Medical practices in the ER are publicly criticised by Bethlehem West neurosurgeon Dr. David Delamere, resulting in Arch being investigated on a charge of manslaughter relating to the death of one of his patients. No longer able to emotionally let go from her patients, Macy quits and takes a job in a nursing home. Monsignor Duval, a representative from the Vatican, arrives to investigate a potential miracle for which Wayne, the atheist, is the principle witness. Wayne tries to avoid him while Marina tells Duval she's not sure if she believes in saints. Harry confronts Delamere about the accusations and accidentally blurts out he had an affair with Delamere's wife. Duval takes Wayne and Marina to meet the Catholic patient who was miraculously cured of cancer. Arch has a flashback about the patient Delamere accuses him of killing. When he wakes, the police are waiting to question him about the patient, Brendan Keys.