nearing a break-through before all of this commotion has led to a relapse, and he adamantly maintains that George be given room for understanding.

Meanwhile, as Helen and Ann welcome Doctor Carlson's techniques to restore their brother's memory, Jessica maintains his innocence and investigates Fairville to prove it.

When Jessica visits the newspaper office to request archive reports of the fifteen-year-old case, she realizes the reason as to why Meg appears familiar although Rosemary insists upon shielding her daughter from scandal's way, or at least until Jessica discovers Meg's snooping around the Owens' basement with a camera, a fact which daughter and mother each deny.

Doctor Henry Carlson finally manages a breakthrough with George, as he focuses upon a shiny object, reminiscent of the day when he had last seen Nathan Rollins, and the "Shear Madness" of it all.

The cast is rounded out by Freyda Thomas as Coquette, Yolanda Lloyd as Caterer, Ann Marie Gillis as Mother on Bus, Joseph Gordon-Levitt as Boy #1, Ben Ryan Ganger as Boy #2, Daniel Bryan Cartwell as Bus Driver, and Jon Huffman as Hearty Male.

Bryan O'Byrne, acting since 1958, and Sandy McPeak, acting since 1976, and appearing in three "MSW" episodes, have unfortunately since passed.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Again, I am in TOTAL agreement with "planktonrules"
Somesweetkid28 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Whether or not she was directed to perform as this stereotypical Southern dimwit, Barbara Babcock's performance was SO badly performed that I had to either fast forward or mute her annoying voice whenever she was onscreen. I hated her portrayal. If not for her characterization, this would have been an entertaining episode.

Of course, you were meant to suspect Doris Roberts' character as the perpetrator early on after Robert Walker, Jr.'s amnesia-suffering "murderer" was just TOO obvious, so if you have watched past episodes to this point, you KNEW he was innocent of any past OR present murders.

In comparison to Columbo, I don't understand why so many actors went completely over the top in their portrayals on "Murder, She Wrote" - weren't these the same writers?
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A poor, poor episode.
planktonrules10 January 2023
The previous three episodes of "Murder, She Wrote" were episodes in which Angela Lansbury didn't star. Instead, she introduced the shows....and that was all. Generally, these are poor episodes and so I was thrilled to see she WAS in "Shear Madness". Sadly, my joy was short-lived....as it was a very badly written episode.

Jessica is visiting with relatives...which, of course, means someone's gonna die and some family member will be accused of the killing. In this case, her cousin George (Robert Walker Jr.) is accused of murder...and he'd also been sent to an insane asylum years before for another murder!

There are three big problems with this episode. First, the plot was lifted from both "Straight-Jacket" and "Psycho II". If you've seen them, you KNOW where the episode is going. Second, the show is full of psychological mumbo-jumbo and impossible to believe things...such as the hypnosis bit near the end. Third, Barbara Babcock's character is ridiculously acted...VERY broad and amateurish...which is odd since she was a competent actress. Overall, a very bad episode of a show I really like...normally.
1 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed